Does this seem like a logical list of colleges to apply to? (Balancing EDII vs RD schools)

Hi! I’m planning on applying to Brandeis EDII after realizing it’s the place for me (I just toured and students were protesting for fair pay for their librarians <3). But since I won’t find out if I’m in until February, I still have to apply to other colleges as if I’m not applying ED. I’m looking for colleges that have good polisci programs, good aid, are smaller in size, located in the NE area and not too far from internship opportunities, and are test optional. This is going to be long, but I’m a stressed senior so yannooo :slight_smile: Any of your thoughts are super appreciated!!

Colleges I’m currently thinking about:
American
Brandeis <3
Bryn Mawr
Holy Cross
Conn College
Dickinson
Mount Holyoke
Simmons
Smith
GW
Trinity
UMass
Wesleyan

Stats:
-GPA: 3.62 UW, ~3.97 W
-SAT/ACT: I’m planning to apply test-optional to all of these schools except Simmons and UMass bc my scores aren’t great
-APs: Lang (5), Micro (3), also took a PSY CC (A-)
-Senior Year Courses:

  • 1st Sem: AP Stats, APUSH, SWG CC, Internship
  • 2nd Sem: AP Lit, APUSH, GOV CC, AP French
    -Awards: Honor Roll, NHS, AMC12 Participant (not super impressive Ik)

ECs:
-Misc.:

  • Intern for politician (12 hrs/wk)
  • Spoke at well-known reproductive justice conference (also essay topic)
  • Lead local MFOL
  • Founded community gun violence non-profit
  • Interned at a national non-profit organization (15 hrs/wk)
  • Member of community climate justice group (2 years)
    -Clubs:
  • Co-leader of Democrats club (2 years)
  • Feminist club member (4 years)
    -Summer activities:
  • Volunteered for winning political campaign (60+ hrs/wk)
  • Intern at jewish farm combatting food insecurity (12 hrs/wk)

Other:
-Recs: APUSH and AP Stats teachers probably talk about political leadership (also club advisors), my counselor had us fill out a survey so it’s probably what I wrote there, also getting an additional rec from the politician who I intern for which should be very good
-Additional Info: I missed half of 10th grade on medical leave and some of 11th as well. I’m hoping this can help explain my GPA being on the weaker side bc I had to self-study for my classes then (lowest grade was a B).
-Strengths (imo): essay, ECs, additional rec letter
-Weaknesses (imo): financial aid, 2 internships on transcript (took a 2nd bc of app stress and now it’s causing more stress, how ironic)
-Hooks: first gen, technically URM

This is a list of 13 schools which does seem a bit excessive, especially if I do get accepted EDII to Brandeis and have to withdraw them. But on the other hand, if I don’t get in I’d like to have options so I can land somewhere I love equally. I’m practicularly worried bc Brandeis is the only school of schools I’ve toured and that I’ve liked (loved!!). What is the logical thing to do here? I love other people’s opinions so if you have any please lmk! :slight_smile:

Your list seems reach heavy. You need more matches, and you need a couple of safeties—what is the SAT/ACT score you are sending to Simmons and UMass (which campus? UMass-Amherst?)

Have you sent out any applications yet (whether to schools on this list or not)? Have you started on these apps, essays and supplements? If not, this is a lot of work to get done in the next couple of weeks.

A few more observations:

–What is your annual budget for college (what can you and your parents pay each year)?

–Have you demonstrated interest to the listed schools that value that? Check common data sets from each school to know this. American is really big on DI, and if you haven’t visited, signed up for emails, gone to local AO programs, I might consider striking that school from the list.

–What do you mean by ‘technically URM’?

@Mwfan1921 The culture of my school and city is basically that your worth is determined by how good of a school you go to (in years past we’ve had a wall of acceptance letters to elite schools) so I agree with you that this list is pretty reachy. I’ll either send a 1050 SAT or 21 ACT to Simmons and UMass Amherst (Ik it’s a reach but I could commute so that’d decrease costs, I could switch it out for Boston but the downside is the polisci program isn’t as good). Do you think I should add Hampshire back to my list as more of a match?
My common app essay is finished and I’ve started supplements. I realize it’s a lot of work but I’d like to put in work to end up somewhere I’ll be happy. (Also four of the schools listed don’t have supplements. Probably the only reason Wesleyan is still on that list bc I’m going to be rejected.)
So far I’ve applied to Suffolk and I’ll hear back in 4 days. Depending on how much aid I get, this will be my safety bc my budget is non-existent and their acceptance rate is ~84%.
I did go to an AU event in my area and get emails so that shouldn’t be a problem.
And a counselor suggested that due to my grandfather being native this might help me not get rejected for needing lots of aid. Seems weird to put this down to me but they used to be an admissions officer.

Do not let where you go to school define you, or determine your self-worth.

Do you mean Native American? If you are an enrolled tribal member, there are scholarships you may qualify for.

If you can not afford it, it is not a safety. It’s good you will know in 4 days.

Regarding financing your college education:

Have you filed FAFSA? What is your family’s EFC?

Have you run the NPCs on the college websites? If not, you should do that ASAP. What number does Suffolk’s NPC give you?

You should only apply to schools that will be affordable per the NPC, that may help you cull your list. You probably will not qualify for merit scholarships at the schools on your list, but do your research.

Does anyone have suggestions for safety schools (in terms of both acceptance and aid)?

With the exception of Simmons and UMass (if it isn’t the flagship) your list is all reaches. You really need to pick one or two of those (I think American fits the bill), add Simmons and a MA state school, find four other matches and a couple of safeties. There is no safety on that list.

I don’t know what schools are test optional but here are some matches: Providence College, St. Michaels, UVM, Wheaton, UNE, Emmanuel, Becker.

Take a good look at UMass Boston who just recently added dorms to the campus, is directly on the red line with easy access to downtown Boston.

Good luck, you have some work to do here.

I think your safeties are probably Framingham State, UMass Dartmouth, MCLA…the non flagship state schools.

You’ve worked hard and done well! Be proud of that! That will serve you well going forward. Being positive, Being forward-looking, being authentic to yourself, being resilient, and working hard (and having some fun) are infinitely more important to creating a life you love than your college’s ranking.

Good luck with Brandeis! I really like Smith and Mount Holyoke for you based on your comments about Brandeis. Conn Coll too. Holy Cross has a great, great political science program and claims to meet full financial need.

I love Dickinson, really one of my favorites. I consider it one of the best choices for Poli Sci students. Based on your comments, it might be too small of a community for you, and maybe not so activist as you’d want. But I can’t say for sure.

How about Hampshire as well? It seems like it would be a good fit, and Hampshire, Smith, Mount Holyoke, Amherst, and U Mass Amherst make up the Five College Consortium.

I’d also think about Skidmore, which, fortunately or unfortunately, has gotten much more competitive in recent years.

I’d also suggest you visit the website for Colleges That Change Lives. Certainly some of these would be good fits and attainable in terms of admission.

I would like to add one out-of-the-box suggestion: Berea College. It’s a work college with no tuition. It has outstanding academics. It’s out of your region. You may have too many resources to be considered. You’d want to apply very soon. But maybe give the website a ten-minute look to see if it is at all desirable.

The financial side is important. For lots of these schools, including the CTCL, there’s a high sticker price, lots of students get generous aid, but there is still a substantial cost. Go through your list and run the net price calculator (NPC) to see what numbers you get. Research some of the suggestions you get here; if a few look good run the NPC. That would probably help you eliminate some of the schools on your list. Do not go by me, but I’d imagine GWU and AU would not be affordable. Again, double-check that on the NPC.

And it can be a stressful process. Maybe try to refocus your thinking on it though. Take it as a journey, your journey. You’re learning about lots of interesting places. You’re getting an opportunity to think about yourself and what works for you: what kind of place is a good fit, what do you want to do, who makes you your best person. There can be disappointments, certainly. AND in the end, you’ll very probably end up in a place that works for you and where you’ll meet great friends. Trust that, and it can seem more an adventure than a stress. Good luck!

American University is test optional and for political science would be an ideal location. They are also a needs meet school.