Help! High GPA, low test scores -- where to apply?

My son is having an existential crisis over where to apply, LOL!
He’s a high school senior, always been homeschooled, and he has great grades – right now he’s on track to get a dual AA degree with his high school diploma through dual enrollment, and he’s had a 4.0 overall GPA at the community college honors program for four quarters. Overall his GPA is 3.95, I think, and most of the credits are honors or dual enrollment. He’s very heavily lopsided on the liberal arts and, frankly, sucks in math.
ACT: 25. He got 18 math, 24 science/English, and 30 in reading.
He will take the SAT in October, but his PSAT was 620 reading, 450 math. He’ll do better than that, but probably more like a 690 reading/510 math, I’m guessing.
He’s an Eagle Scout, active in 4-H, works 25 hours on a farm, volunteers every weekend at a food bank, and is overall a great kid.
He’s really interested in a school where he can stay up all night talking about world-building, dungeons and dragons, philosophy, why religion and poverty exist, and how to overthrow capitalism and racism.
Right now his schools are Reed, Grinnell, Lewis and Clark, Whitman, Pitzer (they’re test-optional, so he has a shot, maybe, if he applies ED?), University of Washington, Colorado College, and I don’t know where else.
He’s supposed to go to Grinnell this weekend for the “Discover Grinnell” weekend, but he’s thinking of skipping it because he’s convinced he doesn’t have a shot.
We live in Western Washington, and he’d like to stay on this side of the country but could be persuaded if he found a school that was a good fit.
Would love some ideas, and to know if what he’s thinking is realistic with a 24 ACT.
Thanks!

Other than pitzer you are barking at the wrong trees, you should be looking at the test optional schools.

He should absolutely go to the Grinnell weekend, because certainly it’s a high reach, but they are actively seeking rural applicants so helping on a farm and geographical diversity will help, and going to that weekend will indicate high interest. If he doesn’t go whatever shot he may have is gone.
He has a shot at all test optional schools but add a few others.
Dickinson is test optional and may work for what he wants.
Easier to get into yet intellectual and socially active: Earlham? Classically intellectual: St John’s in NM? Research emphasized : Wooster?
What about taking subject tests in the subjects he’s strong at and applying to UBC for History or Philosophy?
Run the NPC for all of these.

Check the testing requirements, because many test optional schools require home schooled kids to submit scores. Not sure how it works if they have an AA though.

Seems like he has some deficiencies in math preparation…that can be an issue for college classes. Is there a way he could get extra help? Like Khuman or Mathnasium or even Khan Academy and learn more math?

https://www.fairtest.org/university/optional

He might want to look into Hampshire College even though it’s in MA and perhaps out of geographic range. They flat out won’t receive/accept scores from anyone (if a student sends them they say they don’t even look at them). The school could be an excellent social and academic fit, popular with homeschoolers who have enjoyed following their own paths. Also Hampshire is in a consortium so he’d have access to other fine LACs and even UMass Amherst.

Whitman and L&C are now test optional, though he might have to submit since has been home schooled

His scores are close to mid 50% for Puget Sound, and they are also test optional, perhaps too close to home geographically?

Would he consider University of Redlands? His composite score is within Redland’s mid 50% range. It’s on my D18’s list as a likely admit and her list shares some of the schools that interest your son… Colorado College, Whitman, L&C…

MYOS1634: Thanks – knowing about the “rural” thing helps. What is the NPC? That’s one I acronym I haven’t heard. I will suggest the other schools to him.

I have to call the schools, since I’m my son’s “college counselor,” and find out how it works for test-optional schools if he has an AA. I’m hoping that’s enough that he won’t need to submit test scores. He has a 4.0 at the CC, so that should be enough to give him a shot at test-optional schools.

And lr4550: I’ll have him take a look at Redlands. They’ve certainly sent him enough fliers! We’ve toured Puget Sound, and it’s a beautiful campus. I think he was hoping for “far from home,” but I’ll have him take another look.