Duke ED or Northwestern ED

These are my two top schools: Duke then Northwestern

1510 SAT
class rank: 1/231
ACT 31

this is where the problem comes in…
subject test scores are really bad
Math I 740
Math 2 730
US History 660 (got a 5 on the ap exam but bombed the subject test for some reason)

Duke is my first choice, but Northwestern is a close second. With my subject test scores, I dont know if it is even worth applying to Duke ED – Northwestern doesn’t require or even recommend subject tests, so I could just send my SAT there.

Besides tests and grades, I have some decent extra curriculars with 4 leadership positions, and my essay is really good (at least I think…)

Does anyone have any advice – should I go for Duke even though my subject tests suck? or would I have a much better shot at Northwestern?