@PengsPhils Really great analysis, thank you so much.
Yes, I’m using CSRankings quite a lot, amazing pie charts for overall faculty and for academician’s papers. However, for example, when you choose computer vision and machine learning and click on NYU, you don’t see Rob Fergus and Yann Lecun at all. When I searched CV and ML papers on Microsoft Research I saw that the papers of Rob Fergus and Yann Lecun are under the name of “Courant Institute”. I don’t know maybe that’s the reason, or the website only considers only some specific conferences and leaves out the others. So CsRankings are pretty good, but it can make you miss out some colleges.
The reason I’m even considering BU next to NEU is because of CSRankings actually. But I don’t know is CSRankings is skipping some people from NEU, as well.
@gearmom
Michael Black is a great researcher but I think (I’m not sure though) he is currently residing in Germany. He’s working for the Max Planck Institute and all of his research students were from Germany when I last checked. I don’t know about Hayes and Sudderth though, I’ll check them now. Thank you. And the Quora link you sent me has some amazing info I’ll definitely check all the universities that are mentioned there as well.
@simba9 I would definitely consider the University of Washington. It is a great university, however, at Seattle campus they only offer a BS/MS combined program for computer science, and they only have a standalone professional MS and Data Science MS program which doesn’t fit me, unfortunately. I’ll check up on USC though. Read about it, but never had the chance to deeply investigate. Thanks!
@mathmom CMU is like the top of the top when ML /CV is considered, I am not sure if I would have any chance there, what do you think?
@mabelpines Looks like you are correct about Black. A Brown researcher currently residing in Germany. Also via Brown website Hays and Sudderth moved to GTech and UIUC.
Oddly after looking, NEU and BU are prominent in ranking but do not seem to have featured visionary CV giants.
For your cities, America has nothing like Istanbul. Our biggest NYC is half the population. And just a consideration, our more diverse cities are sometimes the most segregated, Chicago, Baltimore, Atlanta.
What is your career goal? What are your stats? If you could get into CMU, I’d learn to love Pittsburg.
My goal is to pursue a PhD and work in a research lab or institute. I have 3.35/4.00 GPA which I know is not high and my references are from my 3 professors who had their PhDs from UCB, BU and Brown. I worked as a teaching assistant for 3 years for math courses at my university and have a minor in math. Did an internship at Turkcell, a telecommunications company that owns Turkey’s biggest data center.
So basically, I can easily be rejected due to low GPA and lack of research experience. I don’t know if it’s easier to be accepted with a Fulbright, or it doesn’t add anything in terms of your chances of acceptance.
@mabelpines CS for undergrad is indeed very hard to get into. I have no idea however what admissions to graduate level study are like. I assume since you have a Fulbright that your credentials are pretty stellar. And being a woman will be a plus.
Seems around 5% for computer science @mathmom, which is quite selective for master’s as well. So, I don’t know if I should give it a go. I would definitely if I had infinitely many chances but I only have 4 so I have to use them carefully even if that means giving up on some options that I would really like to try.
@mabelpines I forgot where it was on your list but I would keep NYU high. NYC would truly keep your interest and be the only similar city to an Istanbul. It has big thinkers in CV. You’re going for grad school not an undergrad so I don’t think the campus would be so critical. My son’s friend goes there for CS and is perfectly happy. I’m sure you’re already street smart. You won’t walk through the Bronx with your new iPhone out. And I think you could get in. It should have enough international prestige to be meaningful where ever you go. That was one of the things for preferring Brown over NEU (which I do like as a school) is a bigger and better known reputation which might be a factor for an international. Though I think both have the open curriculum for grad school which you said you’d like.
Yeah, although NYU is not so high on rankings I’ll hold on to that, I think the rankings are skipping some excellent professors because their papers are under Courant Instıtute. @gearmom
Yeah, it does appear that CSRankings are missing some people, so looking to confirm is certainly a good idea. And yes, Courant Institute = NYU.
Re CMU and cash cows: Many foreign students use it as a way to validate their undergrad degree, and not for graduate research. Given selectivity, I would not apply there.
Based on everything so far, I would make sure that you apply to schools like a US undergrad would - have a safety school, a match school, and two reaches. I can’t say what exactly the chances are, but I think taking that approach would be pretty safe. Here are my recommendations:
NYU seems like a great option based on the researchers there for your area, the city, and it’s not impossible to get into like some. That could be considered your match school.
For your reaches, it looks like Georgia Tech, UMD, UW, USC, and UT-Austin all are great CS options. I would pick 2 of those. I don’t think there’s a wrong choice here, so use your best judgment and pick 2 of these as you prefer.
If you pick two, you’re left with your safety. This should be a school without a big CS name who also has researchers in the area. I think BU fits this bill, though I can’t confirm their acceptance rate. However, the team below appears to be more than sufficient in terms of conducting good research relevant to you.
@PengsPhils For her reaches, if she is ruling out the hot ones (our family is the same with heat and sun - would be hard for me also), UT-A, GTech, USC and then she ruled out UW (or Seattle would have been a cool choice). What should her new reaches be? Would you add UIUC back on? She is worried about size. Add U of Michigan even though Ann Arbor is smaller than Providence. At least with Providence you’d have other fun cities to explore. People make the hour train ride to Boston every day for work and it is no big deal. UMD, she stated her concerns about Baltimore. We have family in a very wealthy area of Baltimore and they find it just O’k. Should she add Princeton on for a reach? That is a lovely area but not a city like NYC.
So with her criteria, not really big, not hot and sunny, good nearby city for fun, seems to like an eclectic vibe. Maybe she should contact Felzenszwab at Brown just to see. He might be looking for a grad student to work with and they might really hit it off. Her admission would likely be holistic (the Brown way) so be a female Fulbright scholar from Turkey could definitely work in her favor inspite of her GPA and it has the open curriculum she likes. Boston and NYC would be more fun but also you might need to consider or be aware of cost of living. Those are not inexpensive areas. At this point maybe getting a feel for her potential advisor should factor in more. I’d choose a great advisor over a more fun city or just rankings. She is only there for two years.
For CV/ML specifically, I would go BU over Northeastern for Masters / Ph.D. Northeastern has the far superior undergraduate program, and if you’re planning to go into software development, data mining, networks, systems, or PL research, it’s the right call for the Masters. The one weaker area at Northeastern just happens to be the AI/ML/CV area. In this case, that’s really all that matters.
It doesn’t seem like size is a huge factor - the concern seemed to be attention, which top CS departments at large schools get plenty of.
Ah, I did not see that on the weather. If those are true eliminators, then some other options would be UMD, Columbia, and UPenn. Personally, It sounds like Columbia and UMD would be the best two, all things considered. Baltimore isn’t a perfect city, but the research strength there in this area is incredible.
So if the weather is a true eliminator, it would be NYU, BU, UMD, Columbia. I would highly recommend trying to get around that though, as it does really eliminate a lot of good options.
As far as Brown goes, it doesn’t hit the city factor and the chance of it hitting the research area factor is slim. Reaching out to Felzenszwab can’t hurt, but even if that works out, why go there instead of NYU if you can find a good advisor/research there as well, given the criteria? So I would reach out to him only if there is a struggle to reach out at the two selected reaches that fit both of the primary criteria here. Whatever 2 reaches are selected, I think reaching out to the relevant professors before the decision is a very good idea.
@PhelpsPhan I think @mabelpines needs to prioritize the importance of city. I would definitely chose NYU over Brown. I think I might put that as number one. But seeing her leaning towards U of Michigan and a place like Brown for fit. I’m not sure. There are plenty of kabob places in Providence especially College Hill https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurants-g60946-zfn8452-Providence_Rhode_Island.html and they have an Istanbul Market https://www.yelp.com/biz/istanbul-gourmet-north-providence. She wouldn’t be in the boondocks. But perhaps Columbia should eclipse Brown unless Felzenszswab really wants her and he might. Columbia would be a better location for fun. If her choices come down to a Columbia, NYU, Brown, BU. It would be easy enough to travel here and visit them. That would be very doable. Probably the best thing for such a big investment and any of those would be impressive for future studies.
@mabelpines You are a really impressive grad school candidate. Very thoughtful and thorough analysis on your part. Let us know how this turns out.
@gearmom and @PengsPhils I can’t thank you enough for such amazing feedback. I can’t write to schools because of IIE. (the institution that will apply to schools on my behalf) I don’t know this is a stupid rule they have, they contact all the schools for you and you don’t get to have a say about it. I hope someday Fulbright finds a way to remove this rule. I’ll update here when I decide on the unis. Thanks a lot again!
Oh and one final question, really sorry I’ve already taken too much of your time but why does nobody talk about D.C. when UMD is the topic? Like everybody talks about how bad the roads are in College Park, how it doesn’t feel safe at all, how Baltimore is bad, how everybody just wants to party all the time. (I don’t know why this is even an issue just don’t hang out with the party people if you don’t like them but I’ve seen quite a lot of people complaining about this so this must be an issue?) But literally nobody says: “It’s a great school, we have a metro stop right outside the campus that directly goes into D.C.” Is it that bad out there that they can’t even focus on the nice things? Or are there problems with the underground services that makes it too much of a hassle to deal with? Or is D.C. not worth it (although I don’t think it’s quite possible)?
D.C. is a great place to visit. A national treasure with plenty of free things to do like museums and monuments and activities. The cons would be cost, expensive restaurants, terrible traffic, a high crime and high poverty rate (embarrassingly).
The travel to get into the city is also a full hour. More or less the same time as Providence to Boston. In other words, it’s an occasional day trip, not your daily life, which is UMD’s campus, as you likely wouldn’t spend time directly in Baltimore the same way you would spend time in a school in the heart of Boston, NYC, etc.
@PengsPhils You don’t think Baltimore is a little seedy? I don’t know about suggesting an international female student go College Park. Of all the places in America to go to. As a mother, I would not be excited about that
All cities are dangerous to some level. You need to have street smarts whether you’re in NYC, Boston, Baltimore, Detriot, or any major city. Baltimore is more so than others mentioned here, hence why someone would likely stick more to campus, as mentioned above. In my experience, most dangers of cities are far overstated. What parts you are in make a big difference as well. For example, many people cite concerns about Chicago and gun violence, but if you’re in Lincoln Park, it’s probably much safer than picking a lesser neighborhood of any city considered “safer” generally. You mentioned exactly that about visiting Philadelphia. When I visit there, I regularly use city amenities and go to cool places like the Reading Terminal Market, for example. Just because parts of the city are not 100% safe does not make the city unusable or too dangerous to go to. Especially for someone already familiar with city life.