Does ED increase chances of admission in LACs? If deferred to RD, are you less competitive?

We don’t have data on the 10% or whatever it is international but I’d be shocked if it wasn’t a higher % of full pay than domestically. Your statements show you agree with me but you clearly have an emotional attachment to Pitzer, which is fine. I’m not making this statement specific to Pitzer but most every private, especially those need aware.

I looked at the CDS - 26 of 310 enrollees were intl so 8.4%. If I look at the school as a whole, 119 of 1,242 so a tad less. Interestingly, 26 of 60 acceptees enrolled per the 24/25 CDS, which is a much higher % than either in or out of state, so they are better bets.

I’m looking unemotionally. This is not a PItzer thing. Colleges that can’t find bodies are buying them, as some revenue is better than others. Colleges that can attract are full pay are bringing those in, in large part.

But this isn’t a Pitzer subject. It’s just OP mentioned PItzer and Pomona and I was noticing they are not the same, especially from an admission POV, other than sharing a larger footprint amongst the Claremont Colleges.

I was referencing Pitzer because that was OP’s question school and the school you referenced in the language I quoted. Since we agree on the facts but not the characterization, I think no more to discuss. No emotional involvement in this whatsoever. You likely misinterpreted my statements for something they are not. Thanks for the engagement. I hope you have a great rest of your Sunday.

3 Likes

I’m guessing OP mentioned Pomona and Pitzer, not because they are the same, but because lots of people in junior year consider two of the Claremonts (e.g., Pomona and Pitzer, Claremont and Scripps, etc.). And I agree, the two schools are different in many ways.

My interpretation, right or wrong, was that they grouped them as similar.

Pitzer is test blind, I’m sure in part because they are going to have heavy CA coverage and you have to play to the kids who apply to UC and CSU.

They have another thread (I didn’t know) - someone pointed out - and I hope they respond on that because they may be talking about a level of school, academically or cost wise, that they are not even in the game for…..

1 Like

Aren’t there differences in how schools handle non-admitted ED (or EA) applicants?

Some schools reject those whom they see as obvious rejects, so deferral indicates being a borderline applicant. But others defer all non-admitted early applicants, so deferral could mean borderline or obvious (to the school) reject.

Georgetown would be an example of the latter.

Yes, of course there are differences. But I see deferral as different than a wait list, which is more likely to be a rejection (but even that varies, of course). Often, with selective schools, deferred students have a slightly higher chance in the RD round than other RD applicants do, if only because they’ve already cleared one hurdle. I don’t know of any schools that defer all non-admitted applicants, though some defer quite a lot of them – the schools I’m familiar with that do this vary in selectivity but are usually larger universities, not LACs.

Georgetown says that: Early Action Program | Office of Undergraduate Admissions | Georgetown University

1 Like

The OP asked about ED (not EA).

2 Likes

Crazy as it sounds, there is an example of this. USC deferred all non-admitted Marshall students who applied ED. All USC schools (except those requiring an audition) will offer ED starting next year, and their recent communication says they will defer all students not admitted in an ‘early round.’

2 Likes

Let’s get back topic please. 100% deferral rates, EA, and, RU’s are amongst the many topics that the OP didn’t ask about

This is my suggested framework:

(A) If a school rejects you ED, it means they are confident they will be able to enroll the class they will want out of other ED and RD admits. If a school would not want you as an RD applicant, it isn’t likely they would want you as an ED applicant.

However, possibly in some cases, some colleges will waitlist or even reject certain RD applicants who they would want to enroll as students, but they think the chances of that applicant actually accepting an offer are too low to make it worth keeping an offer open for them. This is implicitly assuming that applicant will get other offers they prefer.

If you are a very strong candidate but it is actually not possible for you to get offers you would prefer, then you can prevent them from mistakenly doing this to you by applying ED. In that sense, applying EDing could “increase your chances”, but I think that is a potentially misleading way of putting it. It isn’t taking someone they wouldn’t want RD and turning them into someone they do want ED. It is taking someone they would want RD but would think they couldn’t get, and turning them into someone who is bound to stop considering anywhere else and instead accept their offer.

B) If your ED school defers you, it typically means they want to see the RD applicant pool before deciding whether or not to admit you. If that means they “lose” you to some other school, well, apparently they are willing to take that risk on the theory they could still get someone else they would like out of RD.

Some schools defer a lot of people and others relatively few, but that’s really just because deferral is essentialy costless for them, so the ones that defer relatively few are basically doing a favor to applicants who have no realistic chance of being admitted RD by giving them an earlier answer.

So I don’t think being deferred reduces your chances. But I think it does mean they think there is at least a pretty good chance they might prefer other people in RD. So that can obviously happen, that they end up preferring other people, even at schools which do not defer a lot of people.

Not necessarily change of focus, but the kid is most interested in CA as a location (we live on West Coast), but given that I think he would thrive at an LAC is getting me to explore options on the East Coast given the larger quantity of schools (some family is based in the NE). I’d like to do two trips (CA and East Coast) and am trying to navigate the dizzying amount of options. 3.9 Unweighted GPA, strong ECs, interested in science and pretty outdoorsy. No financial concerns (as of yet). We probably won’t do ED, just trying to understand how everything works.

Can you update on your other post please - 3.9 UW - but need to see the rigor or expected rigor in English, Science, Foreign Language, Math, and Social Science.

There are also strong LACs out west.

You note no financial concerns as of yet - but if you had a budget, list it - and we’ll find schools to meet.

But that’s on the other thread - where you haven’t yet respoded.

Thanks

At a school that defers few (rejecting the no-chance) applicants, that suggests that the deferred applicant is kind of borderline, with a real chance of admission (or rejection).

But at a school that defers all non-admits, the deferred applicant may be a borderline applicant or (more likely at highly selective schools) a no-chance applicant.

I think that is exactly right. And that could be relevant if, say, you are trying to decide whether to ED2 somewhere. If a ED1 (or REA, SCEA, etc.) college does not defer a high percentage of people, and you would still prefer that college to your possible ED2 college, it isn’t crazy to hold out, just apply to the second college RD, and see what happens. Obviously this is easier if you have other good options too, in case neither works out.

Unfortunately, if your first college defers a high percentage of applicants, you really aren’t getting much information to work with. That doesn’t mean you can’t make the same decision, but you are necessarily doing so with less insight.

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.