Entitled, Elitist Students? U Wisconsin (Madison) vs. Syracuse vs. Tulane vs. U Delaware vs. USC

This is great. From @jym626 thread post 273 (refers to another thread):

Entitlement (“preppy”) Index for 50 “Top” (according to USNWR) National Private Universities

First number represents percentage of enrolled students who came from private schools. Second number represents percentage of enrolled students who receive no need-based financial aid from the institution. Tie-breaker is the second number. Numbers taken from most recent edition of Princeton Review:

  1. Georgetown 53/59 112
  2. Notre Dame 50/60 110
  3. Yale 47/60 107
  4. Vanderbilt 40/62 102
  5. Tufts 43/59 102
  6. Univ. of Penn 43/58 101
  7. Johns Hopkins 40/60 100
  8. Brown 40/60 100
  9. Princeton 45/54 99
  10. Duke 34/64 98
  11. Boston College 40/58 98
  12. Emory 35/62 97
  13. Washington U. 39/55 94
  14. Dartmouth 38/53 91
  15. USC 39/51 90
  16. Georgia Tech 18/71 88
  17. Harvard 35/52 87
  18. Northwestern 27/56 83
  19. Stanford 28/54 82
  20. Brandeis 30/52 82
  21. Lehigh 31/46 77
  22. NYU 31/44 75
  23. Case-Western 30/45 75
  24. Univ. Chicago 30/44 74
  25. CalTech 19/43 62
  26. MIT 28/28 56
  27. RPI 21/29 50

Modified Entitlement Index (Reflecting Pell Grant Shares) for 50 Top Private National Universities:

  1. Notre Dame 102
  2. Georgetown 101
  3. Yale 97
  4. Vanderbilt 92
  5. Princeton 92
  6. Tufts 92
  7. Penn 91
  8. Johns Hopkins 90
  9. Brown 90
  10. Duke 88
  11. Boston College 87
  12. Washington U. 86
  13. Emory 82
  14. Dartmouth 80
  15. Harvard 80
  16. George Tech 74
  17. Northwestern 73
  18. Stanford 70
  19. Brandeis 68
  20. USC 66
  21. Lehigh 64
  22. Case-Western 61
  23. Univ. Chicago 61
  24. NYU 57
  25. CalTech 47
  26. MIT 44
  27. RPI 31

Thread: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-life/11033-rich-kid-schools-p4.html

LACs. Same thread, http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-life/11033-rich-kid-schools-p4.html

Post 56 by @mini

ENTITLEMENT INDEX AMONG 50 “TOP” (according to USNWR) LIBERAL ARTS COLLEGES

The first number represents the percentage of students who were admitted from private schools. The second number represents the percentage of students who do not receive need-based financial aid from the institution. The final number is the “Entitlement” (“preppy”) Index score. Numbers are taken from the most recent Princeton Review.

  1. Davidson 52/67 119
  2. Washington and Lee 40/73 113
  3. Trinity 57/53 119
  4. Bates 48/60 108
  5. Middlebury 45/60 105
  6. Kenyon 46/59 105
  7. Williams 46/58 104
  8. Univ. of the South 48/55 103
  9. Connecticut 48/54 102
  10. Colby 40/60 100
  11. Skidmore 40/58 98
  12. Bowdoin 43/55 98
  13. Furman 39/57 96
  14. Haverford 39/57 96
  15. Amherst 44/52 96
  16. Wesleyan 44/52 96
  17. Barnard 47/48 95
  18. Swarthmore 40/51 91
  19. Pomona 40/49 89
  20. Whitman 30/58 88
  21. Scripps 37/51 88
  22. Franklin & Marshall 34/53 87
  23. Colgate 30/56 86
  24. Colorado 30/55 85
  25. Dickinson 38/47 85
  26. Sarah Lawrence 31/51 82
  27. Hamilton 40/42 82
  28. Vassar 34/47 81
  29. Wellesley 37/43 80
  30. Denison 30/49 79
  31. Lafayette 32/46 76
  32. Oberlin 34/42 76
  33. Bryn Mawr 38/38 76
  34. Bucknell 26/49 75
  35. Union 27/48 75
  36. Gettysburg 30/44 74
  37. Claremont-McKenna 27/44 71
  38. Carleton 25/45 71
  39. Smith 26/44 70
  40. Occidental 30/39 69
  41. Bard 30/38 68
  42. Mount Holyoke 38/30 68
  43. Agnes Scott 30/36 66
  44. Harvey Mudd 20/45 65
  45. Macalester 34/31 65
  46. Depauw 17/42 59
  47. Centre 21/36 57
  48. Grinnell 13/40 53
  49. Wabash 8/30 38

Incomplete data from Holy Cross and Rhodes. Tie-breaker is percentage of students who do not received need-based aid.

If you’ve visited a lot of these campuses, you’d likely not find many surprises in this data. The only clear generalizations to be made are that, on the whole, midwestern schools do not seem attractive to private school students (or they simply aren’t accepted – which I find unlikely), and southern schools (with the exception of Agnes Scott) offer (or need to offer) significantly less than average in terms of need-based aid. One caveat that must be attached to the data is that some schools (some that I know of for sure are Bard, Mount Holyoke, Smith, and Macalester) offer merit-based aid to significant portions of their entering class (as much as 10%) – some of those students, upon receiving the merit aid award, no longer qualify for need-based aid, and hence wouldn’t appear in this picture.

This data picture as always is incomplete. While it reflects “entitlement” on the campus as above, it does not reflect the impact on campus feel of low-income students. A school could offer lots of rather small “need-based” grants to attract students away from the competition, without really changing the make up or feel of the campus. (Macalester has a reputation for doing this – whether it is just or not, I have no idea.) One way to correct for that is to subtract the percentage of students on Pell Grants (with family incomes below 35% of the national average) from the total. All of a sudden, the extremes become more extreme, and the picture (I believe) more clear.

Numbers Represent the “Entitlement” Index minus Pell Grant Shares:

  1. Davidson 119-6 113
  2. Washington and Lee 113-3 110
  3. Trinity 119-13 106
  4. Bates 108-9 99
  5. Middlebury 105-8 97
  6. Kenyon 105-8 97
  7. Williams 104-9 95
  8. Colby 100-7 93
  9. Connecticut 102-11 91
  10. Univ. of the South 103-13 90
  11. Bowdoin 98-10 88
  12. Furman 96-9 87
  13. Skidmore 98-13 85
  14. Haverford 96-13 83
  15. Wesleyan 96-14 82
  16. Amherst 96-16 80
  17. Whitman 88-9 79
  18. Swarthmore 91-13 78
  19. Franklin & Marshall 87-9 78
  20. Barnard 95-18 77
  21. Pomona 89-12 77
  22. Colgate 86-10 76
  23. Scripps 88-14 74
  24. Dickinson 85-12 73
  25. Sarah Lawrence 82-12 70
  26. Vassar 81-12 69
  27. Colorado 85-17 68
  28. Lafayette 76-8 68
  29. Hamilton 82-15 67
  30. Denison 79-12 67
  31. Wellesley 80-16 64
  32. Bucknell 75-12 63
  33. Gettysburg 74-12 62
  34. Bryn Mawr 76-15 61
  35. Carleton 71-10 61
  36. Union 75-15 60
  37. Oberlin 76-17 59
  38. Claremont-McKenna 71-15 56
  39. Harvey Mudd 65-12 53
  40. Macalester 65-15 50
  41. Bard 68-20 48
  42. Mount Holyoke 68-21 47
  43. Depauw 59-13 46
  44. Smith 70-24 46
  45. Occidental 69-27 42
  46. Agnes Scott 66-26 40
  47. Grinnell 53-13 40
  48. Centre 57-18 39
  49. Wabash 38-19 19

^Not at all sure what it is about subtracting Pell grant recipients that would cause the percent of students from private secondary schools to shoot up to 119%?

Before anybody freaks out over these lists, remember they reflect data from 2002-2003.

Yes, these are old threads and old lists, but they are a hoot!!

Yes! And I am not doing the work but wouldn’t be surprised if things haven’t changed all that much…

Any time someone is paying $70k per year, there are going to be ‘entitled’ students. I don’t know where they hide them at Wisconsin, but I’m sure they are there.

I was very surprised to learn after graduating from college how wealthy some of my sorority sisters really were. It was pretty easy to figure out that a few had more money than most as they had cars and didn’t work, got to travel over spring break, etc., but it turns out a few were REALLY wealthy. Miss Porter’s School for Girls wealthy. Coal Baron wealthy. My-dad-owns-a-patent-on-ball-bearings-used-on-all-Fords wealthy. It didn’t change much.

THIS. ^
I was thinking exactly this but this poster worded it better than I could. OP- don’t you have one at WSUTL? Is that school too “preppy”? Are the students “entitled” or “elitist”? The truth is, you will find all kinds wherever. And some of the wealthiest students can be some of the most down to earth. When one of my S’s attended one of the schools on your list, one of his best friends, who was as low key and down to earth as you can imagine, turned out to come from a very wealthy family. No one would have known. She did not reflect it in the least.

Those schools are not dripping with hoity toity bluebloods. Your kid will be fine at any of them. And if not, it may require an attitude adjustment.

From the NY times article mentioned on page 1.

38 colleges had more students from the top 1 percent than the bottom 60 percent

STUDENTS FROM THE TOP 1% ($630K+) BOTTOM 60% (<$65K)

  1. Washington University in St. Louis 21.7 6.1
  2. Colorado College 24.2 10.5
  3. Washington and Lee University 19.1 8.4
  4. Colby College 20.4 11.1
  5. Trinity College (Conn.) 26.2 14.3
  6. Bucknell University 20.4 12.2
  7. Colgate University 22.6 13.6
  8. Kenyon College 19.8 12.2
  9. Middlebury College 22.8 14.2
  10. Tufts University 18.6 11.8

These estimates are for the 1991 cohort (approximately the class of 2013). Rankings are shown for colleges with at least 200 students in this cohort, sorted here by the ratio between the two income groups.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/01/18/upshot/some-colleges-have-more-students-from-the-top-1-percent-than-the-bottom-60.html

I’m also sure there are entitled students at UW-Madison, but no one should be paying $70K per year. Estimated COA for in-state students, 2018-19 academic year, is $26,000. Estimated COA for out-of-state studnets, 2018-19 academic year, is $53,000.

My S is a freshman at one of those schools. He has a beater hand-me-down car that is almost as old as him. I warned him there will be others at school with $70K+ cars. I told him to wear it proud and if someone gives him crap, say “why would I drive anything nice in this pothole ridden city?”

Based on our experience visiting several of the schools you included in your title, we did not perceive them as being full of entitled students (did not visit USC). You might be trying to narrow down schools so that you don’t have to visit all of them but I would suggest visiting as many as you can once you narrow down - most of the preconceived notions we had about schools were found to be untrue once we visited. We expected Syracuse to be pretty homogenous and were pleasantly surpised to see that it was quite diverse and didn’t live up to the stereotypes that we had heard.

If you are trying to find down-to-earth students, you won’t have to look real hard to find better options than USC, Syracuse, & Tulane.

I find it so strange this glorification of anything and everything as long as it isnt: majority, successful, and wealthy in college these days.

Success, hardwork, has somehow become a negative thing though we want our kids to go to college to achieve those exact things: engineers, doctors, lawyers, cs majors, etc.

Seems convuluted I dont get it.

One can be humble, down to earth, unpretentious, etc…and still be wealthy, smart, hardworking, successful, top school, etc.

Success etc is not a negative… it’s the attitude portrayed by some that is a negative.

OP you will find all kinds of students at the schools you mentioned.

@twogirls I couldn’t agree with you more. It is absolutely not the wealth I have a problem with. It’s the entitled, stuck up, snobby attitude that unfortunately some have. If you have nice things, that’s great. Just be humble about it and not act like you’re entitled and above everyone else. That’s the attitude I am looking to avoid. If one of the schools I originally mentioned has a lot of students who have that type of entitled attitude, that’s what I’d love to know so we can try and avoid or at least know what we’re getting into.

Have you visited these schools?

Just entering the thread … please define entitled and elitist.

However, wealth of a student while in college is usually parental wealth, rather wealth earned by the student.

It is not a negative. But an oversized sense of entitlement that some (not all) successful people and their dependents or heirs have can be.

“One can be humble, down to earth, unpretentious, etc…and still be wealthy, smart, hardworking, successful, top school, etc.”

So you’re saying it’s ok to be wealthy, you just can’t show it, or you have to somehow humbly drive a Mercedes?