Grinnell v. Sarah Lawrence v. Skidmore v. kenyon?

So I’ve left my decision off for the last minute. Mostly because I got wait listed at my top two schools, UChicago and Vassar. Now I’m trying to decide between these four. What do you guys think?
I like the arts a lot, I’m really into Theater and want to be in an orchestra. Also, for my major, I’m thinking maybe English, History, Russian Studies, or Political Science. I’m way more interested in the humanities. I’m more of a city girl from the Midwest so I’d prefer a city, which is why it’s hard for me to get over the location of everywhere but Sarah Lawrence. I’ve visited them all but skidmore. I’d prefer less of a party campus, and like an academically challenging and rigorous but not too competitive environment. What do you think?

Location wise, Skidmore isn’t so bad either. Saratoga is a really nice town with a lot of culture, and the town and the students have a good relationship, which isn’t super common. I think there would be significantly more going on there than in Grinnell or Gambier. With that in mind, I would choose Sarah Lawrence or Skidmore, especially considering both have great music and theater programs.

Given your stated interests and preference for a city, Sarah Lawrence sounds like a perfect fit.