Full Ride [at Emory] vs Harvard/Yale [Yale is $14k, no parent contribution]

Someone borrowing 14K per year (so let’s assume no increase in room and board) is borrowing UNDER 40K? Math ain’t mathing for me. 14K X 4 years equals what exactly?

I agree that pointing out all the options is fantastic for this student. But the implicit tone here is that a kid with no credit history can figure out how to borrow above the federal limits is unkind.

2 Likes

I laid it out exactly in my post. I did not suggest OP borrow $14K per year. Please get your facts straight before saying I stated something I did not.

But they can. It is inaccurate to say they aren’t an option. Like I also said above, those types of loans/non-cosigner are expensive, and I don’t recommend them. CC’s own partner, Ascent Funding, which advertises on these pages, is one of the companies that offers these loans to college students with no credit history and no cosigner.

Again, I am treating OP like an intelligent adult who can sort through options. My goal is to give facts to educate them. They can decide what makes sense for them. Whether they get a job in their area now/this summer is just one consideration. Their major, future education, and career goals additional considerations. I don’t know enough about their situation to give them my opinion, not to mention all the FA offers aren’t even in.

1 Like

All the options are fantastic!! Congrats!!

I second those who say wait for all of your financial packages before finalizing your choice. If the other schools will lead to loans and you prefer the financial freedom (and perks) Emory can provide then go there withiut hesitation.

1 Like

I agree that Emory might be the best choice and I am imagining that it will offer the most freedom to not be stressed during the summers and academic year, but I’m also wondering how much of the 14K is money billed that needs to be paid Yale and how much includes miscellaneous expenses that a frugal student can flex. Apologies if that has already been answered. If a chunk of it is Yale’s estimate about travel, books, miscellaneous stuff then you may not really be borrowing the 14K. Or in the case of one of my kids, her package does not expect any summer earnings at all and it does not expect her to earn as much as she does during the academic year (or maybe it is vice versa, I can’t remember). In any case, her summer + campus job together puts her ahead of the package to speak.

My caution though is I believe Yale is a no loan college, which often means that you will not be eligible to borrow subsidized loans. Because they believe that you don’t need to borrow to cover expenses and that your COA does not need to include loans, you may only be eligible for unsubsidized ones, which are more expensive in the long run, I think.

2 Likes

Yale does not package these federally funded loans in their financial aid awards, but they are always available to students, IIRC. The student needs to call financial aid and request this loan. @kelsmom might know for sure, but I believe the loan amount can’t take the student above the cost of attendance.

1 Like

If someone gave you a new Lexus with free gas would you take it? Or would you get car loans for BMW or Mercedes?

9 Likes

Yes, I am not entirely sure how it works, but I would recommend calling financial aid. I know that it came up for us with one of the no loan schools listed above. We called before she even applied because the NPC showed that I would not be able to afford the parental contribution. The financial aid office was very helpful in advising us, but they were also very clear that if admitted, she would not be eligible for subsidized loans. She would be welcome to borrow if that is what we wanted to do to help with the family contribution, but that any loans would have to be unsubsidized because their package would already cover the COA with no loan expectation. By the way, the office was blunt and said not to apply ED and that the smartest choice to wait until RD instead in case she ended up with offers on the table from other no-loans school that they could use for comparison but that we should understand that there were rules around the subsidized loan eligibility. They basically said that they would likely give her additional grants funds if she was able to demonstrate that another school calculated her need as higher than her package from them, but whatever her final package offered, she would not be eligible for a subsidized loan. She would only be eligible for unsubsidized ones. I don’t know if Yale is similar, but I think the OP should double check.

2 Likes

The Emory program may be better if all were priced equally. And it’s clear from the first post that OP really likes Emory.

I hate to call Emory a safety but kids pick safeties every day of the week over reaches. So I’m using safer in this context since we are acting as if Empry is deficient.

Woodruff is designed to pull in top studs like this. They will have no shortage of opportunities and at a place they can presumably see themselves at for four years.

Yes kids turn down Ivies for non Ivies.

2 Likes

No one here has stated that Emory is deficient in any way. I see many posts saying what a great option, etc etc.

2 Likes

Your offer from Emory is an incredible gift. Also, the overwhelming majority of the time, students incurring debt for an undergraduate degree is the wrong decision. There are only about 5 US universities that are genuinely worth doing this. Yale is one of these universities.

You have one life. I wouldn’t let this opportunity slip away. Contact Yale, hunt for other scholarships and explore every resource. You can do this.

4 Likes

Deficient vs. the other potential choices, etc.

Or the discussion wouldn’t even be taking place.

@Zrt42 is it (Yale worth it)? Do we know the student’s career goals? Woodruff will set this student on a strong path - Emory needs these kids to succeed. Yale likely will but doesn’t have the same level of university need for the student to succeed.

Here are career outcomes for both (don’t know the major). Yale’s sheet is more in depth (gives salaries). Yale shows a 91% knowledge rate. I don’t see one for Emory - and Emory reports business majors in a different table so Emory has two.

We don’t even know what the student is interested (major wise) so not sure how we can say Yale is superior.

I wish OP the best of luck but I say, college is stressful enough. Why add financial hardship?

Yale College First Destinations – Office of Career Strategy – Yale University

Student Outcomes – Career and Professional Development | Emory University

BBA Employment Success | Emory University Goizueta Business School

2 Likes

I think that you will likely find funded internships and opportunities at all of those schools including potentially funded research related to your major. But if you are scrambling to make extra money to cover your expenses at Yale, you may not be able to take advantage of the funded internships etc and instead you will have to take the highest paying employment that you can find. In other words, I wouldn’t worry that the funded internships aren’t available at Yale, but if a summer internship or summer study abroad opportunity is available at Yale, they might provide a $500/week stipend + cover travel & housing. And it is possible that you might feel stuck like you need to forgo that opportunity so you can live at home that summer for free and make a lot more money to help defray costs during the school year.

From my understanding, you are saying that at Emory, the whole COA is already covered by the Scholars program. Thus you’d be able to take the internship without worrying about the need to save money for the fall. Similarly, you might end up with some cool campus paid research opportunities at both colleges, but at Yale, maybe you’ll feel the need to be work 15 hours per week instead of only 8 hours or even zero hours. And you could potentially come to regret the additional time and stress that you are putting into making Yale work when you had a great offer at Emory that was stress free.

7 Likes

No deficiency, just a choice. OP doesn’t even have all the facts needed to make the choice, and has some research to do regarding what comprises that $14K Yale COA while they wait for their other FA offers.

There is so much posters don’t know regarding OP’s situation that I also don’t understand how anyone here can have an opinion yet.

6 Likes

After tax? Doing what?

The vast majority of graduates of colleges like Yale are going to go on to normally-successful professional careers, same as equivalent individuals who go to colleges like Emory. Law firm partners, doctors, scientists, professors, business managers, and so on.

Which can be a very nice outcome, except sometimes some people end up unhappy with their chosen path. Some eventually switch, but then there is a significant opportunity cost to the time and possibly money they spent on a false start.

This isn’t entirely avoidable as a risk, but again you can at least reduce it by minimizing debt to the extent possible.

6 Likes

If you’d like to continue this via PM, please reach out. OP’s $14K Yale COA very well might include summer earnings and/or work study.

1 Like
  1. You should probably wait for this before stressing too much! (easier said than done).
  2. Make sure you REALLY understand the nuances and details of all awards. Don’t hesitate to reach out to fin aid officers to capture nuances. It is confusing stuff.

They are all wonderful, fantastic schools. It is not awful to turn down Harvard and Yale for Emory. However, I think you also don’t have the full picture yet, and sounds like your heart is pulling for Harvard or Yale (which I fully can understand).

The freedom of not worrying about money for 4 years (or I should say worrying a lot less) will be very, very nice though.

My vote, wait for ALL the details, do the math on what you can make work financially (and be realistic about it).

5 Likes

Congratulations !!!

Thus far, you have received incredible advice in this thread (but I’ll offer my thoughts anyway).

If you truly prefer Yale, Harvard, Dartmouth, or Brown over Emory, then you need to contact the primary school of interest & ask that school if they would be willing to consider Emory’s offer when calculating or recalculating your financial aid package. If not, then Emory University’s offer should be given strong consideration (always difficult to turn down Yale or Harvard or Princeton or MIT or Stanford).

Over two decades ago, one of my brothers-in-law faced a similar dilemma regarding his MBA. He earned a perfect score on the GMAT & had work experience as an electrical engineer (degree from Georgia Tech). As with almost every person in my extended family, Atlanta is regarded as “heaven on earth”.

Emory’s MBA program offered a full ride and stated that if he wanted more, they would do so. His other offer was from Northwestern Kellogg MBA which was long regarded as the best MBA program in the country (for 16 straight years from 1990 through 2005 Northwestern Kellogg’s MBA was ranked #1 in the country by US News and maintained the #1 ranking in marketing among MBA programs–which was his specialty area of interest). Not sure what Kellogg’s financial offer was, but it would be affordable, but probably required some amount of student loans. His intention was to return to Atlanta forever.

He asked me for advice & I recommended Northwestern Kellogg; advice which he followed. Was it the right decision ? We’ll never know, but we do know that it was not a wrong decision as employment offers out of Kellogg were plentiful and with the top companies in the world.

My point is that you have 5 great options—none of which is likely to be a wrong choice. If you are trying to make the best choice from among your 5 options, you need to define “best” and understand that from a future perspective looking back, that you will only be guessing. Easier to make a best choice based on your current situation, and that choice would be the debt free option. In the future, will the debt free option still be considered the best choice when looking back on your career, we don’t know.

One concern is that you have presented only one factor to consider—COA. We do not know what you intend to study, whether graduate or professional school is likely, what is your career goal, and where you prefer to live & work.

In short, you have already made your choice based on your single focused vision on COA. Is this how you really want to make your potentially life altering decision ? If yes, then the answer is clear. If no, then you should share more information about yourself beyond your financial situation.

FWIW The reason that I recommended Northwestern Kellogg to my brother-in-law was not Kellogg’s premier status with US News as the best MBA program in the country, it was Kellogg’s unassailable top ranking in marketing which was my brother-in-law’s specialty area of interest. The result was outstanding in terms of career opportunities.

All we know now about you is that you are seeking to save money; we know nothing about your educational interests and career goals.

P.S. And, of course, your situation is about undergraduate school, not grad school, and this can make a substantial difference in the weight given to COA.

2 Likes

Yeah, grad or professional school might require being more specific about where would best support your desired career path. This is among the reasons taking some time out of school after college can be a good idea, to help refine what you really want out of further education.

1 Like

I think the OP has already factored that into the equation /question when they stated that doing so might mean giving up other valuable opportunities. And that is a very valid thought. I am currently watching S23s friend group make these exact decisions. The ones that struggle to pay for school are forced to take summer jobs outside or their major (think servers, retail, etc) to ensure they can pay for the next semester of school, while S23 and the friends that have school paid for are taking summer jobs that will give them experience in their field, but will leave little, if any, money left over after paying transportation, housing, equipment, etc. ,

4 Likes