- Ithaca is expensive and gives lousy FA
- Drew U in NJ - -they want to be out of state but it's a possibility
- Earlham
- Wells
- Wagner
- Manhattanvile
- Manhattan
- Washington College in MD
- Juniata
- Denison
- Wooster
Thanks for the suggestions, Susquehanna looks interesting for S2, and I’m going to run the NPC at Ohio University to see if that might be an option. How close do the NPCs tend to be to the real financial aid offers, are they normally within a few thousand dollars?
Looking at our list I agree we might have to look at increasing our distance radius to find the Goldilocks college, the one that is just right!
My impression from when I was doing NPCs, and looking at comments of other CC posters, is that NPCs were pretty accurate unless you were self-employed; then they could be off a bit (they were for us).
Maybe Ursinus in PA? Their Gateway Scholarship (which at least one of them, maybe both, should be eligible for) takes their direct cost from $65K to $35K. It is pretty small at 1500 students, though.
The direct cost at UNC-Asheville is about $34K without any scholarships. It has about 3500 students, and the very artsy small city of Asheville might interest Son #1 in particular.
If you increase your radius, you may want to consider –
- Knox in Illinois
- Lake Forest
- Alfred in NY -- there are two Alfreds. One is SUNY Alfred, but that's not the one I'm suggesting. I'm suggesting Alfred University, which has many unique and interesting programs -- https://alfred.edu/academics/colleges-schools/index.cfm They have the top ceramics program in the country.
- St. Olaf
- University of the Pacific -- if one is interested in engineering. This is a pretty school, great programs. It also has many other non-engineering programs.
- U of Maine at Orono -- a university that's the size of a large college, gorgeous campus, airport next door. I think of it as the less expensive UVM. Orono is now matching in-state tuition. Check their scholarship page to see what NJ residents would pay there. Orono has great sciences and also is strong in theater and many other arts.
- Southwestern U near Austin TX
- R.I.T. -- although this is a "tech" school it has some art programs that at least people at my D's arts HS here in NY are aware of. One in particular is interesting and that is its anatomical drawing program. https://www.rit.edu/programs/medical-illustration-bfa
Thanks @Dustyfeathers for your suggestions. University of Maine in particular looks like a feasible option for S2.
James Madison University in Va?? They would be in range for SAT - Maybe bigger than you’d like (~20K) - but OOS tuition w/out any merit $$ is around $38K. Worth a look at least.
Thanks @4Gulls, JMU seems like a good one to add to our list.
Here is a link to a recent article from the Wall Street Journal about private colleges that match in-state tuition, or public universities that either do not differentiate between in-state and OOS students for tuition purposes, or match the in-state tuition rates for public universities for OOS applicants: https://www.wsj.com/articles/in-race-for-students-colleges-offer-to-match-tuition-at-rival-schools-1535972400. Oglethorpe University in Atlanta was one; SIU-Edwardsville and SIU-Carbondale are others.
Thanks @ gandalf78, some good potential colleges particularly for S2.
Just got S1’s SAT score back- he’s managed to raise it to a 1350, super scored it would be a 1370. Now he’s debating whether to take it one last time to see if he can get it any higher. I’m hoping that this might help a bit with merit as a lot of it seems to start @ the 1330-1350 SAT range. If anyone knows of any colleges that might have merit for that score please post. Thanks.
@tabby18 - look at West Virginia - there is auto merit for GPA/test scores with info posted on their website.
Maybe too small for them (~2,200) students, but they should get merit $$ at Muhlenberg.
https://www.muhlenberg.edu/main/aboutus/finaid/prospectivestudents/merit.html
Thanks @4Gulls and @ mamaedefamilia for your suggestions.
Seton Hall is worth investigating.
Son one should get some scholarship money.
I think average SAT was 1250 this year.
Good school with good outcomes.
Wheaton in Massachusetts is a very nice school, lots of history, and would prob offer merit – https://wheatoncollege.edu/
Beloit is a very nice school with a hip, humorous vibe and is really pretty cheap as far as these things go.https://www.beloit.edu/
I personally love the programs at St. Olaf – lots of music. Gorgeous campus. They have buses to Minneapolis/ St. Paul so that the kids can get into town.
As a fellow NY resident, I think you should consider talking your kids into considering the SUNY’s. So many different size and “fit” possibilities and well within your budget without needing any special merit award. For what its worth, my D recently visited and loved New Paltz. Other than being a SUNY, it fits many of your criteria.