Give some tips to a foreign student?

Hey, everyone

First, thank you for reading this, I think it’s going to be a bit long.

I recently received a Fulbright scholarship for a master’s degree in the United States. I’m 22, female and from Turkey. (a country between Greece and Iraq if you’ve never heard of it before.) I have bachelor’s degree in computer science and engineering and I want to focus on machine learning applications of computer vision for research.

I’m going to apply to universities via an institution called IIE. And apparently, I have only 4 choices. The problem is I’ve never been to the United States before and I have absolutely 0 inside info to help me decide.

Here’s what I’m looking for:

University - Most public universities in Turkey are overcrowded and lack in terms of having academicians that are supportive and attentive with their students. I went to a private university with around 4000 total students and I think my friends and my teachers believed in me more than I do myself. Every year our university president takes successful freshman students to M.I.T for a 2-week summer school. I expect a similar university environment from schools that I’m going to apply. However, I don’t know if I can expect a supportive environment from a huge college. For example, University of Michigan, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, University of Texas at Austin, University of Maryland College-Park are all pretty good colleges in machine learning applications of computer vision, but they are HUGE. So, to have a more supportive environment should I go for more smaller colleges in the U.S. too? And can you give some examples?

City - I would like to be in a city or close to a city where there are many cultural activities to do. The thing about I loved my city (Istanbul) was that you can go to a super underground art gallery opening that also has a kebab restaurant next to. Or you can watch both Morrissey and Madonna on the same stage. I don’t want to be in a city where the only event is the big football game and only places to go are bars.

Until now, university-wise my favorite has been UC- Berkeley although the hugeness factor scares me a bit. But San Francisco is perfect, the climate is pretty good (my favorite season is Fall btw), UCB has Jitendra Malik - a great professor who has pioneered in machine learning applications of computer vision. Student-and-school-energy-wise my favorite has been Brown. But Providence is a question mark and I’m not sure if Brown is good for studying computer vision. So I would appreciate any university suggestions and tips you could give. Thanks again!

I forgot to say; I don’t consider applying to UC Berkeley since they only have an MS/PhD combined program and only accept around 20 exceptional students for an alone MS program, so I don’t think I have a chance

@mabelpines I am local to Brown. To better understand you, what is your apprehension about Providence? Then I will expand on suggestions.

@mabelvision I have some time for the next few minutes. Let me sketch out Providence/Brown/Rhode Island. Not sure of your religion or if that is at all factoring in. I have friends from Turkey who are Christian but also know plenty of people who are Muslim who live in Rhode Island. First assume that everyone knows about Turkey. If you are Muslim, Rhode Island is kind of a spunky little state. It was founded for religious tolerance way back when. It is my experience that the Muslim population here is a professional crowd. University professors, doctors, etc… It is a liberal place and most everyone will likely be very careful to be nice. A city is a city but it wouldn’t be a place I would really worry about the safety of my daughter too much.

In Providence, you have other colleges such as Providence College and RISD (a well known arts school). So there can be a college feel to the city. There are definitely artsy theaters where you can see art house movies in comfy chairs. Thayer Street is fun favorite with college students. Westminster St. and the bookstores. A diverse range of restaurants. I don’t know how people do it but they seem to be going out to dinner all the time. Federal Hill is an Italian section of Providence with a large number of Italian restaurants and supplies and a brick out door eating area.

Spring through Fall, Providence will have something called Waterfire. There is a canal that runs through the city and they light torches on the canal. It is supposed to be reminiscent of Venice. It is like a big celebration. They will haven’t free public concerts. We saw Marian Hill perform this summer. Sometimes they have fireworks. Right near by is the Providence Place Mall, a large nice mall.

Rhode Island is the Ocean State with a long shoreline and largest Bay. All four seasons but not as cold as Boston in the winter because the nearby water provides a thermal buffer. Nearby, places of interest are Newport, Boston, Martha’s Vineyard and reachable New York City. Newport, think Great Gatsby. Larger Mansions that can be toured. Sailing, a famous Cliffwalk along the shore and mansions. A seaport town which has nice shopping and restaurants though upscale and pricey. Tennis Hall of fame. Polo matches late spring through fall which are fun to take a picnic blanket and picnic basket to. Usually the announcer is pretty funny.

Music Scene: Providence still has an alternative music scene. For main stream, there is the Dunkin Donuts Center in Providence, the Xfinity Center north in Massachusetts, Boston and for an adventure, NYC.

Shopping: Plenty of malls but for awesome value go a half hour north to the Wrentham Mall. An outdoor mall with a large of premium outlets. Amazing value. I think people who visit Boston purposely go there.

Boston is an easy train ride away. Maybe an hour. That is one of my favorite cities. Martha’s Vineyard is a fast ferry away. A vacation island that you can bike or kayak on. Known for the wealthy people who go but actually started as one of the first place black (wealthy) American could buy a home. It is on the National Black Historic sites list and has an interesting community of Gingerbread summer houses. President Obama visits and Spike Lee has an enormous house there. Also known for the Kennedy family. Not really a pretentious place. And you can visit for a good value early fall and late spring.

New York City is probably a 3 to 4 hour bus ride from Providence. You could go for the day. My college student went there and it was very inexpensive. Saw a great concert and Broadway theater, museums. He stayed at an airbnb. Not sure if NYC still allows airbnb though. So much to do in NYC.

For your major, you should contact LEMS @Brown directly. You are a prospective grad student and you have questions… https://vision.lems.brown.edu/content/welcome-computer-vision-lems

Also look at Carnegie Mellon university. @mathmom I think can tell you more about that.

Wow thanks for the great answer. I was afraid of Providence not being diverse enough to find something to do, you know like a city where people go after they are retired. I am not a religious person at all. But numerous times local people I met in some European cities stopped talking to me when they found out I’m from Turkey. Unfortunately, to some people, it doesn’t even matter who you are as a person. And since the U.S. is so much further away from Turkey with respect to Europe, I’m a bit worried about people’s reactions. I hope I managed to explain myself.

@mabelpines I’m not sure anyone retires to Providence. They all head to Florida. I can’t imagine a single person in Providence having an issue with Turkey. Europe would be a different animal for political/immigration issues. Completely different here. The city has more diversity than the rest of the state which is majority white but I think it is better integrated than other places. For example, for preschool for your kids you’d look for and try to find a school that has a diverse classroom. I don’t think it is a place with racial tension. People are chill.

With a bunch of good colleges, I can’t imagine being bored but it is not like New York City. A place that never sleeps. And of course the colleges themselves have plenty of events. Check out the Brown and RISD event calendar. There is a theater district in Providence also.

I’m confused as to what your four choices are, as you mention a number of schools in your post.

@mabelpines If you were the kind of person who stopped talking to a person because they were from Turkey, you would be socially ostracized in this area especially among the educated set. Wouldn’t worry about that for Boston or Providence. More cosmopolitan and liberal than that. I mean a place like Massachusetts worries about not being nice enough to chickens. Are their lives happy enough before you eat them? Do they get to be free on the range. People will be carefully nice as a generality.

*my second post should have said, they HAVE free music concerts in Providence.

@mabelpines Sent you a private message

@gearmom Boston and Providence look pretty awesome, hehe loved the chicken example. It is a relief knowing people will not ask me whether I’m going to school riding a camel.

@AroundHere I have not completely decided yet. I’ll have a Skype conversation with someone from the IIE to finalize my list. The institution also has a right to interfere with the list i.e. they may leave a college because it is too overachieving and add a more suitable one. That’s why I’m considering many colleges; because if the institution wants to replace one of the schools in my list with another one, I want to have an idea about their suggested school as well. If I were to make a list right now I think it would go like this:

  1. Columbia University or NYU (NYC colleges. Columbia has Shih-Fu Chang, NYU has Yann Lecun and Rob Fergus. Courant Institute seems pretty cool, although no-campus environment of NYU scares me a bit.)

  2. Boston University or Northeastern University (BU has Stan Sclaroff, Northeastern because I got the impression that their CS department is better. And there were no core courses at NEU which is great. More freedom is always appreciated.)

  3. One of the big sized schools. I’m still pretty confused about those. Do they just have good names or the schools really support you: I still don’t know. I have UIUC which makes me question Champaign, UMD College-Park, which is always mentioned in crime reports and budget cuts. U of M, not good at computer vision as UIUC or UMD College-Park but somehow seems more appealing to me. And of course, University of Texas at Austin. Best school-wise and city-wise. (I don’t know Austin seems really nice, I even loved how their motto is “keep Austin weird.” Am I missing something horrible?) But, the weather is a huge problem. I have a mother and a granddad who can’t stay even in the shadows wearing 50+ SPF sunscreen without getting complete lobster red swollen skin and ending up in the hospital. I am not as sensitive as them, but I have pretty fair skin as well and to be honest I hate the heat. I am not a huge fan of the sun either.

  4. One of the UC colleges, or UPenn or Brown. UPenn is much better in general for computer vision and machine learning, but they seem to work on these two subjects separetely. I got the impression that computer vision belongs to robotics and machine learning belongs to A.I. and they don’t collaborate. On the other hand Brown doesn’t seem overall very good at computer vision. However, there is Pedro F. Felzenszwalb factor. And although Philadelphia is a much bigger city with respect to Providence, I just can’t help but like Brown. And after finding out Providence has pretty much everything to offer, I’m even more leaning towards Brown. Can’t tell much about the UC colleges, they are still pretty unknown territory to me except UC Berkeley and UC Los Angeles. And I don’t think I would ever have a shot at UCB or UCLA.

@mabelpines Oh the chicken example was a real life problem in Massachusetts. They voted in last year’s election to prohibit the sale of eggs from chickens confined in a cruel manner.

Overall Brown is in a different league for computer science compared to BU or Northeastern. I’m not sure I would choose the later two if cost was not a factor. It certainly has more international prestige than a BU or Northeastern which can be more workmanlike. You need to see if you would be a big fish in their small pond. Contact the noted professors. See what your opportunities would be.

And I would not be really comfortable in Philadelphia. A much higher crime rate than Boston or Providence for example (i.e. murder rate Philly ~300, Boston ~70, and Providence ~15 per year) When we go to Philly, we go in, do something and we go out. A nicer area in that part of America would be Princeton.

My female relatives who attended college in NYC ended up getting mugged several times but as a parent I would more comfortable sending a daughter to NYC than Philadelphia.

Also Professor Michael Black for Brown.

I got tagged to show up here. Have you looked at Carnegie Mellon? When my son graduated (undergrad) from the school of comp sci I noticed that most of the Masters grads were internationals. Pittburgh is an up and coming city with very pretty residential areas. Carnegie Mellon is near the art museum and a gorgeous park. Weatherwise, it’s not as cold as Boston or as hot as Austin. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/12/travel/pittsburgh-pennsylvania-rust-belt-arts-culture-budget-travel.html?_r=0

@mabelpines For #2 I’d choose Northeastern. Better campus in the middle of the middle of the city. BU doesn’t have a great campus.

@mabelpines

Some comments on your possible schools:

As far as state schools, often graduates get a good deal of attention - that stereotype often applies more to undergrads than grads. The grad departments are what actually create those reputations.

Based on your notes and preferences, I would consider both UT-Austin, UMD, and U of M. Both of the first two have strength in your areas, both are in cities, and while Baltimore is not perfect, it’s not something to avoid on that alone. U of M is in Ann Arbor, which is not a full-scale city but is still a good place for students with a decent amount to do. I would say it’s comparable to Providence. I don’t see anything you’re missing with UT, so that would still be in the lead for me.

BU vs Northeastern - I am a Northeastern CS undergrad (actually combined BS/MS so I’ve taken 4 graduate CS courses now) who has worked professionally in a research setting (internal research lab for a big company in California), so hopefully I can speak to these (I looked at BU, chose Northeastern for CS over it, but again, for undergrad).

Northeastern is specifically known primarily for its strength in PL. It is the home to Matthias Felleisen, and it maintains Racket in conjunction with Brown. A lot of its strength permeates from that, as seen by its undergraduate teaching philosophy on programming [1]. When it comes to AI and CV, I can’t say I’ve seen the same strength reflected in undergrad, though I’m not by any means aware of all the research here. When it comes to BU, their department had a lot less strength generally when I looked last (2014), but I’m not sure of what their specific specialties are. My advice here would be to really look at AI and CV at both to get a better idea - even if BU has a generally not quite as strong program, they still may be stronger in your specific area.

[1] http://www.ccs.neu.edu/home/matthias/Thoughts/Growing_a_Programmer.html

[2] http://csrankings.org/

If you look at [2] above and change the filters to show all so BU appears (#53), you find that 25% of their research in the past 10 years has been in Vision, and ML makes up a good chunk too. It’s actually their top two research areas. While Northeastern’s total output is higher (ranked #21 for the same time range), you see that the research is a lot more distributed, and Vision + ML make up about 10% total. BU actually publishes more value in ML and Vision together than Northeastern, even though Northeastern publishes a lot more generally.

That site above would be a great tool to filter down your options by subfield. It’s not perfect, as research output isn’t a direct link even for a MS, but it’s a good data point.

Looking at just filtering for ML and CV, here is where the relevant colleges stand by pure numbers via the site above:
CMU - 1
UCB - 2
UT Austin - 7
Columbia - 9
UIUC - 11
UofM - 14
UMD - 18
BU - 21
NYU - 33
Northeastern - 36
Brown - 53

This is ranking, not number of papers, etc. Look there and you also get an interesting story. CMU 64, UIUC 15, Brown 3. So the tippy top really does have a lot more output here when it comes to research.

The lesson here is that when you are at this specialized a level, standard rankings should go out the door a bit, and you can hyperfocus on concentrations. As seen in the top 20 or so, many stay the same. With BU / Northeastern / Brown, they actually reverse order for this specific area of CS in terms of pure publication strength.

A school not mentioned here is Georgia Tech, which comes in at #4 for CV and Machine learning. I would consider it, as it’s also located in a major city (Atlanta).

On top of all this, if you’re planning to focus on the research side, a single professor could be the difference when decision time comes, so make sure to reach out to possible options once you have acceptances back.

Speaking as a fellow lover of cities going to college in Boston with many people I know coming from Providence, and meaning no disrespect to Providence, I don’t think it really fits the city aspects of what you are looking for.

It’s certainly no slouch and I think it’s fair to say it’s overlooked often for people looking for something in the middle of NYC and farmland (which is often the extreme presented). However, many of the responses given by gearmom would be seen as unacceptable to a city lover. The Xfinity center is actually outside of Boston, and it’s considered far for someone in Boston. Boston has at least four main venues (The Sinclair, Paradise Rock Club, House of Blues, The Middle East) all accessible by public transportation, and that doesn’t even include stadium shows at TD Garden, etc. I’m focusing on music because I think it reflects more generally on the size differences.

Look at this for scale:
Istanbul: 15M people
Boston: 5M people
Providence 1.6M people

Boston will already be a 3 times smaller city than you are accustomed to. Providence would be nearly 10 times smaller.

Again, I mean no disrespect for Providence - it’s simply a different experience. You do indeed have train access to Boston, but traveling there regularly just doesn’t happen for most. It’s inconvenient to take a $20 or more round trip plus 2 hours to get into the city, and you won’t be doing that just to grab a kebab around the corner - you have to live in Boston to get that experience or find a place in Providence.

All this said, Brown does indeed have a fantastic CS department. To me, the question becomes then how you weight the importance of the city life with the CS strength. But as shown above, it may not be the best choice for your particular interest, so I think Brown may actually not be a good option for you at all in this specific case.

@PengsPhils That is an excellent analysis. Boston would be more fun and if it is academically stronger, the only reason to choose Brown may be fit.

Indeed @gearmom, fit always as well, for all schools mentioned.

One correction: The rankings of ML / CV are from the past 5 years, not the past 10. I narrowed this range due to the speed of the field, particularly with ML. If a college hasn’t published much in the past 5 but did a bunch of stuff 10 years ago, it’s not quite as relevant. You can tune the time range as you see fit.

@PengsPhils This is what I sent her. It listed very specific Brown professors including Felzenszwalb, Hayes, Sudderth and Michael Black ( Max Planck Institute and Brown University adjunct professor.) Especially interesting CV Phd student Mert Killckaya list of visionary CV professors.

https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-best-schools-for-studying-computer-vision

Think this is O’k for CC after reviewing terms.

Nothing wrong with Brown for graduate-level CS.

I know the University of Washington in Seattle has a very active machine learning group, and I’d have to think the school is big enough to offer opportunities in computer vision. Usually schools in areas with a very active tech scene, like Seattle, have all kinds of interesting CS research going on.

The University of Southern California in Los Angeles is another to look at. From reading the alumni magazines they send me, it looks like there’s a lot of fantastic graduate-level research going on in computer vision, machine learning, robotics, etc. It’s also one of those schools where it’s easier to get in as a graduate student than as an undergrad.