3.16 weighted GPA; top 75% (only better than 1/4 of students at my school; I know it's bad!)
Pretty good extra-curriculars; studied abroad for a year in New Zealand, did an exchange program in Japan for a summer, taught myself Japanese, interned at an art gallery in Japan, worked part-time etc.
Essay is very good. It is about my struggles with my Tourette's Syndrome in New Zealand, and how I was bullied by my host mother there. I then talk about how my friends there helped me get over her, and how I took those experiences into my life back in the US.
Teacher recommendations are mediocre and are from senior year as I was in New Zealand during my junior year
I have taken 7 AP-level courses, but only 2 were official AP classes, the rest being high-honors (weighted equally)
I know that my GPA is bad, but I was hoping my test scores and upwards grade trend as well as my year abroad would help my cause.
Arizona State is in a large metro area and will admit you if you have the specified requirements: https://students.asu.edu/freshman/requirements
However, some majors may have higher standards to be admitted to the major. It may also be expensive as a non-Arizona resident.
If you’re open to Canadian universities, they won’t care about your freshman or sophomore grades at all or your references. They will pretty much care only for your senior grades. McGill, University of Toronto and UBC are in excellent cities.