My daughter got into 7 of the 8 schools she applied to. (She was rejected at Vassar). She’s been so busy with that she hasn’t had time to visit any schools for accepted student days. She’s so stressed out, that she’s having trouble thinking about where to go. She has no strong favorite. She likes different things about the different schools. She’s a serious violinist who is considering majoring in music and is also interested in psychology, English literature, philosophy, and women’s studies. She’s thinking she’ll go on to graduate school in psychology, but music is still a possibility and of course she may discover something entirely new once she gets to college. She’s also a swimmer and plans to swim in college if the team and coach are a good fit. She also enjoys horse back riding. She’s politically liberal, a feminist and atheist. She’s introverted and inexperienced in terms of dating and partying.
Her schools: Bryn Mawr, SUNY Geneseo, Sarah Lawrence, Skidmore, Smith, St. Olaf, and Wooster
St. Olaf and Wooster gave her merit and music scholarships, no college grant. Sarah Lawrence and Bryn Mawr gave her college grant and merit awards. The other 3 private schools gave us only need-based awards that will be substantially less her senior year once her sister graduates from college. Geneseo gave her a $2000 merit award for this year only.
She’s still waiting to hear if she might get the Filene Music Scholarship at Skidmore. She may be offered it if one or more of the 6 winners turns it down. If she gets it, then she will definitely choose Skidmore. Without the Filene, Wooster seems like the obvious choice financially but she didn’t click with the violin teacher or the orchestra teacher when she was there for her audition. Geneseo would allow her to graduate debt free. The other schools she would take out loans totalling $22,000 for four years except for at Smith which would be $13,000 after 4 years. Financially, it seems that St. Olaf would be the next best deal after Wooster and Geneseo (assuming she doesn’t get the Filene). Sarah Lawrence would be by far the most expensive school. We haven’t filed any appeals for more aid, but probably should have (we kept thinking we would hear from Skidmore about the Filene.)
We live in west central New York State. St. Olaf is the farthest school away, but our older daughter is a Freshman at Carleton so the girls would be in the same town which would be nice. Wooster is the longest drive, Geneseo is the shortest with Skidmore next.
Would LOVE some advice especially from people with first hand knowledge of these schools.
“Sarah Lawrence would be by far the most expensive school.”
If she really loves it you could appeal, but otherwise or if the appeal fails I would drop it from the list. If she is considering graduate school, or if she is going to major in anything other than computer science, then you need to minimize the debt for undergrad.
^ appealing usually takes at least 2 weeks at many private institutions and possibly 6 weeks at public ones so it is possible that it may be a bit late now to do so.
I am a huge fan of Smith. The opportunities there are phenomenal, the student/ faculty and mentoring connections are truly special. If I understand correctly, the loan total for all 4 years would be $13,000? That would be my pick!
If she doesn’t like the violin teacher or orchestra at Wooster, that seems like a really big barrier.
How much does she care about swimming? Which schools can she swim at? These are the kind of things I’d be weighing, once I dropped the most expensive places (sounds like Sarah Lawrence should be gone to me)
@Syrxis That’s good to know. We did it right away last year because Carleton was my daughter’s clear favorite. This year we’ve been hedging because we’ve been thinking we might get a call from Skidmore any moment about the Filene.
In terms of her interests, Skidmore and Sarah Lawrence seem like two schools that could be natural fits for her. Overall, though, she’s got some great choices available to her, which makes it hard to recommend even these two ahead of her other options.
@DadTwoGirls The debt would be the same at all the schools except Geneseo (zero) and Smith ($14,000). The other schools are all at $22,000 total. It’s the amount of cash we’ll have to come up with that differs. She seems to like Sarah Lawrence the best at the moment however based on the numbers it’s the least appealing from our end.
If one of the other three private schools WOULD BE your first choice if the aid were the same, call the admissions officer for your area and tell him/her that your daughter is ready to commit if the financial aid can be adjusted, then ask for professional review. They will ask to see the awards from the other schools. Send copies. You should get an answer within 24 hours, particularly if they are concerned about meeting their enrollment numbers this year. A $9000 gap over four years is a really small number for them to meet (but keep in mind that you will have a larger number to pay when tuition increases are factored in).
@cameo43 I feel like we keep hearing that Smith students are stressed, angry, and depressed. What’s your experience? My daughter already has those tendencies somewhat so I don’t want to make them worse. Other than that, for several reasons Smith seems like the obvious choice. She hasn’t visited Smith since 3 years ago. I should have taken her this week and we just couldn’t make it happen.
I would definitely call admissions, they admitted your daughter, they want her so they will try to do what they can to get her to enroll. So many people lose out because they are afraid to call.
First – congrats on so many wonderful options!! I have friends with daughter at Skidmore, Smith & Sarah Lawrence. I know the girls at Smith & Skidmore have been very happy. Not sure about Sarah Lawrence. Not sure there is a serious orchestra at these warranting a music major but you can check. Smith allows students to take courses elsewhere too. If you have specific questions I can try to ask friends.
@PurpleTitan She’s been in touch with all of the coaches except Geneseo and some of the conductors and violin teachers. The St. Olaf orchestra has the best orchestra/conductor by far. And a choice of 3 different violin instructors. Their music program is conservatory level which has both good and bad sides to it. Skidmore would be the second best music program. She loves the violin teacher there too.
I’d vote for Bryn Mawr or Smith due to the environment fit with the description of your daughter, the quality of education, and the consortium opportunities at both.
I’m a spreadsheet girl, that’s how we approached final decisions. Cost of attendance, faculty ratio, school ranking, strength of the music department… that should help you eliminate some that are too expensive, lower rated, not strong in music, don’t have opportunities for her sport… once you have a few final contenders then it’s really about the feel and fit of a school. Can she visit two or 3 before May 1st?