@coffeeat3 While I don’t disagree that HS counselors are most knowledgeable about the profiles of previous applicants, they can’t predict how Admissions will play out in any given year, especially when ED’s considered. For example, only another student and I were admitted to Brown this year out of multiple applicants (both of us were unhooked, applied ED, though I was deferred; and I’m only choosing Brown b/c it’s the only school for which I have knowledge of most of the students admitted this year,) from my high school, though 5 other students were admitted to HYPSM----it’s more important that you match what the school’s looking for (such as Brown and the Open Curriculum or Columbia and its Core) and at least 10-20 others going to Penn, Cornell, Berkeley, NU, USC etc. Selective college admissions are unpredictable at the best of times, and in the current admissions cycle with many T20s seeing high gap year percentages, again, I would recommend OP choose the school that they fit better at.
I am going to go against the grain and recommend that you not apply to any school that is not your clear and obvious choice ED. Why not apply to both of them without binding yourself to either of them?
I think private schools like to diversify their overall application list, so I think it’s a possibility that they don’t want too many students applying to the same schools. If the students apply to a lot of the same schools then it’s less likely everyone will have an acceptance to an elite school.
They have slightly higher GPAs, but you have a legacy boost. Does it count for much in the RD round or only during the ED round? As long as you have a safety or two, apply where you want. If Duke is your first choice, then apply there ED. If Cornell is your first choice, then use your ED there.
I’m with @Dis3456. Neither. Have you visited and toured both schools? Why exactly do YOU love Duke and/or Cornell? Not your parents, grandparents, or GC. I always thought ED was for the one school that was beloved above all others. If you’re full-pay for either school I would think that would be a bigger boost than legacy or geographic diversity.
I don’t know how schools are ranked for marine biology but Cornell doesn’t pop into my head. I would think UMiami, schools in Florida, CA, or Texas. I remember when we were in the Keys one of the seal trainers at a local aquatic zoo was from Texas A&M. I think she was a marine bio major.
Because ED provides a leg up in admissions, and OP would presumably rather have a decent shot of getting into at least one of the two than run a very good chance of being rejected at both.
Most high-achieving students can flourish wherever they’re planted. I have always been deeply skeptical of the popular notion that your ED choice has to be a college you place on a pedestal above all others. Rather, I think it simply needs to be a place you’re 100% sure you’d like to attend. Columbia ED/Chicago EA was a very popular combination for years, for instance, because many students adored both schools and would be content to attend either.
There’s no better place for graduate studies in oceanography except MIT-WHOI and UCSD-Scripps, but I don’t think URI is worth the out-of-state tuition when OP has excellent in-state options like UF, FSU, and the New College of Florida.
I don’t know OP’s financial situation, though, so YMMV.
U Miami and Eckerd have possibly the best undergraduate programs in marine science in the country, but Cornell is no slouch. In any case, undergraduates interested in marine biology should focus on getting a broad foundation in the sciences (including CS and programming), and Cornell is much stronger in the sciences as well as organismal biology in particular.
Additionally, virtually all of Cornell’s programs are extremely strong, which is nice if OP decides marine biology is not for him/her after all. That is not the case for, say, Texas A&M-Galveston or UNC Wilmington.
First of all, you’re the one applying and going to college, not the college counselor! From every post above it sounds like you want to apply ED to Duke, not Cornell. While you may be happy at Cornell, you really want to apply ED to Duke. You do NOT want to have regrets and wonder what if. Cornell is not a freebie either. It IS an Ivy league afterall.
If it makes you feel any better, I know someone who got waitlisted at Cornell but got into Duke. Also, comparing yourself to a 4.6 and a 4.9 GPA is not significant. It’s everything else that you have going on. You mentioned your out of school activities. Has your cc seen all of those? What about your essays? If you’re not submitting a test score, then everything else you have will be considered a lot more significantly. What about your letter of recs. Maybe you’re more likeable than those people. Also, maybe you’re applying for a different major. It’s not black and white. Just because someone has better grades doesn’t mean they are the ones that get in above you.
I don’t know if legacy matters for Duke, but if it does that will definitely give you an edge over the other candidates. The cc would know this too. Maybe cc wants you out of the way so the other candidates have a better shot at Duke than you? Just saying. Cornell legacy means a lot.
Listen to your gut, not the cc. Also, consider why you’re not submitting a score and make sure that doesn’t backfire on you. 3/4 of all high school seniors have taken the ACT. I know colleges say not submitting won’t hurt you, however, when they know that 3/4 of seniors have taken the ACT, and they get a lot that don’t submit that are high achievers, then that’s got to factor into their decision making somehow. Also, for whomever said being from Florida would mean something at Cornell. That person is wrong. There are a surprisingly number of Floridians at Cornell. Don’t bank on that helping you.
Good luck in whatever you decide! But if you’re going to shoot for a huge reach, this is absolutely the year to do it!
This may sound silly but if the two schools are equal to eachother in worth to you then do this:
Assign heads and tails of a coin to both schools
flip the coin
Based on the results of the coin, take note on how you feel. Are you secretly happy that you got that result or are you secretly sad? Did you secretly want one side to win over the other? Then that’s your choice!
If you have no specific bias as explained above, then follow the coin.
Sounds silly, but it helps people I know find out what schools they subconsciously preferred. GL!
Does your school have Naviance? If so, even without a score, where do you fall for ED and regular admissions to these 2? I ask because you might be able to figure out if it looks like you’d have a shot at Cornell regular decision. Then, you’d feel better about your Duke ED.
Honestly, no one knows how schools will handle TO candidates who they said would be at no disadvantage applying TO. But, I don’t think a CGO would lead you astray. On the other hand, they aren’t psychics. Who knows what will happen?
Our S goes to a school where we already know of 3 Duke EDs just from our kids’ small circle, one is an URM, another has tons of leadership, but we told our S to ED there if that’s really his top choice. (That’s still a question because, as you’ve learned, there is no perfect school).
Life is full of uncertainty. Welcome to it. I’d bet you’ll love wherever you land. Good luck!
I think the triple legacy could counteract the few points between you and your peers. Sounds like Duke is really where you’d like to apply ED.
If it doesn’t pan out, will you feel like you gave it your best shot or that you wasted your ED app?
You should apply to the school you are most interested in attending, and you should convey what it is about the school that makes it your top choice and what you have to offer that shows it is a good match. Our DD ignored her college counselor’s advice and ended up at Harvard. If it was up to him, she wouldn’t have applied to several of the top schools she applied to including Harvard and got in. College counselors have experience to impart but I think sometimes they forget that for each student, it is more than just another college but you are looking for THE college.
I think that this is really a philosophical question/point. Most schools, especially when you are talking about the upper tier, are unique. They aren’t fungible. While most high-achieving students can flourish anywhere, it doesn’t mean that some schools are not better fits for the aforementioned students. I have a high-achieving daughter, and if there wasn’t a clear choice for her top school, she would not apply anywhere ED. My personal opinion is that it would be better to take the extra time and decide which school is truly a better fit and make the decision when the time comes. Duke and Cornell are very different schools so if the OP cannot decide which school is better for applying ED, I think that he would benefit from taking the time to figure it out. I do not think that the “ease” of getting in ED outweighs the negatives of not making an informed decision.
When we visited Duke 4 years ago (things can change), they were very clear that the legacy boost was only available for ED. They said that the legacy advantage should only be for kids who really want to go there, and applying ED was their way of knowing that you really want Duke.
Duke, because it’s your dream school and because it weighs legacy very heavily. And because no kid from So Fla in their right mind should ever move to Freaking Ithaca, even if the best school in the world was there. Don’t do it. As plan B do consider ED 2; take a look at Bowdoin, really really really. New College also sounds great if UM too close to home. Really high PhD production for its size. Sounds like you might go to Pine Crest… they like to boast re Cornell placement and the other elite school in S Fla does not weigh GPA… but yuck Ithaca… plus see recent story re S Fla freshman who died there last year allegedly due to binge frat drinking.
“Not sure that college counselors in elite private schools are as helpful as tends to be asserted on CC”
Very few, if any, college counselor in a public hs will have knowledge of who else is applying where to give that kind of advice the OP is getting. Their caseload is too large to even begin digging for that kind of info. It’s an older book but the Gatekeepers shows the clout private c/c have with elite colleges.
Anyway for the OP’s question, I’d definitely apply to Duke ED, seems that’s OP’s first choice but the CC brings up Cornell, probably for some of the reasons discussed in this thread.
“Binge frat drinking” would be an issue for a student prone to binge drinking who joins a fraternity where that is encouraged, regardless of what college.
Cornell and Duke have similar percentages of men who join fraternities (32% and 29% respectively).