Essay Topic Help

Over the last few weeks, I have been brain storming a list of essay topics for admissions and I have finally narrowred it down to two. 1.) Being mixed (I’m half black, half white) 2.) Having an impulse control disorder called excoriation (it’s a skin picking disorder) that is considerably rare . It was just added into the The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders in 2013). Which topic do you think would be more interesting from a reader’s standpoint? Both are very personal matters and they are both very important pieces of who I am. Thanks for your help!

I would say not #2. It might be memorable but not for the right reasons.

I agree with @Falcon1.

If you write about topic #2, you are basically saying to a college, “If you admit me, you will be mandated by law to provide mental health services to me for the next four years.” One of the highest add-on costs at any college these days is health care, so writing about your impulse control disorder is going to give an Admissions Office pause. They will have to weigh how much they want you vs. and how much it will cost them to provide additional services for you. Yes, Admissions is not supposed to think that way, but AO’s are human, and it’s difficult to ignore when a student raises such a red flag by writing an essay about their mental health issue(s) which they may not have overcome, or if overcome, might return when they are on campus. I would strongly counsel you to write about ANY other topic!

^^ Well said!

I hope you can write really well if that’s all you can think of. Nix #2, I’m sorry it must be said, there is an ick factor there as well as the more important things already said. Basically there is no way I can see that you can say that is the most attractive feature you bring to the college community. It kind of falls into the TMI category along with a host of disorders mild and otherwise that aren’t the most compelling thing about you (I’m sure.) So to make that the thing you want to present makes one pause.

And I don’t at all mean to belittle your experience, of course it is unique to you, but if you go with #1, please try to surprise the reader and not write the obvious or cliche thing. If the obvious thing are your own personal experience, then come at it with a fresh approach, a different angle or just make it super personal. A kid with autism spectrum disorder once sent me a really good short essay and it was so good because he allowed the reader to understand what was going on in his head and how things seemed to him, put very simply and it also showed a turning point where he decided to take control of how he presented himself and related to people. It was very simple and very effective because it demonstrated so much about him, his self awareness, communication skills, his wanting to interact with others that use the resources for similar students, and his desire to essentially live as a change agent.

Like all essay topics, this one has built-in traps.

The first trap captures anyone who can’t tell the difference between an essay and a story, so they write a rambling bunch of incoherent biography.

The second trap catches applicants with boundless egos; they write about how they are the most awesome athletes or dancers or how they single-handedly rescued the starving Nigerian children or produced a YouTube video with 100K views.

The third trap is to come off needy, as if we are defined by our circumstances when in fact define ourselves by the way that we respond to our circumstances.

Obviously, you haven’t explained either of your topics in great detail, so I don’t know if any of this applies to you. But Post #5 of a thread called Essay Topic Help seems a useful place to remind readers of this.

Wait I’m confused. The deadline has passed ages ago… @zairia13

@Zairia13‌ I don’t like either of those topics. I feel like there are issues of greater importance to write about. I’m not saying that being interracial or having a skin condition is not significant. It might come across as if you are writing a biography about yourself. I just think that it’s better to write about something intellectual or creative about you. I wrote my 2 Harvard essays about why I love learning French and why I love to read.

^^ Good point. Applicants often forget that colleges are academic institutions, and as such, Admissions seem to gravitate toward student’s who have a passion for self-directed learning.

What I don’t get is why either of those topics would tell me more about you except to say that you have some perceived disadvantage, so “pick me”. Seriously, you are applying to Harvard - think of what you need to tell them on your own.