True. There is binge drinking at every school and drugs too. You have to want to say no to it. Doesn’t matter if it’s Cornell, Duke, or some other random school. It is everywhere, sadly.
So you have set this conversation up as:
'should I go against my GC or should I got against my parents and Grandparents
…because I don’t have a strong view either way’.
Time to buck up and think for yourself. You are the one who is going to live there for 4 years.
You could do that by setting both aside for a minute and looking up lists of ‘if you like school x here are similar schools’ for each, and see which list appeals to you more- then go back and look at your pros/cons for each of the original schools. See anything that stands out?
Or, you could do that by thinking about / looking more deeply into the overall personalities of Duke and Cornell. B/c ime they are seriously different, and if you really don’t have a preference you probably don’t really know enough about them.
ps, your GC could be gently nudging you b/c she knows who else from your class is applying to each place, and she reckons your odds are better at one than the other. She could also be gently nudging you b/d she knows you well enough to think you are likely land more happily at one than the other. Or it could be completely unrelated to you. Or you could be completely misreading her. No way to tell from here, but in general, GCs -esp at private schools!- are looking for an outcome that will leave the student & their parents happy.
You have a way better chance at getting into cornell. Go for cornell.
If you have no preference then it really sounds like ED is not the choice for you at either school. ED is for kids that have a school they are dying to go to so far above any other school. Not for kids that have no preference at all.
These two schools are night and day. Duke is tiny. Cornell is huge. Duke you’ll get nice weather, Cornell you will get snow and cold and isolation as well as it is hard to get to. Duke is in the research triangle. Cornell has many more majors and schools to choose from than Duke. Literally night and day. I know people who got into Duke but not Cornell. I know people who got into Cornell and W/L at Duke. This year is a crazy year so no one know.
But in all seriousness, as someone above said, you and only you need to decide where you want to be. You’re going to college, not your parents or grandparents or even your GC who doesn’t quite seem to have your best interests at heart, but more like her track record at heart. Also, top students at schools generally know where each other is applying. I know my kid knew who else was applying ED to the same schools and didn’t care. 3 kids applied ED to the same school. About 11 applied ED to Vanderbilt that year and 5 or 6 got in, and more got in during RD. Worry about yourself. You’re not competing with others.
You also need to look at your major, and if the school is good for that major. My daughter decided against applying to Duke altogether because they don’t have a strong program for what she wanted.
Again put yourself first.
I went to Duke. One of my kids goes to Duke. Duke and Cornell are peer institutions and the selectivity is pretty much the same. I’d go with the school you feel more comfortable with. Can’t go wrong with either. As is the case with all of the selective schools, even very fine students who would succeed at a school can’t count on getting in. Competition is stiff and the schools are building classes. They are trying to find the right mix of geography, talent (think dancers, musicians, artists, scientists, etc), socio-economics, first generation, international, race and gender, athletes, legacies, and on and on. You can’t predict how this will play out because the applicant pool can vary year to year.
Apply to Cornell. Your CC knows the landscape of your cohort and given the option of a 1A and 1B, is steering you to your 1B because there is stronger competition from your own classmates applying to Duke. If you can really flip a coin and don’t distinguish between the two, apply to Cornell.
What did you end up doing? Best wishes to you either way!