I agree it is not necessarily because of any deep similarity… people who are not very familiar with the schools (like people out here on the west coast) have a tendency to confuse WPI, RPI, and RIT simply because the acronyms seem similar.
3 Likes
St. John’s College (Annapolis, MD or Santa Fe, NM) has a great books curriculum. It’s the old University of Chicago curriculum.
St. Olaf’s has a foundations course, Great Conversations, I think.
Reed has a strong intellectual vibe.
You can Google “schools with residential colleges” and get a list. I think St. Andrew’s in Scotland has “houses”. Lots of schools have living-learning communities.
I’m not sure what specific thing you are thinking about for the other categories. Other than being fairly selective, not sure what distinct qualities are sought.
2 Likes
RIT/WPI have overlapping liberal builder culture for STEM kids… RPI is, to a great extent, too though more theory-based classes probably. (MIT has a similar overlap). Also all have SUPER nerdy clubs. model trains, ham radio, lots of cos-play and robots, and extra-nerdy frats. There are overlapping subcultures.
Northeastern/RIT/Stevens (and to an extent WPI) has the coop - pre-pro overlapping sub-cultures. I know less about Purdue/Rose… But Rose clearly has the same size vibe and a builder culture no?… Our kids ruled out in geography and more conservative/neutral schools. Mine seems very builder-y too, like WPI/RIT.. Purdue is probably outlier due to sports, but i suspect a huge subset of kids who would thrive at RIT/Stevens/Mines too.
Flagships, you are right is due to solid stem programs, but lots of kids hide in engineering 
3 Likes
Perhaps stating the obvious…but many of the Jesuit schools have similar traits including (but not limited to): being mid-size universities, urban locations, having little or no Greek Life, and a large humanities core.
9 Likes
I am not sure those are entirely unrelated, though. Like, I do think what I call “powerhouse” undergraduate engineering schools (this is basically about a combination of student population, devoted resources, and relative variety of more specialized programs even at the undergrad level) tend to have some cultural similarities. Possibly differences too, of course, but overlaps in ways they wouldn’t necessarily have to the same degree with the typical student mix in undergrad business schools, undergrad Arts & Sciences schools, or so on. (Edit: see also other poster articulating this in more detail.)
Of course sometimes there are large undergraduate engineering schools as one of many undergraduate programs at the same institution, and I think kids can reasonably cross-shop those with the more purely tech-focused institutions.
But even then, some kids might particularly like it when the whole undergrad program is more tech-focused. And those are the kids who might well put together lists dominated by such institutions, even if they then have more nuanced reasons for preferring some more than others.
1 Like
I’m always struck by how with the possible exception of the core part (and maybe not even that), that is a rather popular wish list in certain circles. I’d add being highly networked in areas like business, law, and politics.
Hence I find myself recommending Jesuit colleges to quite a few people who seem stuck finding alternatives to the secular private universities they are considering, but which might be a little less selective.
5 Likes
I think it’s hard for me to see putting a school like Purdue (~43,000 undergrads) with a cohort of small schools like WPI and Rose. I guess RIT is a bit bigger (I just looked it up … around 20,000). I think once you start considering big flagship engineering programs, I think there’s going to be a lot more similarities in vibe between a Purdue and other excellent engineering schools at those flagships than with the small nerdy schools? But I have not really visited or investigated Purdue, so maybe there’s something in missing about this.
2 Likes
Never set foot on the place, but always felt there was something nerdy about the name. Like, it’s one letter removed from the chicken company 
4 Likes
So Purdue ultimately graduates around 2400 people with their primary degree in engineering per year. That is in fact a lot. I think TAMU may be the only engineering college regularly with more, and then usually not much more.
Most of the other really large engineering programs are also at publics. I believe there are only six or so privates that regularly graduate more than 500 engineers–Northeastern, WPI, RPI, RIT, Drexel, and Cornell. Even schools like MIT or CMU are typically more in the 300s, although they may add some more secondary majors.
Still, how much that matters in terms of subjective experience is an open question. Like individual classes can only be so big. You can actually only be acquaintances with so many other people, meaningful relationships with even fewer, actual friendships fewer than that. There is actually a pretty good scientific basis to believe that at 500 or so people in just your own engineering year, you have already passed the limit where more students in your undergrad program are just going to be adding more strangers, not more relationhips.
So, you can make of this what you will, but I tend to think it may not matter that much exactly how big your engineering program is, once it is this big. Distinct from a program where, say, there may be 100 people or less in your year? Sure. But will it really make a material difference if it is 2500 or 1500 or 500 per year? Maybe not so much.
My Purdue grad had 180 in her chemical engineering major. This was her cohort for three years. She had classes ranging from 10 -80 people (after intro classes freshman year)with most classes being around 25. Her honors cohort was also quite small.
When my daughter was thinking about overlap she was more focused on the approach rather than overall school size. She had plenty of smaller schools that had the same teaching approach as Purdue and felt similar. She recently told me that if she hadn’t been accepted at Purdue, RPI would have been her second choice.
2 Likes
Not true. According to each school’s career center, about 100 seniors a year find their way into what may broadly be described as Finance and Consulting jobs. TBH, I think there may be more than a correlation between the number who go into that sort of work and the size of Amherst and Wesleyan’s respective football, wrestling, soccer, lacrosse and perhaps even field hockey rosters.
4 Likes
Both are similar in another way: engineering students start as undeclared engineering, and must go through secondary admission to get into specific majors.
Other schools that do this include NCSU, VT, Minnesota, Ohio State, Penn State. Wisconsin is effectively similar in this respect, with GPA thresholds higher than 2.0 to stay in engineering majors.
2 Likes
agree Purdue is an outlier there -and honestly didn’t realize it was THAT big # of undergrads thought it was like ~25k undergrads (I should have looked up, apologies!)…at some level I am not ~15-25k undergrads matters (though 5K - 25k does) I suspect 40+ does though..
Though some students really do care about different things. Mine didn’t care one bit about city vs. suburban locations…. some care a lot. Mine really didn’t mind much about sizes either and had a big range (though not up to 40K though not sure there ARE any with 40K in geography we were looking ha!). The looked at clubs, vibes, and the feeling/culture of school. My older really had a sense if faculty and staff really seemed to care about students at open houses and admitted students, and that was their north star. (ended up at RIT where the department head was at the Sat admitted student day and held a sign w/department name and led kids (like a parade) to the department building across campus and was with them all day going to sample classes, answering questions, helping with A/V when it broke ;). That spoke to them that all departments had faculty doing this, not students or grad students… And this isn’t a tiny school, as you pointed out…
But I do agree, purdue can fall off my list:)
1 Like
Oberlin - St. Olaf - Lawrence U
College/conservatory model (or at least a very strong music program), liberal arts, residential campuses (most students live on campus all four years), Midwestern
3 Likes
This thread is so interesting. My S27 is considering EDing to Richmond. Average strong student, good rigor, top 25-30% of his class (estimate, school does not rank).
Goes to a preppy New England day school where about 30% of the class are recruited for college athletics (he is not) so he is used to that vibe and is not particularly bothered by it. Interested in greek life, but not in the hard core greek environment of SEC schools, and not having greek life is not a deal-breaker. He loves the Richmond campus, loves that it is a quick direct flight from Boston. Does not want an urban campus, but likes that it is near a city. Feels that it is collaborative rather than competitive. Likes that you can enter undecided and as long as you do well in a couple of pre-reqs, you can enter the business school, but he is also interested in history, global studies, econ.
He rises to the occasion when surrounded by driven students and hangs in a really nice group of kids that are academically driven, but also make time for fun (typical work hard/play hard). He is bright and driven, but not particularly academicky, if that makes sense. Will want to join club sports but is not a “lax bro”. Would like to watch school athletics, so some degree of rah-rah would be preferred.
Would prefer a student body size in the 3k-15k range.
Likes Bucknell (high target, low reach) and Elon (likely/target) but Richmond (reach) checks more boxes. Did not love Lehigh’s campus or vibe when we toured (felt a little less inviting, somehow). Liked the Holy Cross campus, but it is too close to home and he is not a fan of Worcester. Same goes for Providence.
Other schools you might suggest? We have two friends whose kids transferred out of Wake due to a brutal rush season (did not get bids and then both struggled socially), so he is not interested in looking there. He feels the vibe is too exclusive.
Has Santa Clara and University of San Diego (the smaller, catholic private school) on the list, but my gut tells me he won’t go all the way to CA. Looking for a few additional Target schools.
1 Like
U of Denver? It falls in the size target, has a business school, has D1 sports (but no football), smaller Greek life, is urban (and in a nice part of the city), easy to get to from Boston. DU has a big international studies department.
4 Likes
Small Liberal Arts colleges where there is also a good size (more than 400 students) school of engineering:
Bucknell
Lafayette
Manhattan
Ohio Northern
Union
Sorry. I was making a list for the larger thread topic and didn’t notice that someone had asked a question. 
1 Like
In addition to Elon University, have you looked at Davidson College? It is about 1/2 hour from Charlotte, NC.
2 Likes
I actually think Richmond has done a nice job carving out a niche for itself even in the world of LACs, which are basically all some form of niche school. So it is not surprising close substitutes are not easily materializing.
But I might suggest checking out Trinity University in San Antonio, which I will admit I have never seen in person (unlike Richmond), but on paper seems to be doing some similar things (not least because it has also been doing quite well in terms of accumulating financial resources).
From what I can tell online, it seems to have a sort of similar relationship to San Antonio in terms of setting as Richmond–not in a very dense area itself, but not far from the downtown area. Looks like Delta has a daily nonstop from Boston.
I know nothing about admissions options after first-year admissions, but this write up of the business program seems promising to me:
They also have a specific BA in Business option for people who want to double major in something outside of Business:
Generally I feel like things I am hearing about Trinity these days are pretty similar to things I heard about Richmond before my S24 took a look. So in terms of colleges that could be seen as trying to follow a similar model, that might be worth further investigating.
I actually have another child at DU.
He is having a great experience. But he is more outdoorsy than S27. S27 will apply, but he doesn’t really see himself there. We like the school a lot.
1 Like