<p>Both of my sons were extremely bright kids who also were academic underachievers. Both said they wanted to go to college right after high school.</p>
<p>I went way out of my way to help older S apply to colleges that he liked, including doing apps for merit aid. By helping him, I mean that I did virtually all of the research for colleges, and then stood over him while he did the apps. He then went to a college that he loved (and also had virtually full merit aid), and flunked out because he partied too much. At 24, he has never returned to college.</p>
<p>I learned my lesson, and did not stand over younger S to make sure that he got his apps in on time. He missed the deadlines, but within weeks had lined up an Americorps position for himself in our hometown. He loved community service, and the position was perfect for him.</p>
<p>He lived at home, paid rent ($50 a week so that he developed a reasonable idea about how far a stipend goes), and followed the same rules we’d have imposed on an adult longterm guest. He matured a great deal, too. </p>
<p>He got some wonderful skills including grant writing. He got to represent his agency at meetings where typically he was the youngest person present, organized events, and went on two business trips for training, including an out of state one that he had to fly to.</p>
<p>He learned a great deal about what he likes doing, and what he doesn’t like doing. He also saw the connection between school and work, such as learning that just as one has to write reports for school, one has to do the same thing for work, and his supervisors weren’t as tolerant of lateness as were his teachers (He almost hadn’t graduated from h.s. because of the backlog of late lab reports and similar homework that he had to get in at the last minute). </p>
<p>Because his grades had gone into such a slump his senior year, H and I told him that we wouldn’t pay for his first year of college. S managed to get some merit aid to the LAC of his choice, but also had to take out loans – large loans-- to pay for that.</p>
<p>In college, he handled with great maturity having a difficult roommate, and also was active in several ECs (including some activities that he had never tried before) that included facilitating a weekend leadership workshop for a club, being on the board of a campus-wide organization, having a major role in some fundraising events, and organizing a team that made a film for the campus movie fest. He also worked a parttime job, and managed to end the year with a 3.3 average, not bad for a guy whose h.s. gpa was about a 2.7 unweighted.</p>
<p>This summer, he is working parttime at the place where he was an Americorps volunteer, and has been given the task of organizing a one-week summer camp. He gathered a team of volunteers, and planned the program, and got flyers, an application, and a publicity article completed within less than 10 days. </p>
<p>I’m convinced that the gap year was a good choice.</p>