<p>are you referring to me? <em>confused</em></p>
<p>Harvard has the best name and probably the best education overall, but if you go there you are going to have to pay the price of freezing your a$$ off during the winter.</p>
<p>Stanford is sunny, with palm trees and beaches, but its reputation is inferior.</p>
<p>It depends what factors are important to you. </p>
<p>Quite candidly, according to studies and surveys I’ve seen, the principal reason the great majority of common admits choose Harvard over Stanford has less to do with the perceived quality of the education at either than it does with the clear superiority of the Cambridge/Boston setting compared to the relative isolation and lack of stimulation offered by Palo Alto as a “college town” in which to spend 4 years of your life.</p>
<p><a href=“http://www.epodunk.com/top10/colleges/boston-cambridge.html[/url]”>http://www.epodunk.com/top10/colleges/boston-cambridge.html</a></p>
<p>my “anecdotal evidence” is more than any you’ve provided, and it shows that if harvard wants an athletic talent it will lower its standards. All schools do this, so don’t be so defensive about it, and then bash on stanfords sears cup because they have a good polo team or what not when harvard excels in sports like squash or lacross which are hardly even played anywhere else but the northeast.</p>
<p>“Isolation” is hard to use to in regards to Palo Alto.</p>
<p>This is not Hanover. Or Ithaca. </p>
<p>The Caltrain station to San Francisco is very accessible.</p>
<p>Brown, in Providence RI, is closer to Boston than Palo Alto is to San Francisco, for chrissakes.</p>
<p>You remind me of the old “Yalie ■■■■■” who tried to convince us that New York City was just a part of the Greater New Haven Metropolitan Area!</p>
<p>
Last time I checked, the title of this thread was “Harvard vs. Stanford,” not “Stanford sucks.”</p>
<p>
Let’s see…we were having a discussion about the prestige, in which all the Harvard supporters added that Stanford was still an excellent school even if it had slightly less standing internationally. No disrespect to Stanford–even you admitted that Harvard has more prestige worldwide. And then this tidbit from a Stanford student…</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Notice that this was not intended as a reply to “Stanford sucks”…if there were such sentiments at all. This is clearly saying, “Harvard sucks; Stanford is better.” I don’t recall any Harvard students–or even Byerly–ever claiming that Stanford is “overrated.” The Harvard students respected Stanford as a highly selective, academically rigorous institution. On the other hand, I can’t say that Stanford students have showed that same kind of respect (comparing Harvard degrees to peanuts, for example).</p>
<p>
Yes, but when you argue for a university and degrade another university in the process, it becomes an inferiority complex. It is possible to highlight the many merits of Stanford without an offhand comparison to Harvard.</p>
<p>As to your final point, it butresses the view expressed by Fiske that Harvard - love it or hate it - is “is the benchmark against which all other colleges are compared.” </p>
<p>If you want to rule the world, you must first kill Caesar, I guess!</p>
<p>Byerly you amaze me. you never come into these discussions with any evidence. If someone you dislike says something, no matter what it is, you will say the opposite and call them absurd.</p>
<p>By the way…
Palo Alto to San Fran: 33 miles
Providence to Boston: 51 miles</p>
<p>another note on this “isolation”. Palo alto is in the heart of silicon valley and is next to san jose, a city of over a million people</p>
<p>first off, Byerly, stop claiming that Stanford “pays its students” and that it hires “professional athletes” to play for them.
The definition of a professional athlete is one who earns a salary for playing a sport. NO college student is a PROFESSIONAL until he/she has graduated from college and is making a living PLAYING THE SPORT. Stanford gives athletic scholarships to its athletes, true, but there is nothing wrong with that. Many of the athletes that end up playing for Stanford are from low-income families, thus making it justifiable to give these scholarships to them.
If a college wants a student for his/her talents, why shouldn’t the college use its resources to provide incentives?</p>
<p>Also, I am sure that many of these exceptional athletes are also courted by Harvard as well, but end up choosing Stanford. This decision can’t be due to financial need, as Stanford would be offering them scholarships and Harvard’s excellent financial aid would take care of them as well. The athletes most likely pick Stanford as its sports program is world-renowned, and has a better track record for getting its athletes into the professional sports world. Just as an example, there are currently 7 players in the NBA who graduated from Stanford, compared to 0 who graduated from Harvard.
This entire time, you have been trying to fault Stanford for having a better athletics program, and using the “paid athletes” excuse as your crutch. Don’t blame Stanford for being a more attractive school to prospective student-athletes.</p>
<p>You don’t hear much whooping about the attractions of SanJose as a “college town” however.</p>
<p>Palo Alto, NOT San Jose.
Also just to state: Palo Alto has amazing weather, to which no where in the northeast can even compare. Rain is the worst weather you’ll see in that area, while as much as any Northeasterner may celebrate the “beauty of the seasons” it doesn’t compare to the cool, crisp, and yet delightfully sunny 75 degree day that’s nearly all year round.</p>
<p>Conker
"Last time I checked, the title of this thread was “Harvard vs. Stanford,” not “Stanford sucks.”
That was to make a point, because this thread quickly transformed into a Stanford bashing thread as soon as a particular Harvard poster made certain comments. From the looks of your counter post, you did not even understand what I was saying.</p>
<p>Also:
“Yes, but when you argue for a university and degrade another university in the process, it becomes an inferiority complex. It is possible to highlight the many merits of Stanford without an offhand comparison to Harvard.”</p>
<p>Show me a post of mine where I degraded Harvard. Please.</p>
<p>The distinction you find between paid college athletes and paid NBA/NFL etc athletes eludes me frankly, but if the rationalization satisfies you, well that’s fine. The only difference I see is the level of the compensation.</p>
<p>And if training jocks for the pros is the aim in your mind, well that’s fine too - for you. Pre-professional training for the NBA, and being paid while you’re being trained? Swell. </p>
<p>You are mistaken indeed if you are under the impression I think Stanford has a “better athletic program” in consequence. Victories achieved by spending more on so-called “athletic scholarships” (a true oxymoron!) than any other college or university in the United States of America should, one presumes, be expected. You get what you pay for in this respect. But so what? </p>
<p>Just as Stanford’s reputation improved when it decided to stop giving “merit scholarships” to attract good students, so too would its academic reputation rise even higher if it altered its values to award scholarship aid on the basis of financial need - not on the basis of water polo skills. </p>
<p>IMHO, a college or university - whose goal, presumably is academic, should not measure the “success” of its athletic program by how many of its paid performers move on to professional sports leagues.</p>
<p>Byerly, r u the Student representative of Harvard?
Is anyone here a student representative of any University?</p>
<p>I represent only myself, and am fully aware that, here and there, a few others may not share my views!</p>
<p>Good luck in your educational endeavors.</p>
<p>No, I didnt mean that… I was just enquiring about the Student Representatives of different institutions at CC. ![]()
U r from Harvard, right?</p>
<p>Thank you for your wishes :)</p>
<p>byerly, a simple request if i may, do you have any proof that Stanford spends more than any other school in the U.S. on athletics?</p>
<p>im just skeptical as i have never seen any reports done on this.</p>