About 3 years ago, I weighed 115 lbs but was worried about my A1c crept up to 5.7, I decided to drastically reduced my carb intake. Ate almost no rice, bread, potatoes and such. I’ve exercised consistently but moderately (an hour a day of walking with a bit of use of dumbbells).
After 4 months, the result was I lost 11 lbs (104 lbs) and my A1c went up to 5.8!! My PCP told me that as people age, (I was 63 at the time), A1c tends to go up. She suggested I went back to eat normally and have A1c checked a couple of times a year. During this very low weight (for me), my A1c was 5.8 and 5.9!!! (from finger picks in the doctor’s office without fasting).
I’ve gone back to eat normally but made sure I eat more protein than I did in previous years. My weight have gone up to 112 lbs and stayed that way since then. My last A1c was 5.7 in Jan this year. Slight increase in cholesterol but the PCP is not worried and every other reading from my blood work was fine.
I am due to have another A1c check in July (blood work with fasting). My husband, a pharmacist, told me that it takes at least 45 days of a change in my eating habit to see a difference in A1 c result. I’ve eaten more ice cream and sweets since Jan. Now, it’s time I cut those out for 45 days before my next blood work.
I’ll add one more vote for finding a form of strength/mobility work that you don’t dread.
I used to think of Pilates as more of a stretching class, but it is definitely more than that when it is taught well. It works the smaller stabilizing muscles, core control, posture, hips, glutes, and balance in a way that feels very different from lifting weights. For people who don’t naturally enjoy the weight room, I think it can be a good bridge into strength work without feeling like “ugh, I have to go lift.”
I noticed this most when I tried Pilates while traveling in Costa Rica. The studio was called Pilates Nosara Compass, and what stood out was how many tiny corrections the instructor made. A move that looked simple suddenly became hard once I was actually using the right muscles instead of compensating with my back or shoulders.
I’m not saying Pilates replaces heavier resistance training, especially if the goal is building muscle mass, but for core strength, mobility, balance, and body awareness, it can be surprisingly useful. And honestly, the best exercise is often the one you will actually keep doing.
I love walking and yoga and enjoyed running (currently on hold, but hoping to return). I have been strength training since last fall- I am in a small, all women class with a female trainer. I admit I actually dread going, but once I’m there I am fine. The women in the class are friends of mine and very supportive and fun. I always walk out feeling glad I went. I could not discipline myself to do this alone.
My biggest issue is that about a year and a half or so ago, I suddenly developed a “meno pot”. No change in eating habits or workouts but I can’t seem to lose it.
Thanks for your insights. Glad things are going OK for you. (My prior/now-retired PCP did roll his eyes when he heard his backup wanted to send me to endicrinologist in 2019 for 5.7 A1C since he said about 1/3 or his patients were 5.7+. He was just delighted I had started to eat better, run, kept off the lost weight.).
”My PCP told me that as people age, (I was 63 at the time), A1c tends to go up.” - I am age 63, and I’ve wondered about that. I’ll end my long tangent discussion with a snapshot going back as far as I have bloodwork data…. because it was encouragement from my online fitness friends that helped me to loose weight, keep it off… and keep the bloodwork stats from creeping up more
Note - I retired in 2020. In those first few years of running, it was realllly hard to fit workouts into my schedule. Now that I have more free time, gonna try to do Pickleball (my new love) AND running too. Ha, even if it means I need to get up early to beat the heat.
My heaviest weight was 138 lbs, too. As I have exercised more consistently and eaten more carefully, my weight has gone down. It has been under 120 lbs for almost 10 years now.
Compared to forum members on this thread, my exercise is a lot less than others, only about 45 mins of walking (outside when weather is good) on treadmill and stretching and using dumbbells for 10-15 mins.
I used to jog a couple of hours a day but have not done so since my husband pointed out how running could have negative impact on our knees esp. as we grow older.
My goal is to keep my A1c low if possible and fight off osteopenia.
Good for everyone on here monitoring the bloodwork!
I started doing this only relatively recently. A cardiologist I saw a few weeks ago said “everyone should be on a statin” and recommended that I consider it - my cholesterol is 185.
I was a little disappointed in 185 since I’ve been on a low-fat, mainly plant based diet since I’ve been 18! But regardless, that recommendation seemed - to me- unsupported and aggressive.
@rphcfb -it sounds as if you have found what works for you and you really don’t need to do more ( or feel as if you should/ have to).
An aside, studies have shown that knee problems are not caused by running. Some runners do have issues, but that are people who are predisposed to them.
I’ve heard this statement before. IMO, ridiculous. Without a thorough patient evaluation? Sounds like they’re earning a commission from the drug makers.
Did a 6 mile hike on Tuesday. It turned out to be tough. In the 1st 3 miles we climbed about 1450 feet and then gave it all back in the last 3. It was also super hot which added to challenge.
Since I have high HDL, I usually focus on LDL. Looked at my trend chart at the pcp/clinic website and was reminded top range of normal is 130 (not 100 as I had once thought).
Coincidentally today I went to a University Women club even (mostly retirees) with speaker topic of brain health…. and “healthspan”. One of the 14 factors listed was LDL.
I thought this remark from the article was interesting.
Also, in terms of nonvegetarians, which is “my” category, there’s a difference between a lean steak, for example, versus hambugers, hot dogs, bacon and other ultra processed meats.
One problem with many nutritional population studies is lack of controls. When comparing different populations, you are changing many variables at once, which makes it difficult to untangle driving cause vs correlation.
For example, I’d expect Seventh-day Adventists who are more strict about following diet are more strict about other Seventh-day Adventist “unclean” substances including alcohol, tobacco, and caffeinated drinks. I’d expect they also are more likely to exercise regularly and have regular social connections. I’d expect an increasingly strict diet correlates with being increasingly strict about these other factors influencing health. If this group of more strict Seventh-day Adventists has a lower BMI and lower rates of diabetes and hypertension is that primarily because of the vegan diet or primarily because of these other factors?
Ideally you instead want to have 2 groups – one control and one intervention, then compare outcomes. The intervention group would have diet changed and other factors remain the same. A meta analysis reviewing these type of studies is at Effects of vegan diets on cardiometabolic health: A systematic review and meta‐analysis of randomized controlled trials - PMC . The tables below summarizes changes when switching to a vegan diet for at least several months among persons that are overweight or have type 2 diabetes.
There was notable decrease in LDL and total cholesterol, but wasn’t much change in blood pressure. A1C improved among persons with diabetes, but little change among persons who were overweight without diabetes (bottom most figure). BMI tended to decrease.
Other studies have reviewed further about the specific foods or components of foods that are associated with changes above. For example total calories, fiber, protein, ultraprocessed foods, unrefined sugars, EFAs/O3s, etc. It’s not as simple a relationship as vegan products lead to positive health changes, and animal products lead to negative health changes. I’d expect high omega-3 fish like salmon to be associated with positive changes on almost all metrics above, while I’d expect ultraprocessed vegan foods to be associated with negative changes on almost all metrics above.
The “A Roadmap to Brain Health” speaker luncheon speaker I mentioned above talked about was intereesting. She talked “healthspan” (living long with healthy years), which we all think about. I thought of this thread and smiled when she talked about the importance of muscle mass. Says she has massive thighs (not visible under her business dress) - maybe a cyclist?
This is an experimental study overseen by Neal Barnard (of Reversing Diabetes fame). While its purpose is to compare two different diets, meaning the control isn’t a true control as you describe, it draws the same conclusion, albeit from a very small number of participants.
Individuals with type 2 diabetes (n = 99) were randomly assigned to a low-fat vegan diet (n = 49) or a diet following the American Diabetes Association (ADA) guidelines (n = 50). Participants were evaluated at baseline and 22 weeks…
Excluding those who changed medications, A1C fell 1.23 points in the vegan group compared with 0.38 points in the ADA group (P = 0.01).
Note that the study you listed (Barnard, 2006) and 2 other Neal Barnard studies are listed in the meta analysis graphic from my earlier post, which is repeated below. The consensus was the A1C decreased in the studies looking at persons with diabetes, but little change in the studies looking at high BMI persons without diabetes.
Preaching to the choir here… but regardless of which model of eating you adopt, it’s good to cut back on foods that are highly processed and/or high in saturated fat. And to MOVE. Yesterday’s talk said walking is great… but not enough. And trying something new can be good for the brain.