Help me shortlist this list of business schools for my son

My son wants to apply for the fall 2019 session. He wants to study business management at the undergrad level and then go on to do investment banking.

Academics:
He is doing the IB, with 3 HLs and 3 SLs, Business Management HL (7), Economics HL (6), English HL (6), Mathematics SL (?), Physics SL (4), French B SL (5).
SAT Latest attempt: 1440 (680 English, 760 Math)
2 attempts prior: 1350 and 1290
Will do TOEFL

Financial aid:
Would be happy to get scholarships or aid, but can pay full tuition if needed.

Extra Curriculars:
Internships:
Accenture, Bangalore - Learnt about finance management for their customer Cushman Wakefield. (1 week).
Gravitas Investments, Bangalore - Investment Banking firm. Learned about Mergers and Acquisitions, creating Information Memorandums, and capital raising. (1 week)
Radio Indigo, Bangalore - Worked with Radio Jockeys and Programming team. (1 week)

Other ECs
Completed Level 2 Certification by Trinity College (UK) for Speech and Drama.
Played Inter-school football (soccer) for three years. Won third place in football tournament (Adidas Uprising)
Participated in India Investing Conclave 2018.

Volunteer Activities:
Volunteered with “Projects Abroad” in Thailand (1 week) - May 2018
Volunteered with Community Service organization in Portugal (1 week) - July 2017
Volunteered with “Pack a Smile” club which delivers gift boxes to underprivileged children in Bangalore, India - 2017-18

Leadership
Selected as Secretary-General of Canadian International School, Model United Nations - 2018
Best Delegate - Canadian International School, Model United Nations - 2017
Best Position Paper - Sishu Griha High School, Model United Nations - 2017
Elected School Prefect (Student Governing Council) - 2016-17

His college list right now is:
Dream:
Northeastern
University of Pennsylvania (Wharton)
Columbia

High Target:
University of Michigan - Ann Arbor - Ross
University of Virginia (McIntire)*
NYU - Stern
Babson

Target:
University of Texas - Austin - McCombs School
Southern Methodist University - Dallas Tx - Cox School
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
University of Wisconsin at Madison

Safety:
Rutgers - New Brunswick
Indiana - Bloomington- Kelley
Texas A&M - College Station
Penn State University park- Smeal college - main campus

Please help me shortlist this list and all opinions on this list are appreciated.
Thank you

Northeastern is relatively easy to get into lol compared to his two other dream schools?

GPA?

I think that your classification is off by one level. The B schools are normally more competitive than the university as a whole. Also, you have many state schools that are more difficult for non residents. UT may be off by two levels.

I agree with @Eeyore123 (I would also move Northeastern down a notch and Kelley up two notches)
Also note :
–Columbia does not have an undergraduate business school.
–At UVA students apply to the b-school after two years at the college.
–Penn recommends two SAT II exams and Wharton specifically recommends that applicants take Math 2. Has he taken these exams? (I don’t know if other schools on the list require/recommend SAT II tests)

Generally good list of business schools; and I agree with above comments. I’d pretty much consider all of the “high target” schools as “dream” or “reach” schools. Your son is a strong candidate, but more strong candidates are denied admission than accepted at these schools, especially for OOS students. It’s just supply and demand. If 40,000 students apply to a school, and 20,000 are fully qualified, strong candidates, and it accepts 5000, then 1 in 4 fully qualified, strong candidates must be denied admission. This is the case at some of these schools, and sometimes the numbers are more daunting.

I agree IU is more of a target. Otherwise it seems like good balance.

There is going to be very little merit aid, and little financial aid in general at these top-ranked public flagships. If you want to look at some good schools with more financial aid, you might look at these,

http://miamioh.edu/admission/merit-guarantee/index.html

Note that Miami of Ohio super-scores for admission AND merit aid.

https://admissions.ku.edu/tuition-scholarship/freshman

Scroll down for KU OOS scholarships. Lawrence is a great college town.

His high school is an International Baccalaureate school and does not provide GPA. But he will have a Predictive score which most colleges will accept by the last week of November. We expect it to be a great score. Thanks!

Thanks, @Eeyore123. Useful insight. Any suggestions on safeties besides the ones on the list or do you feel that these are sufficient number?

            UT won't be a target, it is a reachier reach (dream) for an international with that SAT. He has no calc? No math 2 subject test? SL is the highest math he has and is planning on IB? 
 Will he apply with no application for FA or merit at the publics in question? Any application for $$ might well be a factor. 

NEU at full pay is not a dream, that could be a target, do you mean Northwestern?

Thanks @happy1! We are very keen on Kelley, but I suppose a reality-check always helps.

At Columbia - he’ll try to get into the Mendelson Center - for Undergraduate Business Initiatives.
For UVA, we felt it will be worthwhile if he gets admission, to work really hard to try to get into McIntire.

He has not taken the Subject tests. I didn’t realize these were required. Thanks for letting us know, will see if there is still time for these. Thank you so much for your help.

Thanks for your help @TTG. Very helpful comments, I guess I haven’t really understood how to do this properly yet :slight_smile: My reasoning was that if we have enough high-quality colleges with a 10%(Dream)-60%(Target) percent chance of getting in, besides the safeties, then he should have a good shot at getting at least one of them and that’s all we need in the end.

Thanks for the information on Miami Uni, OH and Kansas. Looks like we missed the deadline for Kansas. His Predictive scores in IB will be available only in the last week of November, that’s why most of the Priority deadlines were unachievable. Will definitely look at Miami University again, looks like an attractive scholarship.

You need to realign your % estimates. They are not correct for internationals.

@Sybylla Thanks! Yes, will relook.

You’re welcome!

You’re son has done great and is well qualified. These are just some very competitive schools right now. It is very true that lots of them get many more applications from very well-qualified students than there are spots available. For example, we visited a tip-top LAC a few years ago. They said 70% of applicants were fully qualified, and they were confident that they would succeed academically and otherwise. At the time, the school accepted 14%. So 4 in 5 applicants that the school viewed as fully qualified were denied admission.

And students are really evaluated within pools: in-state/out-of-state; male in-state/female in-state; international, etc. It appears that your son will be in an international pool, which can be more competitive, though probably not always.

Also, Texas, as someone above notes, can be difficult because the state mandates a high % of in-state students, about 95%, I believe, so more competitive for non-Texas residents.

So, just saying, be realistic. Based on the info you provide, your son is a very reasonable applicant for these schools AND, at the same time, admissions can be challenging.

One I like to recommend for strong internationals is the College of William and Mary. W&M is often ranked in the Top Ten among public universities (with California, UCLA, Michigan, UVA, UNC, etc.) and has an excellent business school. In contrast to UT, which takes under 10% OOS students, W&M takes between 30-40% (can’t remember the exact number). It is the 2nd oldest US university and retains college in the name for historical reasons, which I think can put off potential international applicants. As a result, I think the international applicant pool is perhaps smaller than it would be otherwise, given the high quality and reputation of the school, so admission odds are probably better. It’s in a nice, safe town with a well-known historic/tourist district adjacent to campus. Not saying your son would definitely be admitted, but perhaps the odds are better than some of the others on the list.

The school is a mid-size national university with a little over 6000 undergrad students and a small grad school presence, including MBAs and law students.

https://mason.wm.edu

Another is Santa Clara University. It’s right in Silicon Valley, so lots of great internship possibilities. Has a very good business school.

Take a look at some of the data for IB placement coming out of undergrad, such as at this link: https://poetsandquantsforundergrads.com/2018/05/21/top-feeder-schools-to-wall-street/ There are other analyses like this, so do some research.

To get these jobs your S will also need an internship (or 2), so check into internship programs at each school he is considering as well. On the one hand the world of internships and job seeking is getting smaller with linkedin and such sites, on the other hand, school career placement offices do still help.

Lastly to throw a curve ball, several smaller LACs regularly place grads in IB jobs, of course at most of those schools students major in economics, as there typically isn’t a business school. Perhaps look at Williams, Amherst, Bowdoin (but they are all high reaches).

I would actually replace Northeastern with Boston College if he is seeking IB. BC places quite well in NYC and Boston. You have direct admit to CSOM (maybe their mist competitive school for admissions- more difficult than their average numbers).

I agree with you that Texas A&M, Rutgers, and PSU are good choices to have on the list.

Note that subject tests are recommend (not required) at Penn. But most applicants will have completed all of the recommendations. Your son should check the requirements/recommendations for other schools on the list.

My son wants to apply for the fall 2019 session<<<<<<

     Just to clarify, he wants to start college in 2019? And you have submitted complete applications at which schools? TAMU would be an academic admit and he would already know by now. Are you going to have to fill in international financial documentation? Or is all this done?