Brown was a no-loan college and my student was eligible for subsidized and unsubsidized federal loans in addition to the grants that were a component of his financial aid package . But he had to ask for them— they were not offered automatically.
Agreed – my social science/humanities kids who went into law and business both had unpaid and low paid summer internships which helped prepare them to get their post-grad opportunities. The flexibility of not having to worry about earning money to pay for school the next year was huge for them as they both went to their financial safeties, knowing they would have more opportunities to explore.
If the family contribution is in the total COA, the student still has the ability to borrow, and if the student qualifies for subsidized loans, they qualify. If the COA is 50k and the school has awarded grants of $50k, then yes, they probably won’t qualify for subsidized loans (but can still take unsubbed loans). If the COA is 50k and the school awards $40k and expects the family to come up with $10k, then that student, if he qualified for subsidized loans, should get them. My daughter qualified for subsidized loans and all of her tuition and most of her other costs were covered by grants and scholarships. She still took the subsidized loans as a cushion for expenses and graduated with 1/2 that money in her bank account.
If OP didn’t qualify for 100% financial aid at Yale, he may not have qualified for subsidized loans or Pell grants. Parents may still not be able to contribute to college, but on paper it may show that they can.
Ok, it seems silly to argue about it since your kids borrowed and mine have not so far. But I’ll just say that I spoke directly to the office at one of the schools above to which the OP was admitted. The office told me that my pell grant kid would not be eligible for subsidized loans because the COA was already covered by their financial aid package. This package included a family contribution that I could not afford. It was not a school where the package was $0 family contribution. According to the school, her full need was already covered by their package (which included grants, summer & term time employment, and a parent contribution) and therefore, she could only borrow by using unsubsidized loans. Clearly something different was happening with your child’s package. Either way, it is worth clarifying with the Yale office since interest accrues differently between the two types(as I understand it).
And I’ll add on a related note- the idea that this kid (or any kid with a gap) is going to be able to “find” local scholarships to fill the gap- this plan has to be run by Financial Aid before the kid spends weeks getting $500 (non renewable) from the local Realtors and $250 from Kiwanis. SOME colleges will allow these local, one time awards to replace the family commitment. Others will not, and the awards will just replace some of the need based aid the kid is already getting.
I was on the board of a small foundation which gave “last dollar” grants and saw up close how hard it was for some families. So the advice “you’ll get more scholarships and fill the gap” may or may not be a viable plan. Yale may say “Great idea” or may say “Your need will go down if you have outside sources of funds”.
Better ask.
Yes and yes, for Yale…
kosibee03, you are going to be bombarded by a variety of opinions here. Everything I have read in this thread is reasonable. I think the people posting here all mean well. However, we are anonymous people with unknown credentials and with our own views and agendas.
Jeff Selingo is a journalist & author who is widely considered an expert on higher education. I encourage you to go to the 3:45 point and the 5:00 point in this video:
A common methodology is to allow outside scholarships to replace student contribution first, but then replace college grants before replacing parent contribution.
It appears that Yale does this, and expects a student contribution of $3.7k. See Financial Aid Policies | Undergraduate Financial Aid . So the first $3.7k of outside scholarships reduces the student’s net price, but outside scholarships beyond that are just donations to Yale until they get big enough to go beyond replacing Yale grants.
Indeed… we all have our own opinions, but opinions are cheap. Student debt isn’t.
I can see both sides of this argument. It’s not like we’re talking full-ride vs. full-pay. $14K/year is a fantastic value for Yale. $0/year for Emory is… well, we can’t even really talk “value” when the denominator is zero, lol. An amazing offer.
To assess this accurately, we’re not talking about around 60K total for Yale. We’re talking the total that financing that 60K will ultimately cost, plus whatever unknown decisions have to be made for financial reasons (e.g. passing up lower-paying opportunities because income has to be prioritized).
And as others have alluded to, none of this is happening in a vacuum. When I look back on my own kids’ college decisions, so much has changed in terms of the economic, political, and higher ed landscape that if we had to make the same decisions today, it would be a completely different calculation.
Deciding to take on debt isn’t just betting on yourself and your own potential. It’s also betting on the economy and the job market that you’ll be entering.
Without crossing the “belongs in the politics forum” line, we are in fraught and uncertain times. One’s beliefs about where this is all heading will inevitably figure into a decision like this. Nobody else can tell you what your risk profile should look like right now, in the context of how things may unfold over your college years. This is at least as much a matter for the gut as for the brain.
My own gut would be leaning toward the debt-free and still highly-prestigious option, but that is heavily context-driven, and your interpretation of the larger context may be less dread-ridden than mine. Or you may see a “T5” degree as even more protective of a your prospects than being debt-free. There is no objectively-provable answer here. There is only deciding what you believe most strongly, and betting on it.
Congrats on earning such great offers!
Take the Woodruff! You will be set for life. The possibilities there are endless. Everyone else who is awarded a Woodruff was also admitted to many excellent schools. And you met those other kids and you know they are amazing as are most Emory students. This is a no brainer.
Really? Won’t you always wonder about not attending H or Y for $56K total (over 4 years) if you go to Emory? Emory is a good school, but I think there is a pretty big gap between attending H or Y vs. Emory.
Depending on what career you end up in, it could very well be that you won’t even miss $56K over your lifetime. $56K is more or less in the realm of buying 1 less new car over your lifetime.
Of course you need to figure out how to get the loans, but I bet H or Y would be willing to loan you that much through their own means. Schedule a time to talk to their financial aid offices and get the complete picture of your options. Then decide.
Many Emory kids will outperform Harvard and Yale and it’s not $56k. You have to borrow $57.5 or $58k to get $56k and then there’s interest. Over ten years at 9% it will be near $90k.
Who has $700+ a month just sitting around ? My 24 year old makes 6 figures and couldn’t afford that.
And you get this - free study abroad and an internship stipend if yours doesn’t pay.
“annual programming including an off-site retreat, specialized advising and mentoring, access to summer funding for international experiences and unpaid internships”
Note
I went to an Ivy a million years ago and even then I got funding to pay for housing for my unpaid internship- there is tons more funding now and universities for kids who need it. I’m not sure that’s a difference between Emory and Yale, but is a difference between rich schools and others.
That’s a car payment these days. This kid won’t be in the poor house when he graduates…if he takes the Ivy offer.
But all of this is premature…he doesn’t have all of his financial aid offers.
Interestingly I know a lot of people who actually attended one of the former and would not agree with this proposition (at least for undergrad). At the end of the day, they are all just schools. Well-resourced schools, but it is how you as an individual end up making use of those resources that actually matters. And quickly enough it is apparent an Emory offers way more opportunities than any one student could possibly make use of anyway.
Congrats on some amazing achievements! For you to receive five acceptances from such elite, tippy-top institutions often takes strong parental support all along the way. Oftentimes, situations like yours - multiple IVY acceptances and absolutely no money at all, whatsoever, that’s a news story. Few other quick thoughts:
-
If you are looking to enter the health sciences, go to Emory, no questions asked, especially if medical school is on your horizons.
-
As I understand it, Brown and Yale meet 100% financial need for admitted students. Wouldn’t that apply in a situation where a parent is not contributing any money?
-
These schools had to have seen your CSS profile and been fully aware of what your financial situation looked like before offering admittance.
Definitely speak to your guidance counselor if you haven’t already. I really can’t see how an amazing kid with four IVY acceptances would fall through the cracks like this.
FOUR. This makes you probably, what, one of 50-75 kids in the country, if not the world, hitting for the academic cycle?
No. Colleges look at a family’s ability to pay by evaluating their income and assets, they don’t look at the parents willingness to pay. If that were the case, no one would pay.
With that said, although we don’t know exactly what Yale’s $14K COA is comprised of, we know that a $14K COA means OP comes from a relatively limited income family as Yale offers only need based aid.
All the schools OP mentioned are need blind. Admissions did not see how much financial aid OP needed before offering admittance.
What does this mean?
The schools calculate what they think the parent can contribute. A parent not contributing to college costs by choice will not increase a need based financial aid award.
Most of these schools meet 100% of demonstrated financial need. The kid who gets into four IVYs is often not the same kid whose parents will refuse to pay a dime for college.
This is a special situation, highly unusual circumstance and OP’S guidance counselor needs to step in.
I agree that these schools meet full need as they calculate it. Yale calculated that OP’s family can contribute $14K…likely partially student self help and parent contribution, but I don’t know that for sure (but have seen other similar offers from Yale.)
I still don’t really understand what you are saying. What is the student’s HS counselor going to do?