We have not heard of any extenuating circumstances regarding the financial aid award. If there are extenuating circumstances, then these should be brought to the attention of the college.
Simply getting accepted at these top schools is not necessarily a ticket to a free ride at them.
But this student should inquire…once they have ALL of their financial aid awards in hand (they don’t have them all…yet).
2 Likes
They may be if they take on $56K worth of loans (and yes, we don’t know yet) - plenty of Ivy kids, even in a good economy, won’t find jobs or desire to take a lower paying job (as many on this website often note) - and debt often eliminates the ability to choose.
1 Like
Although every CSS college is free to set its own policies in the end, this Noncustodial Parent Waiver Form might provide some insights into what I might call the typical criteria for not considering a Noncustodial Parent as a possible source of financial support:
If the parents don’t have the capacity to pay, then OP should be covered under demonstrated need.
Maybe I’m wrong here, but I’ve never seen a scenario like this in the history of CC. Parents pay for at least four college applications with absolutely no intention of supporting the child to attend any of them. Could OP have spent the $300-$400 in application fees, but if they were waived, then again, demonstrated need.
Perhaps the family thought their need based aid award would be higher. It’s not the first time that has happened.
3 Likes
Perhaps, but the family rolling the dice like this is probably not the family that couldn’t manage $14K a year for Yale.
I’m not sure about here at CC specifically, but this is a scenario I’ve encountered quite a bit in some general form over the last few years of paying attention to all this. Some parents seem to be unaware in advance how much these colleges are likely to ask them to contribute, and the kid only learns some colleges will be unaffordable after they get their offers.
This is one of the reasons why some of us encourage kids posting here with unclear answers about their actual budget to have frank, informed conversations with their parents on these issues as soon as possible.
3 Likes
Again, what people want to pay and/or think they can pay is often different from what a meet full need college calculates they can contribute. Seriously, this happens all the time. Yale’s COA is around $93K, so OP received about $79K in need based aid.
2 Likes
This student also needs to look at what is covered in the $14,000 they are supposed to pay themselves. Some of these could be things they have some financial control over…books, personal expenses, transportation. Also, if the family has health insurance that is able to be used at these colleges, this cost would not need to be paid if the proper documentation and waiver were done.
2 Likes
I would be curious to see a concrete example where a student was admitted to four T10 schools and couldn’t attend any of them.
Like money on the passing line curious.
An example would be donut hole families (typically middle class/upper middle class incomes)…these families often can’t afford their expected contribution as calculated by the meet full need schools. This is a common occurrence, and why many families have to merit hunt (because they can’t pay what the meet full need schools’ NPCs estimate.)
4 Likes
I agree with all this, I’m just saying that parents wiling to spend over $400 for applications on colleges that they’re unwilling to spend A DIME simply isn’t logical.
And, if you’ve applied to four ivies, you’ve probably applied to 6 or 8, plus 3-4 other T15s. We’re talking a $600-750 spend on applications. The behaviors simply don’t add up.
Perhaps OP had application fee waivers, a high proportion of students with OP’s level of financial need receive application fee waivers.
5 Likes
I’m sure there are examples of kids being asked to contribute at meets need schools (top 10 included) that can’t pay…or aren’t willing.
Schools don’t always agree with the parent - on expenditure. Some expect you to sell assets, etc.
We don’t know the family situation or why they were given a $14K price tag. We only know the student said this. Yale clearly sees otherwise.
At $14K, you can still get an app waiver - which Yale notes is easy to obtain.
It happens.
1 Like
That’s my point, the kid who is getting the application waivers is the kid falling into the meets full need bucket, which contradicts his initial logic.
That’s not really how it works. Plenty of students who are on free/reduced lunch, to take one example of a student who would qualify for a fee waiver, could still have a $14K expected contribution from Yale.
5 Likes
“Cannot afford.” That should satisfy the demonstrated need threshold. This is why the guidance counselor should get involved and convey to each of the schools what a rock star he is. How many kids do you know that got into four IVYs?
The kid needs an advocate at the school level. Immediately.
1 Like
Again, that’s not how need based aid works. You are giving inaccurate advice. If you’d like to PM me you can, but let’s not scare OP away from this thread.
5 Likes
If they ran the NPC, I assume it would say they’d have to pay $14K.
Families and colleges disagree all the time on what is affordable - things like home equity, assets and more come in.
While both have a side (parents and college), only what the college says matters.
Many families don’t fill in the NPCs or fill them in not correctly or think they can hide stuff that CSS susses out.
Sure, they can ask why they owe $14K - and then appeal if there is reason - but just because someone says they can’t pay (and in their minds that may be true), that may not be the reality from the school’s POV.
1 Like
It is an annual thing in my circles, like some kids just get into most of their Ivy Plus colleges.
But in any event, I think you are drawing a connection between admissions and aid that I am not sure I understand. A kid being a strong candidate doesn’t seem incompatible with having parents who are unwilling to pay what these colleges think they can afford.
6 Likes