Engineering Mechanics w/Aero [at UWisconsin], thoughts vs. other departments?

S25 accepted into Engineering Mechanics and intends to pursue the Aerospace option.

Thoughts on the Engineering Mechanics department?

  • Comparing to the other engineering departments at Wisconsin?
  • Faculty
  • Curriculum?
  • Research opportunities?
  • Job prospects (planns to pursue an advanced degree and go into the space industry / NASA)?

He loves the theoretical and the practical, which is why this major seemed like a good fit since Wisconsin doesn’t have Aerospace. He’s a current NASA intern and love research and projects.

Thanks for any advice and comments!

2 Likes

Congrats to him! Glad one of our kids got it!

1 Like

I’ve no doubt yours is going to soar wherever they go!

It’s an ABET accredited school for MechE. It will be fine.

One needn’t study aero to work for Nasa or any aero organization.

1 Like

And he could also pursue aerospace in graduate school.

We’d just like to know specifics on the program. Wisconsin itself is a highly-rated program.

You can go to any ABET accredited school and end up at NASA or other aero companies. UAH, as an example, and Florida Tech are surrounded by them. Florida Tech has many at Cape Canaveral and Huntsville is NASA’s second city.

Wisconsin is fine and perhaps the student won’t go to grad school. He’s 17/18. Engineering has a 50% drop out/change major rate.

Wisconsin is fine. It will give you similar benefit as many other schools. Rank in this area is to sell magazines, short of a few schools. They’ll work with kids from schools like Michigan to W Michigan. Purdue to Akron etc.

But Wisconsin, if you can afford it, is a very good choice.

And a tough admit. Congrats and best of luck.

1 Like

Sorry thought I posted this.

1 Like

Actually, from our research it looks like Engineering Mechanics sets him up well for research and graduate programs. He’s a thinker and loves theorizing, as much as building.

Every engineering student is set up well for research and grad school. I think you’re over thinking this.

Wisconsin is a solid school, one of many - and for people who think research is only for a select few - not true. Only a select few seek it. They send out notices regularly to all kids and/or you can ask for research involvement from a prof who is doing research of interest.

If you told me you were going to Wisconsin or Wyoming, Michigan State or Minnesota, Arizona or Auburn, the answer would be the same.

You have a fine acceptance - if that’s the school he likes.

If he liked another or you couldn’t afford it and you needed a cheaper, you’d find similar opportunities elsewhere too.

It’s a great admit - so best of luck.

Appreciate all the feedback? Applied engineering is not my field, nor my wife’s, so this is all new to us.

So far, we’re deciding between Ohio State (in-state), Penn State, and Wisconsin while waiting on UIUC, Maryland, and Virginia Tech. Some schools have definite advantages, as in support structures that’ll help him (Scholar’s programs, LLCs, disability support, etc.). That’s high on our priority list.

Thanks again for your advice!

That’s great - especially given you have guardrails - find “that” school - all these names are great but all may not be great for your student!! You have to find that one.

Yes, US News will tell you UIUC is highest ranked but kids from all these schools will work together, at the same salaries but that’s not what should be most important to you. Sounds like you have much more important concerns!!

Best of luck.

1 Like

You’ve been awesome throughout this process. I’ve also seen you help others as well. Thank you!

1 Like

Do professionals at his internship have ideas? I’d ask them.

My nephew went to CU-Boulder, well known for aero, and he was in mechanical. I’m not sure he ever took an aero class, but got a job a Northrup and has done well there. Recruiters know the engineering schools and the quality of the overall program, and know they can give any more training that is needed.

2 Likes

My son from Bama was a MechE and works for an Aero as a manufacturing engineer - so more IE.

One is definitely not pigeonholed by the discipline they study and of course just because a company’s product is in an area - they still need all functions.

And then you hear 75% of educated engineers aren’t engineers in their careeer.

1 Like

Wisconsin has progression requirements including college GPA substantially higher than 2.0 to stay in the major: Progression - College of Engineering - University of Wisconsin-Madison

Think of that as equivalent to secondary admission to major like at Penn State, Virginia Tech, and Ohio State (although college GPA requirements may differ and other criteria may be added at some schools).

2 Likes

Thanks for sharing, we weren’t aware of this.

This does contrast with the minimum GPA requirements with Aerospace, which he intends to study at other schools. Many of those departments require 3.0-3.2 min.

I guess Wisconsin chooses a different way to evaluate the student?

In the end, most jobs will require at least a 3.0 for consideration.

Some 2.8 and some higher - but 3.0 is the bar.

And 50% end up dropping the major - so the truth is, if you’re not meeting that bar, you’re likely not going to finish anyway.

So I’m not sure the progression type things or minimums to advance are that big a deal. You want that 3.0 so your employment odds are greater.

If it was required to get a certain major you desired that was over impacted, that could be different.

Engineering is a brutal major overall.

1 Like

Makes perfect sense to me, thanks for all the information, all!

With my wife and I coming from technology and medicine, we get the challenge and expectations. We believe that won’t be an insurmountable challenge for him, as he’s used to academic rigor… enough that he should be able to adjust to the difficult demands of engineering. He has the passion, but you have to truly love it to make it through.

1 Like