Harvard vs. Stanford

<p>Not directly related to this topic, since both Harvard and Stanford count as elite schools, but still worth a read, especially for some of the over-excited kids in this thread.</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.yaledailynews.com/article.asp?aid=31623&refer=1&type=2[/url]”>http://www.yaledailynews.com/article.asp?aid=31623&refer=1&type=2&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

“Trying to bring a sense of reason and truth to the aura lunacy,” my ass.</p>

<p>When Byerly goes over to the Stanford forum and spews Harvard propaganda there, go ahead and tear him apart–over there. But the Harvard forum is one place where Byerly’s fanboyism is acceptable. Frankly the impression of Stanford students you have left on us is that they are a bitter bunch with an inferiority complex and need to feel that they are better than superior schools. Whether or not Harvard is actually superior to Stanford is a different matter. For all Byerly’s supposed “misinformation” about Stanford, I never thought one bit less of Stanford. But now seeing how Stanford students behave like students from a “second-tier” school–their “sour grapes” attitude towards ostensibly “better” schools–I am beginning to wonder if Stanford really is a second-tier school. The most important thing you can do for your school’s reputation is to present yourselves well.</p>

<p>Stanford is a fine school, for which I have enormous respect. Indeed, were I to develop a national “ranking”, the chances are I’d have Stanford #2 in the world behind Harvard.</p>

<p>That is nor to say I don’t think Stanford wouldn’t be a better school if it adjusted its priorities and stopped paying athletes - applying the money thus “saved” to need-based financial aid.</p>

<p>By the same token: </p>

<ol>
<li><p>Princeton could be improved by eliminating the legacy of the “eating clubs” - a step it is moving towards;</p></li>
<li><p>Yale could be improved by strengthening its offerings in the sciences - an effort in which it is currently engaged; and </p></li>
<li><p>Harvard could be improved (among other ways) by enlarging its engineering school - an effort in which it is currently engaged.</p></li>
</ol>

<p>The lists could go on and on in each case.</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.epodunk.com/images/MA/ma_harvard01.jpg[/url]”>http://www.epodunk.com/images/MA/ma_harvard01.jpg&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>I agree with your post about the relative weaknesses of HYPS, but feel compelled to point out some inaccuracies in your previous posts about Stanford athletics. My background is that I have two degrees from Harvard and one from Stanford, and have had close friends (and one relative) who were athletes at both schools.</p>

<p>You might consider reading: <a href=“Cardinal 247 - Stanford Cardinal Football Recruiting”>Cardinal 247 - Stanford Cardinal Football Recruiting. It discusses a football player who recently “committed” to Stanford over Harvard, and many issues involved with that. In particular, there is mention of a large financial aid package from Harvard that occurred at the last minute – clearly these occult Ivy League athletic scholarships occur regularly, and we all know it.</p>

<p>The “no play, no pay” line that you mentioned is certainly true at factories such as Florida State and Ohio State. But it’s only sometimes true at more academically-oriented schools like Michigan (several high-profile injury cases recently), and it is <em>never</em> true at Stanford. This is mentioned in the article above. Many Stanford football players have had their playing “careers” ruined by injuries, some have quit the team to pursue other interests (including even academics!), and a few have even been asked to leave the team (including one former high school All-American acquaintance who eventually became a Rhodes Scholar and went to Yale Law School). All kept their scholarships.</p>

<p>I suspect that your “there are players at Stanford who wouldn’t get accepted to any Ivy League school” line is ridiculous. Clearly there are some Stanford athletes (particularly from profit-oriented sports) who wouldn’t meet AI criteria at H or Y (or S, if they used it!). But vast majority of these <em>would</em> meet criteria at lower-end Ivies. I don’t think it really matters either way … one could argue that few Harvard athletes would be offered scholarships at any Division-1 school. And maybe the bottom line is that there are bone-headed jocks at Stanford, just like there are similar bone-heads everywhere else including Harvard. But the vast majority of student-athletes at both schools are <em>very</em> well-integrated into the rest of the student body.</p>

<p>Obviously there are some over-zealous people on these types of threads, including some students perhaps suffering from Harvard-envy. But I think the vast majority of Stanford students are there because they <em>want</em> to be in a non-Ivy-type atmosphere, including the opportunity to watch or even participate in major D-1 sports. Stanford could improve its US News ranking (in the % graduation, SAT score, HS GPA, etc) categories – and perhaps even beat HYP on that methodology – by getting rid of big-time athletics. But I don’t think they care one bit about doing that, because those are things that are uniquely Stanford.</p>

<p>you all people need to relax about this.
H and S are two of the premier schools in the country and I think anyone here should be pleased if they went to either.</p>

<p>calm down, goddamn.</p>

<p>It is certainly true that among the small fraction of Harvard/Stanford cross admits who opt for Palo Alto are a disproportionate number of “scholar athletes” to whom Stanford offers fullrides or substantial athletic scholarships but who would only qualify for limited “need-based” aid at Harvard.</p>

<p>A goodly fraction of the others who decline Harvard admission to go elsewhere also are responding to a large financial carrot dangled in front of their eyes - either an “athletic scholarship” (something of an oxymoronic phrase!) or another “merit” award in the nature of a tuition reduction on a basis other than financial need.</p>

<p>To Stanford’s credit, it stopped giving out the “Presidential Scholarships” - or whatever they called them - a couple of years ago, having decided, after some internal debate, that Stanford didn’t need this yield-boosting crutch anymore.</p>

<p>The Stanford President’s Scholarship program was equivalent to the National Scholar program at Harvard: a largely symbolic honor for “top” applicants, with some nomial amount of money involved (about $1000). It’s certainly true that one of the goals of the program was to improve “yield” for Harvard cross-admits, but it was not comparable to full-tuition programs at Duke, Emory, etc. FWIW, several football players have been awarded these President’s Scholarships.</p>

<p>“When Byerly goes over to the Stanford forum and spews Harvard propaganda there, go ahead and tear him apart–over there.”</p>

<p>well, what if i went over to the stanford forums and posted a “harvard sucks” thread (i would never do that btw). are you saying that it would then be improper for all harvard supporters to post in the stanford forums and chew me out about it?
I for one believe you should defend whichever school you choose to defend, and i would fully expect harvard supporters to retaliate in a “harvard sucks” thread no matter where it is located.
In the same respect, this thread quickly turned into a “stanford sucks”-esque thread as well. All the Stanford supporters were right in coming here to defend their school. Conker, if you think less of Stanford students because of their “misconduct” on this thread, then you should feel equally worse about Harvard students whose attitudes were the reasons that this argument ever began!
Obviously, all over the world, Harvard is regarded as the most prestigious university. Thus, whenever someone argues in favor of another university (be it Stanford, Yale, or Princeton), it becomes an “inferiority complex.” When you really think about it, that claim is bogus and shouldn’t even be used anymore in an argument of this sort.
Again, I’d like to point out that the person who started this series of arguments was indeed, a Harvard student.</p>

<p><<i’d like=“” to=“” point=“” out=“” that=“” the=“” person=“” who=“” started=“” this=“” series=“” of=“” arguments=“” was=“” indeed,=“” a=“” harvard=“” student.=“”>></i’d></p>

<p>Oh really? I don’t THINK so.</p>

<p>That OP “person” seems to have done most of his/her posting on the Stanford threads, and has given no indication of an affiliation with Harvard.</p>

<p>“I for one believe you should defend whichever school you choose to defend, and i would fully expect harvard supporters to retaliate in a “harvard sucks” thread no matter where it is located.”</p>

<p>Don’t you all have better things to do? If there were a lack of response than perhaps the “School X Haters” would stop ‘bashing’ said school. For me, the deciding factor between Stanford and Harvard was location. I really believe it becomes a personal preference issue when comparing schools at this level. It’s sorta silly to be nitpicking at the nuances of the respective educations. And, Byerly, you never answered my question: how old are you? You all make some great points but don’t attack one another- unless you all just like arguing. It is fairly entertaining.</p>

<p>The op was more of a question than anything else, but THIS post
seemed to ignite most of the tension:
“No “label-slapping” allowed until they stop paying salaries to their athletes.
The overarching rule of the Ivy League is that financial aid should be paid only on the basis of need.”</p>

<p>tony, it seems that you’ve been reading all of the posts. don’t YOU have anything better to do???
Just kidding Tony, but do you see the irony in your post?</p>

<p>And yes, i do like arguing</p>

<p>There are many who make their choice on the same basis you did, and its easy to see why:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.epodunk.com/top10/colleges/boston-cambridge.html[/url]”>http://www.epodunk.com/top10/colleges/boston-cambridge.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>"As Fiske declares, in his bestselling Guide to Colleges, “at this point Harvard is the benchmark against which all other colleges are compared.”</p>

<p>Edward B. Fiske does state this in “The Fiske Guide To Colleges.” He also states that an acceptance to Harvard is like the golden stamp of education (or something like that… I can’t remember). While I do believe that you can receive a great education at other schools besides Harvard, I do agree with Fiske in that Harvard is the school in which others are compared to. This may not be fair, but I think it’s the truth.</p>

<p>… but as Rudyard Kipling wrote, long before Fiske published his guide:</p>

<p>“A woman is only a woman, but a good cigar is a smoke.”</p>

<p>I am currently at a “lower ivy” and thus have no affiliation to either stanford or harvard. however, hailing from california i can tell you somethings about the quality of stanfords student athletes. First of all, stanford has won the sear’s directors cup for something like ten years in a row, which is given to the school that wins the most ncaa sports championships for that year. So stanford has terrific athletes obviously, after all it has to compete in the pac-10. </p>

<p>Now it would be easy to say that in order to get these top athletes they must sacrifice some academic integridy by admitting sub-par students. However this is not the case. I know of a varsity tennis player there who recieved a 1600 (!!) on his SAT at stanford. They do not look for athletes that will only excel on the field and not the classroom. On the flipside I also know a great tennis player that played on harvard’s varsity tennis team and recieved a 1250ish score on his SAT. These examples don’t prove the case obviously, however, but they give some perspective.</p>

<p>Schools like harvard and stanford and even duke cannot afford to sacrifice their academic reputations over sports. Each one of these schools, despite a student-athlete population close to 1000 still manage to have high SAT scores and GPA’s for the incoming students each year. Maybe these students aren’t as bright, but they still get it done in the classroom.</p>

<p>Harvard definately has more prestige than stanford internationally. Harvard has a more intelectual environment than stanford too. Stanford from my experience has more well rounded individuals and a happier student body. </p>

<p>For me if i hadn’t gotten rejected from both I’d have gone to harvard for the east coast culture and intelectual environment. At the same time, I’m sure many east coasters would take stanford over harvard for the california experience. Their is no way to prove that either is “better”. They both have their pluses and it depends on the person. But most people choose harvard over stanford, I’d say mostly for the prestige. They get to say they go to Hah-verd</p>

<p>The type of anecdotal evidence you cite (“I know a guy at Stanford…” somebody told me about a tennis player at Harvard" etc etc) has little probative value. The AI resrictions at Harvard and the other Ivies are clear, as is the NCAA data which Stanford, as an athletic scholarship-granting school, must file.</p>

<p>Exceptions to the rule or to the norm are exactly that: EXCEPTIONS.</p>

<p>Stanford has an easy romp to the so-called “Sears Cup” every year for obvious reasons: (1) it spends more on so-called “athletic scholarships” (an oxymoron, IMHO) than any other school, and (2) it substantially outspends the big athletic factory schools when it comes to the minor sports they don’t care about. (Does Mississipi sponsor a salaried water polo team?)</p>

<p>Look, if thrashing other schools - particularly in minor sports where you substantially out-spend them for “recruits” and thus earn Sears Cup “credits” - gives Stanford types a sense of pride and accomplishment, I guess its worth it. To each his own.</p>

<p>Stanford, I hasten to say, is an excellent school - one of the very best in many academic areas.</p>

<p>" He wrapped himself in quotations - as a beggar would wrap himself in emperor’s purple." - Rudyard Kipling</p>

<p>it just shows that Standord values athletics.</p>

<p>Harvard values them too, as evidenced by the fact that it has more Division 1 varsity teams, and more Division 1 varsity athletes, than any other college or university in the United States of America. 72% overall winning percentage last year. Impressively, all these athletes are amateurs and unsalaried: no one pays them to play.</p>