Income Threshold Example (Family of Four, 48 Contiguous States):
Free Lunch: Annual income up to $40,560
Reduced Lunch: Annual income up to $40, 561 & $57, 720, which satisfies Yale’s threshold of demonstrated need.
Look, I’m just saying the OP’s guidance counselor needs to be involved here.
And until someone can show a tangible CC example of a student receiving four Ivy League acceptances and was unable to attend any, then none of us really have any experience in this clearly unprecedented outcome, personal, unsubstantiated anecdotes be damned.
That’s my final comment. My limitless affection to you all.
Major/Post-Bac Plans: I’m not entirely sure if I’ll stick with this, but I’m hoping to double major in Chemistry and Political Science in undergrad. I will definitely be attending grad school, but I’m not sure yet if it’ll be med or law school (broad, I know, but so are my interests). If I end up in law, I’ll likely be a public defender or work in policy.
College Needs: As for what I need in a college, I would honestly say nothing much. I’ve never had a dream school, so I don’t feel drawn to any option in that way. I think my main need is the ability to shift educational focuses and the support/community to do so. I think Yale has that and I know from experience that Emory does as well, especially within the scholar program. I’m also looking for the ability to take advantage of opportunities that will lead me to success after my bachelor’s degree (related internships, jobs, connections).
Summer Work/Savings: Am I currently working? No. I haven’t had to, which has allowed me to pursue no cost work that aligns with my interests. Last summer was the first time I recieved more than $1,000 total, and that was for a stipended program. Currently, my savings go to paying for clubs and senior expenses. I have been applying for summer jobs, but I doubt any of them would yield more than $5,000 before tax. I also have to pay for my college travel and supplies.
For these reasons, Cost of Attendance vs Return on Investment is THE deciding factor for me. If I can go to Emory and come out the same person I’d be if I went to Harvard or Yale, I’ll be just fine going there for free. But, if an Ivy League education has as much value as some have been advising, I’ll take the necessary advice and make it work.
I’ll be sure to update as soon as I recieve my financial aid package from Harvard! (Dartmouth came out, but I would be expected to pay $30k a year which is legitimately impossible)
Note that medical or law school is expensive, and government loans for such may not cover the full cost of attendance. Having undergraduate debt would not be desirable in that case.
Where you go likely won’t matter. For example, Harvard Law has 160+ schools representing under 600 kids - schools like Christopher Newport, Towson and more - are represented. Other law schools are like this. I am a medical patient at Vandy. When I look at residents, schools like Lipscomb and Ok State and Kansas State and Luther College are represented, far more than top schools.
Long story short - a student like you can be a success from any school - so Emory or Ivy for law or med, you’re fine either way.
Now grad school is pricey - but there are some free tuition (but hard to get into) med schools. And some law schools buy kids in. I know a Rutgers grad who chose U Miami (free with merit) over Vanderbilt Law (full pay).
So that’s a problem for later - but it’s another reason to choose Emory and save today because $56K ($90K after loans) - and you can only borrow $200K total - so that’s 25% gone. If you choose grad school that isn’t medical or dental, you can only borrow $100K so you’d be over half way there.
I just don’t see any way (personally) in which Emory isn’t the right answer. Even if it was a lower tier school, I’d make the same statement because law and med school are possible from anywhere - but it’s not. It’s Emory, one of the top schools in the country.
Hi! I attend a Title 1 school, so my parents didn’t pay for any of my applications. I’m one of 4 kids and my parents are divorced. While one parent doesn’t contribute any substantial amount, his income was still included in my financial aid because I don’t have court or school documents stating this lack of support (I’ve tried, trust me). Moreover, the parent who doesn’t contribute lost his job recently, which was also included on every financial aid document and in every email.
Most of this process has been completed by me alone and I think the idea has always just been for me to either find a scholarship or pay for myself.
The CSS profile is actually pretty generous with fee waivers. My kids didn’t pay any application fees. But they could have used the earnings that they made at their summer jobs to help cover app fees if they really wanted to apply to a larger list of colleges and I had not been willing to help.
I would then encourage you to not take out any debt in undergrad. Certainly nothing more than the $27K federal student undergrad loans, but you have an excellent option in Emory that doesn’t require that. I would encourage you to wait to make any decisions until you have the Harvard FA offer though.
Meanwhile I hope that you are so proud of yourself for giving yourself these outstanding options. Kudos to you!
On the one hand you have done an amazing job in putting together your university applications. On the other hand you have done an amazing job in putting together the academic results over 4 years of high school to make this all possible.
To me given what you have said about your family’s finances I think that taking on debt is a big risk. Given that you have the alternative of Emory debt free to me that is an amazing opportunity, that you have earned through some combination of hard work, academic ability, and keeping your head together through the years.
And this is a pretty good summary of the experiences of both of our daughters with regard to what they did right after graduating with their bachelor’s degree. There is a significant freedom of having that bachelor’s degree in hand with no debt. Of course also having significant internship experience at that point is also a big plus.
@kosibee03 you have earned this opportunity. Regardless of whatever your parents might say about this, I know that deep down inside they must be very proud of you. Congratulations again!
Edit to add: You have a great opportunity here. Plan to work very hard from the day that you arrive on campus, make a strong effort to stay ahead of your school work, and I expect that you will do very well.
Hi, I suggest that you call Yale and tell them about the Emory scholarship. My experience with friends whose kids wanted more aid from a preferred Ivy to which they had been admitted (i.e. Princeton) is to let the Admissions office at the Ivy know about the competing offer. That creates an incentive for Yale not to “lose this kid” over $14k/year. Do not underestimate how much Yale likes to win now that they have admitted you
So this is an excellent example of what some of us have been suggesting. You definitely do NOT have to go to Yale for college in order to be a public defender or do some other public interest position. However, the pay for these sorts of positions is not the greatest by attorney standards. Not necessarily inconsistent with a comfortable life, but not the same as what you can make with private clients.
OK, so if you want to be free to follow such a path after law school–and of course you aren’t bound to, this is just an example of a much broader point–then you really do need to make it a goal to emerge from law school with not much student loan debt, including both undergrad and law school.
For what it is worth, I went to college in an era before a lot of student loan debt was even an issue, and eventually went to a law school where I got an excellent scholarship, and that made it easy for me to choose to go to the Department of Justice for my first job as an attorney after a federal clerkship. Plenty of my law school classmates felt like they had to take lucrative Big Law jobs to justify all they and their families had paid, or borrowed, for college and law school. And some of them were fine with that, but some not so much.
So this isn’t just a theory, it is a real thing that becomes a real issue for a lot of people.
At at least one school (Wesleyan, in my memory), you just need to apply for financial aid to get a fee waiver on the application – you don’t even need to be granted need-based aid. I’m sure it’s not the only one.
The University of Chicago will automatically waive the $75 application fee for all high school students who are residents of the City of Chicago and who attend school in the city, regardless of school type, and for any student who indicates an intent to apply for need-based financial aid.
Congratulations, @kosibee03!!! Please consider contacting Yale’s financial aid office once you hear from all of its peer schools on your list, from other ivies. Yale matched my D23’s financial package from Princeton, but they did not consider a full ride from Vanderbilt and Woodruff Scholarship from Emory. I would probably group Emory with peer schools like Northwestern, Duke, Vanderbilt and Rice. Emory is an excellent school and Woodruff Scholars are doing incredible things all over the world - you will be in good company! But please consider all opportunities and don’t be afraid to negotiate/ask for a match and explore work on campus scenarios. Good luck!
The Emory offer is a MERIT award. Yale does not give merit awards. They give only need based awards. It is highly unlikely that Yale will consider a merit award when asked to adjust their need based award.
If you’re interested in public policy, Emory’s Public Policy Analysis major is one of the strongest programs out there, with a particularly strong emphasis on quantitative/data skills that are highly sought-after in the policy sphere. The university is also top-notch for life sciences, and its close relationship with the CDC can be a boon for students who are interested in both health and policy.
Obviously there’s impressive academic strength at your Ivy schools too. It just seems as if you’re worried that the rigor won’t be the same at Emory, and I don’t think that should be a concern. Harvard/Yale obviously have reputational and networking attributes that deserve consideration, but I don’t think there is really the kind of rigor/work-ethic differential that you are imagining.
Yes I know that. In my experience, after admitting an applicant who has a competing offer, an Ivy which wants a student to accept may interpret “need” in view of “new information “. I saw that with 2 different applicants at Princeton and I have heard that Yale does the same.
This complicates the matter somewhat as Yale is the top law school in the nation for supporting & securing legal aid type positions (which can be very competitive). As an undergraduate at Yale, the school would almost certainly be very supportive of any efforts by one of its students to work in the public sector. (Yale law school has the best loan forgiveness program in the country for its graduates who enter into public service. NYU law would be another law school if still interested in public service career prior to entering law school. The Colorado state PD office is among the best funded in the nation & experience there will generate offers nationwide.)
As I suggested early on in this thread, you need to communicate your merit scholarship offers to Yale along with your inability to pay Yale’s determination in order to give Yale a chance to meet your actual need/address your current concerns.
At this point, the easy answer is to accept the Woodruff Scholarship from Emory University. Probably no point in considering Dartmouth or Brown in light of your other options of the Woodruff at Emory, Yale, & Harvard.
Although public defender and policy positions are low paying positions, they are usually quite competitive. Yale law school is, by far, the leader in the public service arena.
Divorced parents with a non-cooperating parent is likely to lead you to the Woodruff Scholarship at Emory University.