Full Ride [at Emory] vs Harvard/Yale [Yale is $14k, no parent contribution]

Hi OP, if Dartmouth is expecting you to pay $30K per year, I do think an appeal that will get you to Emory Scholars type funding at Yale(that is full COA) is unlikely. It may be that you filled out the forms incorrectly, but if the main issue is that you have a non-custodial parent who refuses to help with college expenses, FA appeals often don’t work outside of documented cases of abandonment or abuse (physical or emotional). My kids do have a few friends for whom (with a non-custodial waiver), a second parent was not expected to contribute, but it tends to be a high bar because otherwise many second parents would opt out of helping their ex-spouse even at the detriment of their own child.

Wherever you decide to attend next year, I think a summer job (or even getting one now) is a great idea. Work (even part time student work) can buy a kind of freedom from parents, which my kids anyway have appreciated. It is a different story if they need you to contribute to the household budget, but if your custodial parent is able to support you and your siblings without any current earnings from you then any money that you make now and through the summer will be fantastic to have in the bank when you start at Emory or Yale or wherever. My college aged daughters both get stipends from their financial aid office –for one, it is more than enough and for the other, nothing will ever be enough. The difference? Spending habits, social lives (one likes to go out and the other does not), and college location? In cities like Cambridge or New Haven, there can be a lot of fun things to do –some are free but some cost $$$. NYC is close and very fun for college students. I don’t know Atlanta at all, but I am guessing that you’ll want some extra cash on hand in that city as well. Dartmouth is completely out of reach, which is too bad because sometimes there is a lot to be said for being stuck on a rural campus with not much (expensive) to do!

Good luck!

Reminder that this is not the cafe where we permit meandering. Responses need to be on topic and responding directly to the OP. Take other conversations to PM or start a new thread.

Post hidden and replies to the hidden posts deleted.

2 Likes

To the OP, I would again just suggest being careful about studies involving outcomes you might not even be interested in. Like, say, being a public defender is not exactly the same sort of outcome as ending up in the top 1% of household income. And understanding the plausible paths to the outcomes you actually want, and what helps or doesn’t help, is likely going to require some nuanced investigation.

Sure, but so do Emory undergrads.

Realistically, if you actually want a public interest career and are the sort of person with offers like the OP has gotten, the hard part is not being desired by many relevant employers. The hard part is being comfortable with how little they might be able to offer to pay you.

Again, this is not just a theory. I have seen kids go to expensive private colleges like Yale with dreams of public interest careers, who then head instead to lucrative careers they didn’t enter college imagining they would be choosing. Sometimes that is just a sort of maturation of practical interests, but also sometimes it is coming from a realization that paying student loans and such and not falling way behind on normal life stuff can be incredibly difficult on a public interest salary, not least if you want to do all this in a VHCOL city . . . .

And I have seen it happen all again coming out of highly selective law schools.

So I really think more kids with such interests need to be focused on these issues if they want to keep these paths open. Again, it is one thing if your family can pay whatever it costs and tell you it is fine to choose whatever next steps you like regardless of what that means for their immediate “return on investment”. But if money is tight I think you need to be very conscious of how this can all unfold.

5 Likes

I did a little research - the public defenders in Nashville undergrad:

MTSU and UTK lead the way, followed by Belmont and Tennessee State

For Atlanta - I can’t see a count, but the first three that come on linkedin are Tulane, Georgia State and U North Georgia

Bottom line - Emory isn’t holding the student back - period, end of story.

Any school - with any amount of debt - absolutely can.

2 Likes

As a parent of 2 HYP kids here is my advice. Yale is worth it but probably not Dartmouth or Brown. That being said if your need is higher than Yale is offering I would appeal the aid package. Also wait for Harvard aid before the appeal. We had Yale offer us a lot more aid after we appealed and gave them our Harvard aid package.

4 Likes

I can speak from first hand experience on this. I turned down two of HYS for law school and instead went to another extremely fine institution because I wanted to do public interest work. Stanford was my first choice school. The school I went to offered me a full tuition scholarship. I appealed to Stanford, they essentially said, if you were my kid, I’d tell them to go to other very fine law school. Which I did. It gave me a freedom to do public service work a long time. After 10 years, loan forgiveness paid off the loans I did take out but the payments were manageable for me because I had no tuition and lived frugally with my partner who worked while I was in law school.

I saw tons of peers who came into law school wanting to do things like me, but felt forced to take high salary big firm jobs to pay off their loans.

Tons of people thought I was nuts (including some of my own family) turning down Stanford and Harvard. But, it was one of the best decisions I ever made. Not a single thing that I wanted to do has been limited because of that choice. To the contrary, the lack of huge debt gave me incredible freedom.

What people often forget is that people like OP who get these great offers from schools like Emory and also get into Ivy League schools often have so much drive and talent that they can be just as successful, if not moreso, if they choose the “less” prestigious school. The same talent and work ethic that got them the scholarship, will help them succeed later in life as well. The freedom lack of debt provides someone interested in public service should not be underestimated.

20 Likes

Current Yale parent, went through financial aid negotiations. We have subsidized loans at the full amount (this is the kind where you don’t pay interest while in school) This amount varies depending on what year you are in in school : https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsidized

So that is $3500-$5500/year. You can get Yale to guarantee that their offer will be the same for all four years-- we did. They were very quick to match a more generous offer from H – just sent them the letter and they matched the next day. One more email and they confirmed the amount we would have to pay was guaranteed for 4 years

I strongly agree with the parent who said earlier that financial aid is very negotiable at this stage. It is true that Ivies technically do not match a merit aid offer or give out merit aid. And this set of schools is supposed to award based on need alone. But you would be surprised at how “need” can suddenly be recalculated, if you are lucky enough that they want you. Harvard was more generous than Yale for us, so just sit tight and see what they offer you. And then work on getting a matching offer.

I will say that our Yale award also increased over time, after I appealed in the second year due to the declining exchange rate (we live outside the US). And then they kept it at the more generous level as the currency went up and down.

My advice: go to Bulldog Days and Visitas (both schools should sponsor your trips). Take the train from Boston to New Haven. Schedule an appointment with financial aid and present your situation. Bring up to date financial records and documentation of your other financial aid offers.

Focus on any changes in your parents’ income, or perhaps expenses you did not mention in your CSSS-- does your family take care of other relatives or have they done this in the past? Are there medical expenses (past, anticipated) you did not specify? Are there other large expenditures that have happened recently or will happen?

This is the time when you have the most bargaining power-- they have admitted you, and they want you. They have a strong incentive to come up with additional funds and they have a $40 billion endowment. The worst case scenario is that they say no, but it certainly will not hurt to ask. While you are there, find out about other funding you might qualify for after you enroll – summer funding can be quite generous, for example (my kid has managed to get $5000 every summer). Are you interested in being a Froco (frosh residential counselor)? That program is quite competitive and only open to seniors but it will pay you $20,000 for the year. Make sure to meet with the FGLI office-- they will be your best resource re these additional sources of support.

You don’t have to make any decisions until May 1, so I would go to as many admitted student days as you are able to swing (again, the schools should fund these for you), check out the vibe on each campus, talk to students at each place about classes and outcomes, and then make a decision after all your aid offers are in, and after you have appealed everywhere. There is no rush to commit now-- take your time and get as much info as you can before deciding

Then sit down and take a hard look at the numbers. Is it really a $64,000 difference? Have they adequately calculated cost of travel, etc in those estimates? If you live across the country, flying back home in Oct, Nov, Dec, March for scheduled school breaks can definitely add up. How much can you realistically earn during school? Many students find it tough enough just to keep up with schoolwork. I would not count on being able to hold down a term time job for more than 5 hours/week to be totally honest. It also may not be worth it to take a job that pays $17/hr on campus during the term. My kid realized that there are better paying virtual jobs. Also, working commencement/reunions in May at Yale is nice-- you can earn $1000-$1500 during that spell, depending on what you sign up for. The long summer break will be your best bet for making some $. What kind of assistance will each university provide to help you get a good job in the summer?

It is also hard to say whether to think about $64,000 as a figure that will seem relatively insignificant to you down the line (like the cost of a car, as one of the earlier posters put it), or like a ball and chain that will significantly impact your choices in adulthood, as many are stressing. This really depends on what profession you choose, and of course that is hard to know at this point.

For the Ivy League grads headed for consulting, big law, Wall Street, etc, this is an amount they will be able to pay off easily and the ROI is a no brainer. This amount is diddly squat to them. But if you are not going towards one of those jobs and headed towards a line of work where you might make, say, $100,000/year well into your 40s then the calculus is different

You have a great set of schools to choose from–give yourself some time to decide and congrats!!!

20 Likes

Hands down, the best advice on this thread. ^^

3 Likes

I’m not so sure that this student is FGLI. It is difficult to tell based on their posts whether this is a low income or first generation family, but OP does currently attend a Title 1 school. In any case, if appropriate, connecting with that or similar offices during revisit days at any school is great idea not just in terms of understanding the aid package because in my understanding the FGLI offices can be very helpful in helping first generation and low income students transition into college. The office can provide not just financial resources, but counseling, mentorship, networking, and cohort formation. In particular, the office sometimes helps a FGLI student understand and access university resources that wealthier kids and kids of college educated parents know about and feel entitled to.

I imagine that some or even many of those things will come along with the merit scholarship at Woodruff, but the college transition can be uniquely challenging for FGLI students, and if Woodruff Scholars come from all income levels, it may not provide the same sort of supports or focus on belonging/imposter syndrome that Emory’s FGLI office does. A quick search indicates Emory has an EmoryFirst program and they might be a good place to check in with to find out what the transition from a title 1 school to Emory is like, and specifically find out more about what it is like to be both FGLI and a Woodruff scholar, which may (or may not) be an uncommon overlap.

5 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.