Fitness, Nutrition and Health- All Welcome (Hardcore and “Light”)

I’m in training for backpacking. Yesterday I hiked a flat 9 miles carrying 32 lbs! This is the maximum distance I need, so now I’m going to turn to hiking shorter distances with more elevation changes and try to work up to a hilly 9 miles. But I’ll take this as a win!

8 Likes

So as one could imagine I have thoughts about weight-loss. Let me preface this by saying I am not trained by science whatsoever. I am an Accountant by trade and I know sushiritto for one knows way more on the subject.

Everything I am about to say is from my personal experience. I have struggled with my weight my whole life. My earliest memories was having to make weight in 6th grade to play football. Btw, I am 53 now. I have lost triple digit lbs twice in my life and another time in the 80-90lbs range. I have never taken drugs of any sort to lose weight. In my mind I have done it always by sheer willpower. My best friend from childhood tells me I am the best around at losing weight, but suck at maintaining it. It comes from my personality. I am very much an all or nothing type of person.

I have seen and read about tons of diets and exercise programs. I was extremely lucky at age about 13 or 14 to learn about ‘lifting weights’ (back in the 80s) from someone who know what he was doing. So at least I started with a good base of knowledge there.

At different times people have asked me about what I did to lose weight during the times that I did lose a significant amount of weight. Most people don’t really want to know the hard details so my standard answer is ‘move more and eat less’. I have realized as I have matured that is kinda a glib answer.

As I have aged I have realized that weight gain/loss is emotional for many people. I feel like I have an addiction to food. These days I treat food much like an alcohol or drug addiction. But in many ways it is harder because you do need to eat to live. Not saying the other addictions are any easier.

I believe that the program that works best is the one the individual will do. I do believe in the old saying that you can’t out train a bad diet. I also believe there is a very very small % of people who over an extended period of time who were in a caloric deficit won’t lose weight. People like to think they are in that small % when they aren’t able to lose weight. The issue is weight loss and muscle build take time and many people don’t have the patience to put in the time.

I am lucky in that like being in the gym or exercising in general. Not only does it help my body but it helps my mind. I am also lucky that I have lost weight so often that I know generally the amount of food I can intake and be in a calorie deficit without counting the calories perfectly. I am a believer though that if I am not attaining my goals that I need to work harder on both sides of the issue. I am not a person that blames outside forces that are out of my control for my failures. I believe that in all areas of my life.

I am in a good place right now. We are empty nesters so I don’t have as many obligations for my time that would keep me from working out. The time before this last weight loss I hit a goal in May 2012. I was doing well. Then in March 2014 I had my only second involuntary job change. I found a new job within 2-3 weeks. My kids at that time were 13 and 9. They were active kids playing sports and doing other things. That new job for the first 12 months required me to work 60 hours one week and 65 hours the second week on repeat. Something had to give and it wasn’t going to be time for my kids and wife so I stopped exercising and went back to old habits of eating. My low point in May 2012 was 160lbs. By February 2024 I was up to 313. I was depressed. At that point I just decided I needed a change and by February 2025 I got down to 155. I currently hang out in the high 160s. I have the classic goal of more muscle and less fat. I did pretty well in 2025 overall. I had my first hernia surgery in April 2025. Then it came back in fall 2025 and just had the surgery again to fix it.

All through the most recent weight loss I had one mantra that I tell myself each day. I had made doing at least 1 hour of elliptical each day as my non-negotiable in my life as long as I wasn’t travel. That mantra was ‘Not Today’ Meaning I wasn’t going to quit today. It is what drives me to get it done each day. I have had some tough days to get that 1 hour done like no sleep the previous night and I still did my hour.

Overall I feel 1000 times better and my life is much easier at this weight.

Sorry for the long post.

6 Likes

We enjoy your posts. No apologies needed.

In terms of the study above, I always say “some movement is better than no movement.” But folks almost always seem to be focused on the number displayed by the scale.

I don’t like the term weight loss. I prefer the term “body recomposition.” And body recomposition just isn’t easy.

3 Likes

I agree. I remember many years ago when I learned the term skinny-fat.

Overall I feel like I am fine with my muscle mass, but I will never be able to lift heavy like I used to back in the day. My joints and tendons are old. I am fine with that and focus on the movements I can do. I might even be a little too conservative, but I really don’t want to tear something or pull something that would lay me up for 6-12 months.

Heck one of my biggest fears is falling on ice or snow and messing something up bad. I have seen it so much as I age. My wife’s co-worker last winter slipped on ice in her driveway broke her wrist and she has major issues now. We just don’t heal like when we were kids.

One last note. On my motivation to get get healthier one other item was seeing how fast my Mom aged after my Dad passed. She was of course depressed after losing her husband of 50 years and we tried everything to get her out and about. But in like 5-6 years she aged like 15-20 years. Covid didn’t help either. Trying to get an older parent to do something is about as much fun as trying to get a teenager to do something he/she doesn’t want to do. I watched my MIL do something similar with her health. I told myself I don’t want to be immobile in my 70s. We work too hard not to enjoy retirement to some extent.

2 Likes

Varies. Some people with >25 pounds of excess body fat may have decent muscle and cardio strength. However, it is likely that many such people already do some amount of physical activity such was working in a physical labor job or playing some kinds of sports where extra body fat is not as much of a disadvantage or where it does not prevent attaining local recreational league performance levels.

I love Margaret Martin! She’s so calm and has such reasonable advice. Thanks for posting.

3 Likes

You know what I like about this one? I’ve done yoga for over 12 years. I’ve done all kinds of standing on one leg poses and exercises - with bands, weights, etc. I’m not bad at them. Some of them I’m pretty good at.

But I was finding that when I walk with H and he tells me “Look at X” to the right/left, that I couldn’t turn my head without feeling like I may fall. I had to stop walking, turn and look, then continue. This exercise has you actually moving and balancing like you would in real life, not just balancing on 1 leg and moving up/down/all around.

I’ve started a few new things for my mobility/balance that seem to be helping. One tip that made the difference for me with the walking thing was to NOT grip with your toes. Pick them up and learn to feel the 3 points of contact in your feet (heel, pad behind your big and pinky toes). That made me so much more stable! I can even (sometimes) do the one with my eyes closed.

4 Likes

I’m going to put this here..and start by acknowledging the test group consists of n=2.

Several months ago I attended a somewhat woohoo health conference. One of the presenters spoke of her spouses issue with high cholesterol. Now this is a couple who does everything ‘right’. Eat right, exercise, are from all physical appearances strong, on the lower end of weight etc. Before agreeing to lipid medication the presenter asked to conduct an experiment on her husband…take a 15-20 minute sauna 2x-3x week. Followed by a cold plunge. She didn’t elaborate on how long, how cold or how deep to submerge. After 3 months the husband’s cholesterol and ‘plummeted’ to well below statin therapy thresholds.

My total cholesterol had spiked. I attributed one particular spike to a third covid infection in September 2024. It was sitting at 240. Still had very good HDL but the total level wasn’t coming down.

My hormone doc requires a full lipid panel, CBC, A1c and hormone/thyroid level every 4-5 months. She will not renew prescriptions before test results are in.

Around August 2025 I started the sauna/plunge routine. Tested in October …. total cholesterol down to 220. Okay, could be a fluke, I know it can vary day to day. Tested again a few weeks ago…total now 191!

It is NOT due to better eating habits - which are pretty good to begin with. And, this test was after a nice round of holiday food happiness.

I can only point to the sauna/plunge routine. My plunge is at 48-51 degrees and the most I have ever stayed in the water Is 2.5 minutes. So I’m not one of those ‘ice bath for 10 minutes’ people.

YYMV…but maybe it can help someone.

6 Likes

Interesting to note!

I made it to 66 without any regular medications but am due to start a statin on Monday. I don’t eat bad but could eat better. I exercise plenty. Both my parents had high cholesterol. I decided to try the statin and hope that it is a preventive heart intervention and hope that I don’t have any side effects I often hear - like muscle aches, fatigue, etc.

But I don’t have access to a cold plunge or sauna! :slight_smile:

4 Likes

That’s a bummer. I am so proud to be the only one in my fam not to take BP meds, but time comes for us all so we’ll see how long I can keep it up.

2 Likes

I do find this interesting. But where do you go for this? I’m not sure I know of anywhere with a sauna around here

1 Like

Cold plunge can be as simple as pouring a bucket of cold water on one’s head!

Apparently, there are several studies showing potential benefits. Here is one:

https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/ajpregu.00076.2022

And some recommendations:

1 Like

So that fad from a few years back - the bucket challenge - was actually a preventative health measure??! :laughing:

5 Likes

Not unless one sat in a sauna for 15 minutes prior to that! :rofl:

2 Likes

Cold water plunge impact on cholesterol has a far larger sample size than 2. An example study is at Effect of repeatedly applied cold water immersion on subclinical atherosclerosis, inflammation, fat accumulation and lipid profile parameters of volunteers - PubMed . However, it’s not a magic bullet. Note that the study mentions a 13% decrease in LDL cholesterol after 5 months of cold immersion, 3x per week. One typically needs to repeat for long periods to see a cholesterol benefit, and that benefit is often small.

Stanford medical school Professor Huberman of the Huberman Lab podcast does research in this area and regularly discusses protocols, benefits (primary benefit is not cholesterol), and underlying mechanisms of why those benefits occur on his podcast.

I can’t help with the sauna access…but…the gym’s cold plunge was broken for 8 weeks…starting before Christmas and lasting beyond my last blood test. I resorted to cold showers. I start at the kidneys..slowly roll up into the cold water with my back. Turn around and let it hit the heart area and both sides of the nest (vagal nerve). Then down the front. The cholesterol numbers lowered during the holidays…so maybe the cold shower took the place of the plunge ?

1 Like

My gym has a sauna, steam room and a cold plunge.

1 Like

The reason sauna lowers cholesterol (from the UCLA Health I linked above) :

“High blood cholesterol — a waxy substance in your cells — is a major risk factor for heart disease. Lowering your total blood cholesterol by 10% can decrease your risk of heart disease by 30%. The good news is that sweating can raise your good cholesterol levels (HDL) to improve your total cholesterol.

Exercise will certainly help you work up a sweat, and sauna bathing on its own can also reduce total cholesterol levels. But combining the two — sitting in a sauna after your workout — has a more significant effect on total cholesterol.”

2 Likes

The sauna idea sounds nice. Cold plunge not so much.

2 Likes