Grade/Comment on my practice SAT essay please?

<p>If you have free time and some experience with this, can you please grade and comment on my practice SAT essay? Let me know if you’re doing it out of 6 or out of 12, and it’d be great if you can give some feedback on things that I can improve in my writing. Thanks in advance!</p>

<p>Prompt: Is there always another explanation or another point of view?</p>

<pre><code>In regards to any situation or belief, there can always be another explanation or point of view. An explanation or point of view that is generally accepted may not always be correct, and even so, other alternate explanations or point of views may simultaneously be valid. As demonstrated by the example of the discovery of DNA to be the genetic material, there can always be alternate explanations or other points of views.

Before the incredible capabilities of DNA—deoxyribose nucleic acid—were understood by scientists, it was treated as merely another substance found in the human body and left unexamined. Then, through further research, scientists limited the substances that can serve as genetic material down to two—proteins and DNA. Comparatively, much was known about proteins at the time, and miserably little about DNA. Plus, proteins seemed to have far greater variety, as they could be made of 20 different amino acids compared to the 4 different nucleotides that make up DNA. Thus, in the early 1900s, the vast majority of scientists simply assumed that proteins, not DNA, were the genetic material in living organisms. However, when a pair of scientists named Hershey and Chase conducted an experiment in which they labelled the protein coat of bacteriophages with radioactive sulfur and the DNA in those bacteriophages with radioactive phosphorous, they found, to their utter surprise, that radioactive phosphorous—not sulfur—was present in the bacteria infected by these bacteriophages. Thus, Hershey and Chase concluded that DNA was the source of genetic material, not proteins, contrary to the mainstream belief in the scientific community. Through their experiment, Hershey and Chase found an alternate point of view and a different explanation for genetic inheritance, one that they adamantly supported despite the numerous nonbelievers in the scientific community. Thus, their experience shows that alternate explanations and points of views are certainly always possible, and that it is important to be open to these different perspectives. Just because a perspective is generally accepted does not necessarily mean that it is right, or that no other perspectives are possible.
</code></pre>

<p>*Note: I wrote this on standard college-ruled lined paper, and it’s only 1 page (exactly) in my handwriting. Is that too short?</p>

Anyone please?

4/6.
I think it’s a bit short. You should have 400~ words and your current word count is 344 so I would suggest expanding it.
As for the context, the example is great but I feel that the top half of the example has too much excess information. Rather you should focus on the bottom half part that actually proves your thesis. Also if you’re going to give a single example make sure it has no loose knots because it’s the only body you have. I wouldnt risk it though and will very much write two/three examples.

Apart from all the biological terms, there is little to no tough vocabulary so yeah that’s a minus aswell.
Keep improving!

If you added anoter example you could be at a 5, but as of now, I would say 4
Lots of unnecessary info about Hershey-Chase, although we AP Bio kids love it :wink:

@Daemonox , yeah I’m aware it’s a bit short. I just am not that fast of a writer :frowning:
Okay, I was planning on having 2 examples and I included another one in my intro but I ran out of time so I had to cross that part out.
As for the vocab, I usually just write down the words that pop into my head first, which usually aren’t vocab words. Do you have any tips for including those?

@metsfan9‌ : Okay, thanks for your input! I was planning to have another example but I ran out of time unfortunately :frowning:
Ahaha, I think that’s cause I recently had a test on that stuff so it’s all stuck in my head right now. :stuck_out_tongue:
What do you think I could improve on besides having another examples that would help me get a 6?

I think another well-written example will get you an 11 at least

Okay @metsfan9‌

@SnowCookie‌ its a really good example but i think if you maybe take out some detail, then you will have enough time to develop another solid body paragraph. If you have an intro, two bodies (with that level writing/description), and a short conclusion, I think that will be a consistent 5 or 6.

as for your vocab, it’s pretty good; in your other body, you could sprinkle a few SAT vocab words here and there also.

thoughts on mine?

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/sat-preparation/1726915-sat-essay-feedback-scoring.html#latest

Okay, thanks for your feedback @college123college! I couldn’t get your link to work though?