Fiberbed vs Featherbed?

<p>I want to step beyond the simple egg crate and get either. However, i’m not sure which one is better. Obviously one is made of feathers and more expensive and one of polyester fill and thus cheaper, but which is comfier? More suitable for a college student? Worth the money? I have a notion that the fiberbed will feel “crunchy” and stiff, not soft and cushioning and won’t want me to spend all of my days in bed. However, the featherbed seems expensive and apperently they wear out quickly. Any suggestions?</p>

<p>PS- for a bit of background: I’ve always slept on a plain, quilted mattress pad and have always hated it. I dealt with the egg crate, but want a bit more “squishy”-ness and overall softness/comfort of the bed.</p>

<p>I think I may be one of the original instigators of the fiberbed. DH and I sleep on a fiberbed, we have had it for 2 years. I think it is very comfy for the money, particularly if you like a soft bed. The feeling is one of soft cushioning, but with underlying support, not sagging. It has held up fairly well, it does bunch up some over time - I take it completely off the bed about once a month and shake it hard to rearrange and smooth out the fiberfill, then replace. I smooth it out each week when the sheets are changed. Every few months, I leave it off the bed for a week to air out, and in the hottest months last year I took it off the bed for about a month - we live in the deep South and our bedroom is unusually hot, you do sink into the fiberbed a bit and it was cooler sleeping on the flat mattress.</p>

<p>I’ve never slept on a featherbed, so I can’t compare. This may not matter to you as a college student, but I rarely wake up with a backache now, I used to have them fairly frequently, but the morning back pain went away after a couple of weeks on the fiberbed.</p>

<p>I got myself a fiberbed today for school (after seeing cangel’s other post…had no idea that mattress pads weren’t as squishy as I hoped) and it’s not crunchy at all. I think that if you get the fiberbeds that are filled with down alternative, they’ll be just as soft as the real deal but without the feathers poking out.</p>

<p>After looking around, I realized that there is down, down alternative, and plain and simple fiber filling. Looks like I’ll be going with the down alternative I think, because it will still remain hypoallergenic (woo for someone like me who when spring time hits, wants to run away and live under the sea), yet still comfy. I found a great 3" at JCPenny online, so I think it wins!</p>

<p>I prefer fiberbeds just like i prefer cotton pillows to down pillows. I had a featherbebd a while back, but i didn’t l ike it because I had to constantly ‘fluff’ it. If I didn’t fluff it often, all of the feathers would accumulate near the edge resulting in a ‘flat’ spot where I slept. I guess if you like a down pillow you might like a featherbed.</p>

<p>I’d put in a vote for the memory-foam mattress toppers. I love them—and our guest bed has been praised by everyone who has slept on it. Oldest D doesn’t like squishy–at all–so she’s not signed up, but the rest of us in the house swear by them. Ultimate dream sleep, says me. We got ours at Costco, but they’re available most places – starting at about $125, I think, for twin size.</p>

<p>I’m going to Boston College and they won’t allow you to have an egg crate mattress pad. so i would check first and see if any type of foam is ok. i think their rationale is that it is highly flammable & toxic. so i bought a fiberbed, the biggest one i could find! no matter what, it will feel better than just sleeping on the cheap mattress.</p>

<p>I’m allowed egg crate as long as it doesn’t extend beyond the bed (which I guess could happen if you didn’t have sheets, but who would do that?).
Memory foam just seems so expensive, but a friend suggested to buy a king size on overstock.com, and share with a roommate. So, can you cut memory foam in half? Because if so, i’d sooo much rather do that, then cut it shorter to fit a twin bed later on. That ($30) and a fiberbed (60) still seems really cheap, but amazing.</p>

<p>What thickness of memory foam topper are you all talking about? I have the Tempurpedic mattress and I love it, but I think a mattress topper would have to be pretty thick - at least 2"-3" - for it to make any difference.</p>

<p>About Down and Feather Bedding </p>

<p>Many top of the line bedding companies use down feathers as the main filling inside of their pillows and comforters. We have grown so familiar with the word “down” that we rarely think to ask ourselves what it means. What is down? Where does it come from and how it is produced on an industrial level? These are questions that you may have never asked before. The following is a brief description of where down comes from, how it is processed and its pros and cons.</p>

<p>What is down? Down feathers come from ducks and geese, and is under plumage taken mainly from the breast region of the bird.</p>

<p>How does one get the feathers? Down harvesting was originally a byproduct of the meat industry. With the exception of Hungarian geese, birds were killed for meat and the plumage plucked off and processed. Now, demand for down feather products has created a separate, and incredibly cruel industry in which birds are, in some regions, raised specifically to stuff bedding. Feathers are ripped from living birds, then allowed to grow back 4 to 5 times before slaughter.</p>

<p>This is from PETA: "Geese and Ducks Suffer for Down Down is the soft layer of feathers closest to birds’ skin, primarily in the chest region. These feathers are highly valued because they do not have quills. Most products labeled “down” contain a combination of these underfeathers and other feathers or fillers. While most down and feathers are removed from birds during slaughter, geese from breeding flocks and those raised for meat and foie gras may be live-plucked. In countries where this cruel practice continues, up to 5 ounces of feathers and down are pulled from each bird every six weeks from the time that they are 10 weeks old until they are up to 4 years old.(1) </p>

<p>Plucking geese causes them considerable pain and distress. One study of chickens’ heart rates and behaviors determined that “feather removal is likely to be painful to the bird(s),” and another study found that the blood glucose level of some geese nearly doubled (a symptom of severe stress) during plucking.(2,3) </p>

<p>Eider ducks are a protected species, but their feathers are sought out for bedding and clothing. The females lay eggs and surround them with feathers plucked from their own breasts. Farmers in Iceland gather more than 6,500 pounds of Eider duck feathers each year.(4) By taking these feathers, farmers are removing important insulation that the eggs need to hatch. It takes feathers from at least 80 nests to fill just one comforter."
Who are the main producers? The majority of the world’s down is supplied by the Far East. China, with often drastically different humane standards, is by far the leading producer of down for the last 20 years. China not only supplies raw down, but also processes and manufactures finished products of comforters and pillows. </p>

<p>Europe, North and South America and even the Caribbean are all producers of down as well. Europe has a reputation for high quality goose down mostly coming from Eastern Europe in Poland and Hungary.</p>

<p>Bird Lifespans: The older the birds, the bigger the size of down clusters. </p>

<p>The minimum life span is now only two weeks. Therefore, the quality of down has decreased over the years. The highest quality down comes from certain parts of Europe where geese are reared in colder climates and allowed to live longer lifespans.</p>

<p>Processing: Converting wet, plucked, smelly plumage into a fluffy, warm, soft material is a complex process. Down is first washed thoroughly because it is very smelly. This stage can deteriorate feathers if processors are not careful. Then feathers are dried using special equipment. </p>

<p>All feathers are then hand sorted. Sorting begins by separating each piece into categories of down, down fiber, down feathers, feathers. Dust is removed continually throughout many of these processes. Finally, the different qualities of downs are blended to get the desired final products.</p>

<p>Washing Down: It is well known that down’s main “down” fall is its poor performance once it gets wet. Down can lose up to 90% of its isolative qualities when soaked through. Many people either cover their comforters with a duvet cover or take them to the dry cleaners who use a chemical cleaning solution. (One can find specialty dry cleaners these days that use biodegradable and non-toxic chemical washes.)</p>

<p>Hypollergenic or not? Many down brands advertise their products as being hypo-allergenic. This is achieved by extensive washing…sometimes up to 15 washes…to remove the dust and odor. Down product is then “ozonated,” a safe process that further removes impurities. Then it is treated with an FDA approved chemical called an “anti-microbial treatment” that basically kills anything else that is remaining alive. </p>

<p>(However, the FDA has approved over 2000 food additives that are all known carcinogens, so we must heed caution on this point.) </p>

<p>When the down bedding arrives packaged on the shelf it definitely is a hypo-allergenic product, but once it is brought home and used, it will eventually revert back to harboring dust mites unless bedding is thrown out and replaced frequently.</p>

<p>How does Wool Bedding Compare? Wool is comparable in terms of warmth, and can even be warmer than down, depending on the amount of fill, and energetically is very cozy and inviting. Even better, organically raised and sheared sheep do not suffer, nor are they killed, for their wool. Wool is naturally non-allergenic, naturally resists dust mites, moisture, mold and mildew, and is naturally flame resistant. </p>

<p>In contrast, down absorbs and holds moisture; and provides the perfect environment for growth and reproduction of dust mites, unless put through extensive washing and treated with anti-microbial chemicals. </p>

<p>Unlike birds who suffer in the down harvesting process, sheep grow a coat of wool annually and are sheared without harming anyone. When you support products that use wool you support small rural American sheep farmers whose economic industry is in need of our help. This is in contrast to the down feather industry whose manufacturers are primarily overseas in China and Asia. </p>

<p>On the whole, wool adds up to having a smaller ecological footprint than down.</p>

<p>Honestly, if you are in love with the way down squishes and you can’t live without that quality either stick with down, or try eco-friendly kapok. Wool is definitely soft and fluffy but it does not have that squishable character the way down does. However, wool just plain feels homey, warm, and good. Try it once and you won’t go back!</p>