Harvard vs. Stanford

<p>

It doesn’t seem like you understood what I was saying. Yes, a certain Harvard poster did make some unsavory comments about Stanford, but it was only in response to another Stanford poster who was picking a fight in a thread that was fine until then. Read my post again.</p>

<p>

You know well who I am talking about, and it isn’t you.</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.stanford.edu/home/statistics/#admission[/url]”>http://www.stanford.edu/home/statistics/#admission&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>Stupid, stupid, stupid. As a person that’s lived in the Silicon Valley almost my entire life, I have to laugh at this, and the implication that Stanford has anything to do with it. </p>

<p>For starters, saying that Harvard’s engineering doesn’t crack the top 20 is ridiculous. Harvard is an amazing school, and its engineering departments are top-notch. You feel bad because some people are saying Stanford isn’t all it’s cracked up to be? You accuse them of being jealous haters who aren’t being objective? </p>

<p>That’s exactly what you are.</p>

<p>As for the “New Economy”, no such thing exists, at least not in terms of what you’re thinking. There are a bunch of electronics/high-tech companies that were founded and/or headquartered in the Bay Area. Now, many of these facilities are being shipped overseas to Asia, buildings are closing everywhere, and employers and workers alike are being layed off. The Bay Area is no more a “New Economy” than Pittsburgh was in the late 1800’s. It was simply a place where several prominent companies in a new industry were founded/headquartered prior to being shipped overseas. </p>

<p>Stanford has nothing to do with this. </p>

<p>Now, I know what you’re going to say, “But what about Google and Yahoo?”</p>

<p>In the case of Google, precisely one of its three founders went to Stanford…for grad school. However, he had begun developing the project while an undergraduate at the University of Maryland. Should we credit Maryland with the birth of the New Economy?</p>

<p>So much for that.</p>

<p>As for Yahoo, the company was never that large and/or prominent before the three Stanford undergraduates sold their share of the company and Semel took over. It was only after the former Hollywood lawyer did this that the company really became huge. </p>

<p>Heck, the thee Stanford founders aren’t even wealthy, and are only used for PR events like so many puppets.</p>

<p>This is not meant to denigrate Stanford in any way. It’s an amazing institution, and gives its students ample opportunities to succeed in industry or academia. </p>

<p>But to credit a major international event in the progress of mankind to a single university is not only myopic and dumb, but also insulting to the individuals who were truly responsible for it.</p>

<p>So ridiculous</p>

<p>GracieLegend,</p>

<p>Sorry, your comments about Google are inaccurate. There were 2 founders of Google and they both went to Standford grdauate school. Neither one of them went to Stanford as an undergraduate.</p>

<p><a href=“Google - Wikipedia”>Google - Wikipedia;

<p>Whether you call it high-tech or the new economy Stanford and other schools in the area have catered to them for years. Yahoo and Sun Microsystems come to mind as companies started by Stanford grads (along with Berkeley and Santa Clara grads)</p>

<p>In MA that school would be MIT. Harvard is not as highly rated in engineering because most engineering types go to MIT, though it appears Harvard is focusing on engineering in their next expansion to the Allston side of the river.</p>

<p>Not sure why Byerly is so down on the pre-professional nature of athletic scholarships. I have no problem with athletic scholarships provided that a schools provides for 100% of the demonstrated financial need of its students first. Though I think this is a more recent development for Stanford. I guess the expanded endowment supports it. </p>

<p>Stanford is one of the schools along with Duke, Notre Dame and a few others that provides both athletic scholarships and 100% financial need. It is interesting to note that the student athletes at these schools have a very high graduation rate.</p>

<p>well-said eagle79</p>

<p>conker, i understood what you said, and I agree that many Stanford supporters made distasteful comments as well, but I still believe that the argument was fueled by a Harvard supporter</p>

<p>if you read the beginning of the discussion I think you can find the post that I am talking about</p>

<p>That post, juzam_djinn, was in response to the suggestion that Stanford should be labeled as an Ivy League school. (Whether that suggestion was made in jest is besides the point.) That post that you claim started the Stanford bashing was the appropriate response to the suggestion, since it pointed out a Stanford practice that is not allowed by the Ivy League’s joint statement on aid procedures.</p>

<p>actually dualityim, i was talking about post #41 and on</p>

<p>Also, I think it is ludicrous to constantly point out the fact that Stanford offers athletic scholarships in order to cast a negative Stanford in a negative light.</p>

<p>The ivy league’s joint statement sure looks good on paper, but a University’s actions speak for more than what they put on paper.</p>

<p>At Stanford, 670 students received average need-based scholarships of $24,631. Compared to an ivy league school, Princeton, where 616 students received average need-based scholarships of $24,172. I would include more information on other ivy league schools, but few have updated admissions statistics.</p>

<p>Oh, I was just going by what you said earlier.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>

Well…the only way to avoid criticism is to have nothing to be criticized.</p>

<p>you’re right dualityim i should have been more specific</p>

<p>hehe, no college has nothing to be criticized</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well, actually I have to disagree. Stanford was in fact quite integral to the creation of Silicon Valley. Fred Terman, Professor and later President of Stanford, did lease out the Stanford Farm to startup technology companies, building one of the first true ‘industrial parks’, most notably to the founders of HP, both of whom were Stanford undergrads. It is precisely this spark that created Silicon Valley. The Valley could have just as easily developed around Berkeley and the East Bay. But it didn’t. The truth is, Stanford and Terman had a lot to do with that.</p>

<p>That doesn’t mean that Stanford was the only game in town. Obviously you have to give credit to all the entrepreneurs, the venture capitalists, the far-sighted politicians of the time, and the engineers themselves for building Silicon Valley. But Stanford was a strong contributory driving force in the creation of Silicon Valley.</p>

<p>I don’t want to write an entire book about this subject, so for those who want to read more about it, you may want to read the following links, and get some of the books that the links refer to. </p>

<p><a href=“You’ve requested a page that no longer exists | Stanford News”>You’ve requested a page that no longer exists | Stanford News;
<a href=“Internet History, World Wide Web History, Silicon Valley, Computer Companies, Computer Magazines, Netvalley”>Internet History, World Wide Web History, Silicon Valley, Computer Companies, Computer Magazines, Netvalley;
<a href=“http://www.pbs.org/transistor/album1/addlbios/terman.html[/url]”>http://www.pbs.org/transistor/album1/addlbios/terman.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>The comparison between Pittsburgh and the Bay Area is uncalled for. Silicon Valley actually added tech jobs in the last quarter. Not a lot, but it still added them. Whereas Pittsburgh has been steadily losing steel jobs nearly monotonically for the last quarter-century. </p>

<p>I agree that manufacturing and product development is moving overseas. Actually, much low-level electronics component manufacturing moved overseas decades ago. Much of the chip fabrication moved away years ago, although not really overseas. For example, Intel’s Santa Clara wafer fab is actually one of Intel’s smaller fabs. Intel’s largest fabs are not located overseas. In fact, Intel’s biggest fabs are located in Chandler Arizona, Hillsborough Oregon, and Rio Rancho New Mexico. Fabs didn’t move overseas, they moved ‘in-seas’. AMD’s fabs are located in Texas and in Germany. Intel doesn’t have a single fab in a low-cost country (although Intel does have some testing facilities in low-cost countries). The truth is, wafer fab is so capital-intensive that it makes little sense to ship off a fab for low labor costs. After all, labor costs are a vanishingly small part fo the fab budget anyway. What dominates fab costs are electricity, access to transportation/distribution lines, wafer fabrication equipment (which tend to be constant across the globe), and taxes. For example, Intel built fabs in Arizona not really to take advantage of low labor costs but to take advantage of low state corporate taxes. </p>

<p>However, while manufacturing and product development will move overseas, the fact is, Silicon Valley will continue to have a tremendous amount of innovation and entrepreneurship, if for no other reason, for simple geographic reasons and the limitations of venture capitalists. Think of it this way. Many of the world’s VC’s, particularly in the information technology arena, are located around Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park. A typical VC partner is responsible for overseeing probably about 10-20 startups for which he has to attend quarterly board meetings of those startups, maybe pop in on other meetings with that startup’s executives, and so forth. That basically means that most of the time he is in a meeting or travelling to one. That makes it very difficult to get the attention of a VC if you’re not located somewhere nearby where a partner can reasonably travel to you. If you’re located off in the Mid-west, you’re going to have a serious problem in getting VC funding simply because if they invest in you, they are going to want to attend your board meetings, which is a very hard thing to do because of your location. Hence, the point is, until the VC’s move away from Silicon Valley (and why would they?), or somebody invents a teleportation device, Silicon Valley will continue to be a top place to do tech entrepeneurship.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I think this was debunked before, but I would say again, that Google had 2 founders, Brin and Page, and both have master’s degrees in CS from Stanford. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I must disagree. Terry Semel joined in May 2001. However, it was in the year 2000 that Yahoo stock reached its heights. Around January 2000, Yahoo was has reached nearly $150 billion in market cap. Now, they are about worth about $50 billion in market cap. In fact, actually, Yahoo’s market cap today is about the same as it was when Terry Semel joined the company.</p>

<p><a href=“YHOO Interactive Stock Chart | - Stock - Yahoo Finance”>YHOO Interactive Stock Chart | - Stock - Yahoo Finance;

<p>

</p>

<p>Not that wealthy, you say? According to Forbes Magazine, in 2005, Jerry Yang was the #228 richest person in the world, with a net worth of $2.6 billion dollars. David Filo is even richer at #188, with a net worth of $3.1 billion. Oh, by the way, Terry Semel is not on the list of Forbes billionaires. </p>

<p><a href=“Forbes.com: Forbes World's Richest People 2005”>Forbes.com: Forbes World's Richest People 2005;

<p><a href=“http://www.forbes.com/static/bill2005/LIRXTTZ.html?passListId=10&passYear=2005&passListType=Person&uniqueId=XTTZ&datatype=Person[/url]”>http://www.forbes.com/static/bill2005/LIRXTTZ.html?passListId=10&passYear=2005&passListType=Person&uniqueId=XTTZ&datatype=Person&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>This is the one part of your post that I do agree with. Clearly you cannot give all of the credit to Stanford. Many players had a hand in the creation of Silicon Valley and the New Economy. </p>

<p>But at the same time, you cannot dismiss Stanford’s prominent role in the creation of Silicon Valley. It is not a coincidence that so many technology companies did get spawned near Stanford. This wasn’t just because of luck. Stanford did indeed play a highly active role in the creation of a vibrant technology industry surrounding it. You have to ask why didn’t Silicon Valley sprout in some other part of the country? Why not around MIT? Why not in the East Bay around Berkeley? Why not in Pasadena around Caltech? Let’s give credit where credit is due.</p>

<p>brin and page first met while at stanford.</p>

<p>Here’s an interesting bit of history: Stanford Research Institute (SRI) was founded in conjunction with Stanford in 1946. SRI later created the Augmentation Research Center (ARC), lead by Douglas Engelbart, inventor of the computer mouse. When ARC’s founding ran dry in the early 1970s, most of its scientists fled to nearby Xerox Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), which, as we know, is the birthplace of many computing technologies in use today.</p>

<p>Eagle: Read my post carefully again, paying attention to the individual words. I noted that Brin was a grad student at Stanford, not an undergrad. And yes, he started working on search engines as an undergraduate at the University of Maryland, not in grad school. I did omit Page, however, although I don’t really know how much he did. </p>

<p>sakky:</p>

<p>Yes, Silicon Valley is like Pittsburgh of the late 1800’s. Like Pittsburgh, most of its jobs (high-tech in one case, steel production in the other) will eventually go overseas.</p>

<p>This is an undeniable fact, as it’s already happening now.</p>

<p>I must say I’m really suprised by that Forbes link. I might be wrong, but I only thought that Yang and Filo were millionaires, and I’ve been told this by several Yahoo employees. I’ll reserve judgement about that one. </p>

<p>As for Yahoo’s high market value in 2000, the three Stanford founders were no longer an important part of the company back then, even if they did have some lofty titles. Also, just because they have similar market caps doesn’t mean Semel hasn’t done a hell of a lot for the company. May 2001 was only the beginning of the huge recession, and for Yahoo! to come out virtually unscathed from all of that was incredible. </p>

<p>More importantly, Yahoo! has now branched out into search engines and bought AbuDhabi, the Asian equivalent of Ebay. They’re annihliating Google in the Asian market now, and are a much more profitable company with more diverse holdings than when Semel first took over.</p>

<p>Oh yeah, and Stanford had no more to do with Silicon Valley’s prominence than UCLA had to do with Hollywood’s success.</p>

<p>GracieLegend,</p>

<p>I had read your words carefully before I posted. You stated that Stanford had nothing to do with the success of Silicon Valley and mistated that Google was started by multiple Stanford graduates. As many of the posters after me noted, there were many significant companies started out of Stanford. Notably:</p>

<p>HP, Sun, Yahoo, Google</p>

<p>If we accept your agument that Yahoo was nothing until Semel came to the company then you can take Yahoo off the list and put Netscape into the list because Jim Clark, Stanford professor, recruited all the UIUC programmers to come to the valley and start the company.</p>

<p>Regarding Hollywood, UCLA and USC have been driving forces in that industy. Similarly, here in the greater Boston area MIT has been a driving force in the founding of many local high tech companies.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Here’s what I actually wrote;</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>You must have a serious learning disability. Either that, or you’re joking with me. There’s no other way to explain this.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well, I don’t know that your statement is entirely meaningful. The truth is, most of today’s jobs of ANY kind will eventually either go overseas or (even more likely) disappear entirely. After all, 150 years ago, at least half of all Americans worked as farmers. Now, barely 2% are. At one point in time, millions of people in the world used to work as blacksmiths, cattle drivers, chimney sweeps, weavers, cowboys, and jobs like that. How many people in the world, especially in the developed world, hold jobs like that today? </p>

<p>Look, every single job that exists today will either disappear or go overseas (and then probably eventually disappear). That’s a fact. Hence, while I agree that the high-tech jobs in Silicon Valley as we know them will disappear, that’s not relevant. The real question is what will replace those jobs. </p>

<p>As a case in point, Boston and Cambridge Mass used to be large manufacturing centers. Cambridge especially was basically an industrial town, filled with factories, smokestacks, warehouses, power plants, and so forth. In fact, that’s a big reason why MIT was first located in Boston and then Cambridge - in order to be close to the large industrial production capacity around town. Keep in mind that for the first few decades in its life, MIT was basically a trade school and engineering was seen largely as a means to improve manufacturing processes. You can still come and see much of that old industrial infrastructure in Cambridge - much of it is now rusting away and abandoned, and some of it has been either reclaimed and turned into housing or demolished to create science parks. Boston/Cambridge is no longer a major manufacturing center. MIT couldn’t save it. But of course MIT didn’t want to save it - preferring to instead stoke high-tech firms. That’s what Stanford did too. </p>

<p>But of course what is high-tech today will be ho-hum tomorrow. Like I said, all jobs that exist today will eventually disappear. The question is not how to save those jobs but to figure out what it gets replaced with. In the case of MIT and Cambridge, many of those industrial centers got replaced with nothing at all and thus became major slums. In fact, that’s a big reason why the Central Square area is still pretty sketchy and crime-ridden. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Yang and Filo are billionaires. You can check it with the SEC’s EDGAR database that reports on the holdings of major stockholders. As of May, 2005, Yang held over 50 million shares of Yahoo (since Yahoo closed at about $33 today, and presuming he hasn’t sold any stock in the last 7 months, his holdings would have a market value of over $1.5 billion), and Filo holds over 80 million shares (market value of $2.4 billion). Of course that doesn’t include any cash, real estate, or other investments that these guys hold. I think the EDGAR database is pretty unimpeachable unless you want to accuse these guys of committing securities fraud by submitting false information to the SEC.</p>

<p><a href=“Yahoo Finance - Stock Market Live, Quotes, Business & Finance News”>http://biz.yahoo.com/t/67/3519.html&lt;/a&gt;
<a href=“Yahoo Finance - Stock Market Live, Quotes, Business & Finance News”>Yahoo Finance - Stock Market Live, Quotes, Business & Finance News;

<p>

</p>

<p>Who exactly is this mysterious ‘3rd’ founder? I am not aware of Yahoo having more than 2 founders. </p>

<p>And besides, even if they weren’t important parts of the company anymore, an assertion that I would hotly dispute, who cares? Yang and Filo got rich. The whole point of starting a business is to get rich. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Nobody is saying that Semel hasn’t done anything. Indeed he has been an important part of Yahoo’s success. But the point is, the 2 founders have done important things too. Think of it this way. Even in the depths of the downturn, the company was always profitable. The company has NEVER lost money. Lest you think this is a trivial point, I would argue that there are plenty of companies that wouldn’t mind not losing money. For example, GM lost $8.5 billion in fiscal 2005. The airlines have lost billions and billions of dollars in the last few years and many of them are in bankruptcy. In contrast, at least the team of Filo, Yang, and Semel (and yes, they are a team) built a company that has never reported a loss.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>But you are missing the point that there had to be a company for Semel to take over. Keep in mind that plenty of dotcoms did absolutely nothing and completely flamed out. Why didn’t Semel go to one of those dotcoms and not Yahoo? It’s because even when Yahoo was falling, Yahoo was still one of the top dotcoms around. So, if nothing else, you have to give credit for Yang and Filo for building one of the best dotcoms such that there was something for Semel to take over. A lot of other dotcoms, like Webvan, completely bit the dust. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Come on, man, did you bother to read any of the links I posted? Heck, you can find your own, and you will see that there was clearly a period when Stanford was instrumental in the development of Silicon Valley as we know it. Fred Terman in particular was highly influential in the creation of the Silicon Valley business model. To dismiss that would be an insult to him and his memory.</p>