Extra Essay - How Beneficial?

<p>I’m working on completing my common app+supplement so that I can hurry up and submit my additional materials, and I noticed that there’s an additional essay on the supplement that you can write. However, since my most “outstanding” experience in my life - my homestay in Japan - is the subject of my Common App essay, I’m not particularly sure what I would write about that would be worth the time of the admissions board. Is this fairly crucial to making a good impression?</p>

<p>For reference, stats:</p>

<p>2280 SAT (750 Reading, 800 Math, 730 Writing)
SAT IIs: 770 Literature, 770 Chemistry, 790 Lit
4.222 GPA (4.0 unweighted)
AP Scores: 5s in Chemistry, USH, Calculus AB, English 11
Letters of Rec: AP Chem teacher and AP English teacher, both will write me as great of letters as possible.
National Merit Semifinalist.</p>

<p>Senior schedule - AP Bio, AP Eng 12, AP Euro, Calc BC, AP Japanese IV (ind. study), (regular) Physics.</p>

<p>Extracurriculurs:</p>

<p>FIRST Robotics Competition - Software Subteam Leader
Boy Scouts - Eagle Scout rank
Varsity Swimming (9th-10th grade)
Japanese freelance translator (one video game completed, another in progress)
2010 Summer - Member of a sister city delegation to Japan
Helped run and keep together my local Catholic youth group while the new administration was breaking it up (until it fell apart during 10th grade)</p>

<p>It’ll boost your chances, but I’m not sure if it’s beneficial for you. Your stats is not competitive enough for Harvard. But I guess it’s worth a try?</p>

<p>You are competitive for admittance to Harvard. I saw a 2400/36 valedictorian with awesome EC’s get rejected, and a 1920/30 with great EC’s and dedication get in.</p>

<p>Go for the essay if it can show them a new side of yourself. Harvard, as you know, is nearly impossible to get into. (Key word: nearly)</p>

<p>Keep your head up, and keep on pushing. Hope for the best, prepare for the worst. I wish you much luck. I, too, am an applicant to Harvard.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Don’t be ridiculous. 2280/770+SATIIs/4.0UW is definitely competitive. I’ve seen people with lower stats - even unhooked ORMs - get in. Don’t get me wrong: I’m not suggesting that the OP is a shoo-in, I’m just saying that he’s well within the range of accepted students stats-wise.</p>

<p>Your stats are highly competitive. I wouldn’t write an extra essay; if true passion doesn’t shine through, you’re just going to annoy your admissions officer. As the supplement indicates, the essay is fully optional.</p>

<p>I always have the mindset that essays are a chance to attach a voice to your application. It’s basically the one thing you can control right now (since GPA, ECs, etc are pretty much set in stone). I’d personally jump at the opportunity to write another essay, but it doesn’t sound like you have the same mindset, lol. If you don’t have anything to write about, don’t try to force it.</p>

<p>At Pomona the admissions officer said, “We have an optional essay, but it’s not really “optional” if you know what I mean. If the kid doesn’t take the time to fill out the optional essay, we figure he’s not really as committed to Pomona.”</p>

<p>Yeah…</p>

<p>Okay, so…looks like I’ll write one.</p>

<p>What do you think would be a stronger essay? Discussing FIRST Robotics - the leadership skills it’s taught me, the way I’ve bonded and made fast friends through a shared interest in engineering, and the passion it inspired in me for higher achievement and learning? Talking about my experience in Japanese - my freelance translation activities specifically, since that’s the biggest thing I have on my resume that no one else does? My Catholic youth group and keeping it together? </p>

<p>(My common app essay is ~670 words and is about my summer trip to Japan and the bonds I formed with my host family, quite emotional and excellent if I might be allowed a moment of self-pride. Speaking of, if a school has a 500 word essay limit like Yale, should I not bother applying since I don’t want to compromise my essay by shortening it? It’s been edited extensively)</p>

<p>Thanks so much for your input, and glad to know that “You’re not good enough for Harvard” wasn’t actually true.</p>