Full Ride [at Emory] vs Harvard/Yale [Yale is $14k, no parent contribution]

The Op can ask, but I’m not sure Yale or Harvard will consider a merit award given elsewhere when asked to adjust their need based aid. The Woodruff is a merit award. And Yale and Harvard don’t give merit awards. The criteria for a merit award and the criteria for need based aid are not the same.

8 Likes

Yes, I understand your position, but my experience suggests otherwise. If Yale wants a student, Yale will increase the award.

OP: If you decide to appeal the financial aid assessment made by Yale, feel free to contact me via PM/DM.

2 Likes

Agreed, Yale and Harvard won’t consider matching a merit offer. If Harvard’s FA offer comes in lower than Yale’s though, that would be something to share with Yale FA.

3 Likes

@kosibee03 certainly you can ask for reconsideration of your financial aid awards at these ivies. At this point, wait until you have all the offers. Your net cost to Harvard might end up being much lower…and this would be an excellent bargaining chip…or you might decide Harvard is the place for you.

But I will add, if you feel at home and comfortable at Emory, Emory is a fine choice. And your scholars award there is really a terrific one.

2 Likes

deleted

Again, let us move on from the debate and from asking questions unrelated to the OP’s situation.

3 Likes

Just to be clear, though, the OP is looking at colleges, not law schools. And while there is sort of a pipeline effect from Yale College to Yale Law, it is an EXTREMELY competitive pipeline. The vast majority of law school applicants from Yale College will not in fact be admitted to Yale Law.

And for that matter, Emory Law also has a decent LRAP:

Merit can also be a possibility, and I actually went to law school on a merit scholarship where you got more in grant money for doing summer public interest programs.

This is all a long way off, but if in the future the OP is in fact looking at law school to be followed by a public interest career, they absolutely should see what sort of upfront costs they are looking at, then factor in these sorts of programs as well.

But I wouldn’t choose to pay a lot more for college on the assumption the associated law school will eventually be an option. Maybe, but realistically it is only a small chance when it comes to places like Yale Law.

4 Likes

Yes, you are correct, but Yale University, including both undergraduate & graduate programs, is connected in the most favorable light of any school in the country to public service opportunities.

We’re really not going to debate law schools, right?

1 Like

No debate regarding law schools. My point is that Yale undergrads have great access to public interest programs as do Yale grad students.

I’ll add for the benefit of @kosibee03 that I have experience dealing with Ivy FA offices and have thoughts on how best for you to proceed. Unfortunately, I am prohibited from sharing my advice in this thread since I’m moderating. But I’m not prohibited from offering to respond to any DMs if you have questions.

3 Likes

I think what Harvard offers for FA is going to be critical to this discussion.

When my DS1 got into HYP, the Y FA was by far the stingiest (though he had the same need, and the same profile, in all applications in this context). He went to P, which was the most generous - however, we certainly could have asked H or Y to match P if he had preferred those schools.

Second, I think it is true that Y could revise and find a bit more aid, on an appeal, particularly considering the non-custodial parent situation. But probably not the whole amount.

Third, it sounds like the Emory opportunity is amazing and probably the most sensible (and the most relaxing choice so you aren’t worried about money constantly for the next several years).

3 Likes

This point was noted/confirmed a few posts ago. One can always ask. The worst that can be said is no - but the parent in the same situation already has the answer and provided.

As suggested / noted above, how the matter is handled is important.

We do not know how another poster’s student presented the other offers. Again, as the mod has offered and as I have offered, OP can receive advice via private message regarding suggestions on how to proceed.

If that parent gets a new job (particularly a high paying one), but does not contribute, that could make later years of college at a need-based aid college like Yale more expensive. If Yale is already at or beyond the edge of affordability but gets more expensive in your junior or senior year of college, that can be a significant problem.

10 Likes

That’s an excellent point.

OP, as you probably know, need-based financial aid is re-evaluated every year based on updated information.

5 Likes

Yes to all your points, plus the tuition and fees rise each year, so “$14k per year x 4 years = $56k” isn’t the real life number at the end of four years.

At most schools it would look like: $14k + $17k + $20k + $24k

3 Likes

Many guidance counselors cannot discuss a family’s financial situation. They might be able to skirt around it by suggesting the student talk to the FA officer, point out XYZ situations (job loss, supporting some extra kids that don’t appear on tax return like grandchildren, started a new business, that the second home was inherited from a grandparent and is jointly owned by dad and 4 siblings and can’t be sold) but usually can’t talk numbers with the school.

My takeaway from the above discussion is (from @thumper1 ) ASK when you have all your financial aid numbers and give the schools a chance to match other officers or help you figure out how to make it work. For example, ask the Yale FA officer (if that’s your top choice) how to make it work. Call them up and say “I need 14k, can only borrow $5.5k, how to I make the rest of it work?” I bet they’ll have some suggestions.

Keep plugging away at it.

1 Like

I would likely choose the full ride at Emory. There is just no way that this will hold you back. You might want to wait for all FA packages to come in.

I would not be able to handle the FA stress, coming up with additional funding, having to re-qualify every year, etc.

Possible law school or medical school has to factor in, especially given changes to student loans.

Congrats on your outstanding achievements!

7 Likes

Another thing to ask…if they reconsider your need based aid for your freshman year, will you have to go through the same process for each subsequent year. Usually for need based aid, you need to apply annually…and the amount of aid can fluctuate. So…do ask.

2 Likes