Help Me Pick Colleges (With no EC’s)

White Male from Northern Virginia
GPA: 3.5 uw/3.94w
SAT: 1500
ACT: 33
APs: World History (5), Chemistry (5), US History (5), Computer Science (4), Seminar (4)
ECs (very weak):
4 years of club baseball and 1 year for school
4 years of club and school hockey
~20 hours of community service
1 year of AP Chem club
(would it be worth it to join clubs/honors societies senior year?)
Awards:
AP Scholar with Distinction
2x Academic Team for hockey
1x Academic Team for baseball

Possibly looking for engineering? Probably a STEM major
Northeast preferred
Cost can’t be too crazy
Looking for solid safeties and matches

Thanks

Pitt could be a good match for you. They have a more straightforward application process than most private U’s (although there are a number of short-answer questions) and they specifically state, “Extra-curricular activities and community involvement are recognized, but they are of secondary importance when compared to academic accomplishments.” You would qualify for Honors based on your SAT, and you might get some merit off of the sticker price, which is quite a bit lower than similarly-competitive private U’s. (Around $48K/year) The campus is right in Pittsburgh, which is a great city for students - small enough to be manageable, but big enough to have lots to do - a little like Boston only cheaper and not as cold :slight_smile: The engineering and science programs are excellent… and there are club teams for both baseball and hockey https://www.studentaffairs.pitt.edu/campus-recreation/clubs-sports/competitive-clubs/

(Not stopping with one suggestion for lack of other good options - that’s just the one that sprang to mind. Also they have rolling admissions, so applying early could reduce your need for less-competitive safeties.)

Looking at the Common Data Sets for schools you are interested in will give you an indication how much each school takes into account EC (VI-Very Important, I-Important, C-Considered, NC-Not Considered).

Many of the large state publics put less emphasis on EC’s.

Examples of schools where EC’s are Not Considered (NC): Arizona State, Kansas State, Kansas, Towson, Ole Miss and South Florida.

Examples of schools were EC’s are Considered ©: Clemson, College of Charleston, Florida State, Indiana, Iowa State, LSU, Miami (Ohio), Michigan State, NC State, Penn State, Temple, Tulane, Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Maryland, Pitt, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Vermont, Wisconsin, VT.

With your SAT and ACT score take a look at schools in the 40-75% acceptance rate bracket. There are many that will give merit. Do you want to play hockey? Look at some D3 schools; depending on your level of play that might help with merit as well University of New England (ME), Utica (NY), Elmire (NY), Endicott (MA) would all be considered safety schools with decent enough hockey teams.

I’m not seeing no ECs OP. If you were deeply involved in your sports, that is fine!

For a safety, look into Clarkson.

I know at Kansas State you would be able to get good auto merit with your stats and they have a nice engineering school.

McGill., but you will need to demonstrate math chops for engineering.

Understand that many colleges will look for your engineering experiences, including hs math-sci ECs. They like to see these collaborative experiences, as engineering is often about teamwork. It’s more than just academics and “maybe engineering.” Many colleges want to see you pursued this interest, have the mindset. That can apply to schools with their own college of engineering, too.

Plus, competition among kids from N VA can be very tough. So some of the state publics are worth a good look. You’ll need to check the NPC/Net Price calculators on the colleges’ web sites to see if they’re affordable ( assuming your parents aren’t divorced and not self employed.)

For some colleges, it will matter much what brought the gpa to 3.5, whether any grade dips are in stem classes or cores. Get a Fiske Guide to Colleges. Because if you’re a rising senior, it’s late to be posting an open call for ideas.

Many public universities in the North (SUNY Buffalo, UDel, UMBC, UNH, Rowan…) would work. Pitt is a good option, too.
However, run the NPC to see if they are affordable.
Other possibilities:
Union would be a match, Clarkson a safety. Run the NPC and if they are affordable, fill out the Request information form.

I’m warning private schools like Union and Clemson and others may not be a match with so few ECs and little to back up an engn interest. Plus the gpa. Plus the volume of highly prepared kids from N VA, that competition. OP needs to be strategic, needs to figure out what that means, catch up. Eyes wide open.

Clemson is very stats based for admissions.

I almost hate to bring this up, but given AP Calc is not on your list, what’s the highest level Math you’ve taken and what’s your M/V breakdown on the SATs?

A 3.5 UW GPA will be a rejection from McGill engineering. 3.7 minimum required.

Precalc/Trig, taking calc AB next year. Got 770 math (missed one question on June) 730 ebrw

I wanted to suggest Clarkson but couldn’t see how it would get down to OP’s “not too crazy” price point. I think it’s going to need to be hard to get enough merit aid from private colleges/U’s in the northeast, especially for engineering. It would be different if OP had a 4.4 GPA, but under-4.0 weighted for STEM isn’t going to attract big academic merit, especially without any STEM-related EC’s. Maybe if a school like Clarkson wanted him for D3 athletics… but he’s not mentioning anything like league or state level athletic distinctions so my assumption was that a public U with good club sports would be the thing to look for.

Maybe Miami of OH would be a good public U with a Northeast-private-college-like vibe? It has a geographically diverse, majority-out-of-state student population and an “iconic college experience” to quote Princeton Review.
http://miamioh.edu/campus-services/miami-recreation/program-areas/club-sports/index.html

As @momofsenior1 says, substantial athletic involvement is an EC - perhaps not enough for schools where EC’s are listed as VI-Very Important or I-Important, but I don’t see any reason not to target the C-Considered category.

“Not too crazy” is subjective. What does that mean OP? My daughter got considerable merit $ from Clarkson that made them less than an out of state public.

If you are looking for a very low cost option, U of Akron is very strong for engineering and very affordable, you would qualify for honors college, and a lot of merit money.