You can be wealthy, hard working, and successful… and…
I am saying you can drive a Mercedes or live in an expensive home… and still teach your kids that they can’t get a new phone “just because.” These wealthy friends… highly paid professionals…teach their kids that they can’t get that new phone… unless they earn some money …somehow… to put towards it. These wealthy friends… despite their wealth… do not want to raise entitled kids. Do you want new shoes? Better use that coupon and look for a good sale. Are you bored? How about baking cookies, selling them at dad’s office, and donating the $20 to xx organization. They also don’t treat people differently depending on their wealth or “status.” The kids of these friends attend very good, and expensive schools… and continue to give back to the community on a regular basis. They also have economically diverse college friends.
I also have wealthy acquaintances/ex-friends …who give their kids unlimited use of their credit cards, and who allow them to buy $300 shoes and $1200 watches in HS… for no reason…just because they can. These ex-friends… when they introduce you to one of their friends… will say “this is my friend Sam…he is an esteemed lawyer (true story).” Their daughter will actually get mad if her HS or college friends don’t have $500 to blow on New Years Eve… or money to go to Europe.
Another group of wealthy acquaintances … not friends…will always mention to you that their tie costs $600 ( I had no idea that ties can cost $600). Or that they just shopped at ( insert expensive store name) and bought each girl a $400 pocketbook. Again… True story. Oh… and one of their kids thanked her father… on social media… for his money.
All three families are wealthy ( I am not, btw). I think the OP is looking for the first.
There have been some changes. As examples, in 2002-2003, Vassar, Williams, Wellesley and Amherst’s ‘entitlement’ scores put them in the middle of the pack, but by 2017, the NYTimes ranked them as some of the most economically diverse colleges in the US.
The only freshman I know who just went off to Syracuse is entitled and spoiled.
The only freshman I know who just went off to U of Delaware is definitely elite but he is there on a lot of merit money (although he could be full pay) and he has a lot of good qualities as a person.
Syracuse has 22,000 students. That enough to qualify as a large town. It’s similar to the populations of Kingston and Plattsburgh, two actual large towns also in NYS. Is Kingston more elitist than Plattsburgh or is it the other way around? Or are both elitist? Or neither? I don’t see how anyone could know. I think your best option is to visit the schools your daughter is interested in to see if they’re right for her.
Wisconsin is not considered elitist. Beer guzzling partiers? Maybe, though I know plenty of kids who go there that don’t fit that mold, either. It’s such a big school that you can pretty well find what you want there, whether it be elitist(defined as persons who eat imported rather than doemstic cheese), studious, jock, or what have you.
I mostly agree with you, @57special, except that I’d define elitist at Wisconsin as students who eat only Wisconsin-produced cheeses that have won World Cheese awards, U.S. Championship Cheese awards, or American Cheese Society awards. Some of us here are local-cheese snobs.
I tend to think the view of others being elitist or entitled is often more an issue with the one viewing them that way, often fueled by insecurity, jealousy or just unfamiliarity with wealthy and/or successful individuals.
I think the OP’s child should visit…if possible. Sit in the dining hall… walk the campus… talk to students, etc. This is how she will begin to determine if these particular schools are for her.
You’d be hard-pressed to find a group of more fun-loving and friendly students, on the whole, than you’ll find at UW-Madison. With about 40,000 students you’re bound to encounter all kinds – even some jerks, snobs, hermits – but in terms of overall cooperation and felicity, UW would be hard to beat.
I’m confused about the usefulness of a list that is so outdated, given changes in FA in the past 15 years. Even if it was current, the assumption that private high school always equals privilege is troubling to me. I know for Notre Dame, @ 2/3 of that “private school” number are Catholic schools. The same may be true for Georgetown and BC. If you know anything about Catholic elem/high schools, there are many (possibly most) that are among the most racially and socio-economically diverse out there. I wonder if the same is true for charter schools, which also fall under the “private” umbrella? Private high school does not necessarily equate with privileged.
Even if you buy into the stereotype that rich person = elitism, you will find people like that at all types of schools. My daughter grew up in a town that is affluent with little diversity. But she went to the regional Catholic high school, which is VERY diverse racially, culturally and socio-economically. She learned very quickly that many people could not afford to do the things that the kids in our town took for granted. She was friends with a kid who lived in a hotel room with his dad. Another friend in whose culture it was typical to keep chickens in their back yard. Other friends who taught her about their experiences with racism. Basically kids she would barely, if ever, have encountered in our public school. If I think about who was more “elitist” going into college, my D or her friends in our public school (who spent their years with kids very like themselves, and worrying about having the latest Tory Burch bag) – I can guarantee you it wasn’t my D. And none of those other friends attended any of the colleges on the above list. Most of them went to OOS public Us.
There are all types of private high schools and all types of public high schools. Both produce down to earth kids, both produce snobs, etc. Most of that stuff is primarily formed/taught in the home anyway, no matter your personal situation.
We toured UDel this summer and did not get any kind of snobby/elitist feel from the large group of students visiting or any of the tour guides. From what I know of WI as an East Coaster living in the midwest, Midwest nice is truly a thing. WI the state is gorgeous too. S19 says both have large party reps.
The feel at Miami/OH and RPI were very different. I know they were not on your list but using as a comparison for schools we also visited.
I stumbled onto this thread and had to laugh. My daughter is currently deciding between UW Madison and U Delaware. She is from Illinois. I think Madison is her top choice but it is just so darn expensive so we will have to wait to see what the financial package is. That being said, I found there to be somewhat of an elitist attitude surrounding that school, but not from the students. Their engineering program is very competitive and felt a little cutthroat to me. And the campus wasn’t even remotely diverse. Out of 10 tour guides on the engineering tour, all 10 came from Wisconsin. We will tour Delaware in a few weeks. I’m curious to see what it’s like. It’s by far the cheapest option for our family so far so we are hopeful.