I know a couple of people personally who have gone to Utah, but most of my impressions are secondhand. @Twoin18 is a CA resident who has a performing arts kid at the U, IIRC, and might have helpful firsthand info for you. It just strikes me as a school that could hit the sweet spot for you in terms of combining affordability, depth and rigor in the performing arts, strong STEM, and an Honors program that really adds to the experience both academically and in terms of community. Also doesn’t hurt that it provides such a great combination of urban access with natural beauty and outdoor recreation. The greatest weakness I see (especially compared to the CA public U’s) is on the diversity front. (Although, that said, my d applied to U of Colorado, somehow picturing the flagship in famously-liberal Boulder as more diverse than the one in surprisingly-progressive-yet-also-somewhat-conservative SLC… and it turns out that their diversity stats are really about the same.)
@eyemgh also has a lot of good info about Utah; his kid is at SLO but came very close to choosing the U - they come from more of an engineering perspective but might have some thoughts about the math side of things.
I think Utah is one of the most underrated programs out there. It’s a pretty campus, in a pretty location, with an international airport. Students are very passionate about school sports, even gymnastics. Lot’s of their programs are very solid academically, including both math and music. They are also generous with merit money.
I think it gets overlooked because non-LDS families (we are not LDS) fear the influence of the Mormon church. SLC is actually less than 50% LDS, and quite liberal. There are lots of good restaurants and many outdoorsy things to do.
My main concern would be the ability to double or even minor with music. Top notch music programs are very intensive. Like top engineering programs, there is very little room for other classes.
I’d apply, see what sort of package you get and visit if you get the money you’d need to make it work.
“My main concern would be the ability to double or even minor with music. Top notch music programs are very intensive. Like top engineering programs, there is very little room for other classes.”
I’d agree with this generally, ballet is the same. But fortunately at Utah most of the math sequence courses and quite a few electives are offered in the summer, and if you aren’t able to take the sequence course because of a conflict, then you can take it in the summer instead. That is not true for engineering or some of the other lab-based sciences. It would have been relatively straightforward for my D to double major in math (which is something she considered) going in with a 5 in Calc BC (she did Honors Calc 3 the first semester which is the third sequence course out of 7). There is a thread on this in the dance major forum (http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/dance-major/2105606-double-majoring-with-a-dance-bfa.html).
The key thing for merit aid at Utah is to get a great ACT/SAT score.
@zoekirbymikey@Coloradomama Thanks for the recommendations on U of Kansas. I personally know some very good musicians who graduated from KU, both undergrad and grad studies (church/organ music and Musicology, respectively). One actually claimed, when I asked him how good the music program was, that it was “better than anything out here” (which I consider a pretty lofty claim, considering we have CSUN, San Francisco Conservatory, USC, and UCLA…) Anyway, you brought up the possibility of full tuition. What I understood was I’d only be able to get the OOS tuition waiver, plus any departmental scholarships. Are there full tuition scholarships for OOS students available through the office of financial aid? If so I’m definitely interested.
@aquapt@Twoin18@eyemgh thanks for the recommendations on U of Utah. I’m really interested as I had not encountered Utah before in my search! So far I’m pretty impressed with the things I’m finding, and I like the scholarship opportunities. Test scores I think are going to be my key to merit aid which is one of the reasons I’m mostly looking at state universities. Actually, I’m not hugely worried about the diversity front, as my being from CA might indicate. I think I’m more worried about wilting at a hugely liberal school like Oberlin, although I am not worried about most schools as long as they’re big enough. Correct me if I’m wrong but most state schools seem to indicate you can find your niche if you look.
What about a BA double major? BA music, with voice emphasis, and BA mathematics. My understanding is BA math requires fewer courses than BS math, and I will enter college with Calc BC (AB subscore) and Physics 1 APs. My musical training may allow me to bypass at least one semester of music theory (allowed sister who also was in LACC to bypass first 2 semesters at U of Kentucky). I understand BA music is less intensive than BM degrees, or even BME with all the student teaching requirements.
At Utah the difference between a BA and a BS is that the former requires a language class, the latter two upper level quantitative classes. If you are doing math then the quant classes are part of your major already. So a BA is actually more work.
BFAs (and BMus) are exempted from both, but are audition based entry and have a much longer list of required classes (hence less general ed). But if you do a double degree like a BFA first major and a BA/BS for the second major, I think you have to fulfill the general ed requirements for both degrees. The conclusion is to not do a BA and a BS as your double major if you have a choice.