Help please- overwhelmed, college search for twins

Hi,
we are in state for NJ, and our FAFSA EFC estimate looks to be about $31,000 per child. I have run net price calculators at some CSS profile schools and our OOP cost seems to vary from @$44,000 -$51,000 each depending on the college. Ideally looking for the our actual cost per child to be @ $37 K including federal loans. Stats of boys are slightly different, merit may be a challenge. Looking at both in state and OOS options -of course they like the idea of going OOS best! They would consider colleges up to 8 hours from NJ. Are there any colleges that might offer them decent merit to get us within our budget for these stats? They are looking for medium sized schools with at least 3,000 undergrads, but would consider smaller schools if necessary. Neither are keen on the SUNYs, both are still undecided on what they plan to major in.

Son 1 stats: Unweighted GPA 3.48/Weighted 3.90
4 APs already taken Sophomore and Junior year ( scored 3,3,4,4)
Senior year will be taking AP Lit, AP Spanish, AP Art, AP Psych, Hons. Calculus, Hons. Physics.
ECs/job: Editor in chief of school newspaper, Treasurer of school club, summer camp CIT, part-time job @ 15 hrs a week in term time, more hols. Artistically talented, in school district G&T art program since middle school.
SAT 1300, will be taking again to see if he can boost it- (took first time without much study)
Schools considering: TCNJ, Rutgers New Brunswick, Rowan, Ramapo, Towson, Ohio State

Son 2 stats: Unweighted GPA 3.04/Weighted 3.14
Mainly regular classes with a couple of Hons. classes. Took AP English Language junior year grade B (score 3)
Senior year will be taking AP Literature, CP Physics, CP Pre- Calculus, CP economics
Just taken SAT, but not got score back yet, will be taking again soon.
Ecs: Marching band, summer camp CIT, part-time job @ 15 hrs per week in term time
Schools considering: Rowan, Ramapo, Stockton (Rutgers & TCNJ are reach schools)

Any help is greatly appreciated, thanks.

Since money is an issue, why have OOS schools like Ohio State on the list? Not likely getting merit with a 1300 SAT.

I would suggest adding some middle range privates that might give a nice merit offer to get costs down to your goal.

Keep in mind that while you have a budget of $37k per child, you should target about $28k per child since each year costs will go up up up. You wouldn’t want to get to junior year and have each twin’s net costs to be $47k+ per year.

Also, keep in mind that the prices you’re seeing on websites is for either the current school year or maybe even last year. When your kids go, those quoted prices will already be about $2-3k per twin higher.

What is each twin’s major and career goal?

If you really want to look out of state, you could look at some of the non flagships in the Midwest. Ohio University would be an example. The full COA for OOS is right at your top end ($37k). S1 would likely be eligible for some merit aid. It would be a little reachy for S2 based upon GPA alone.

West Virginia U and Marshall U are OOS publics that would be within your budget.

Thanks for your reply @ mom2collegekids:

both are undecided for their major or future career. S1 was looking at Ohio State only if he could boost SAT to above 1330 which I’m fairly confident he can do, and only if he qualified for the National Buckeye Scholarship. the school will only disclose directly to the college if he falls in the top 25% of class rank with a weighted gpa of 3.9

Criteria: Those considered are non-Ohio residents who rank in the top 25 percent of their graduating classes and have an ACT composite score of 29 or higher or SAT Evidence-Based Reading and Writing + Math score equivalent of 1330 or higher. This would give @$13500 off the COA at OSU. I would be happy for them to go in state, but if they can find a school they like OOS at the right price then great.

We have factored in that the price of college will increase quite a bit each year and are budgeting for this in advance. We are also saving a bit extra for other expenses as I’m sure there will be other costs that we haven’t considered not included in the COA. Which middle range private colleges do you think they might get some merit at?

Thanks

There are dozens of schools in North Carolina, South Carolina and Florida that would fit into your requirements. The Florida schools are more than an 8 hour drive, but there are lots of cheap flights. My daughter’s boyfriend and his brother both go/went to school in Florida (from NJ) and their parents visited all the time. They usually drove down in Aug but flew back and forth all other times. There were a lot of kids from NJ (and PA, MD, NY) at the school.

UMaine has a Flagship Match program that offers instate tuition for OOS students.

https://go.umaine.edu/apply/scholarships/flagship-match/

ETA: you don’t get instate Maine tuition but rather what you would pay at your instate uni.

High Point. They send me enough information on a weekly basis to know you could get money there.

Thanks all for the responses, some good recommendations for me to look into. We are supposed to get @ 10-12 colleges for their college lists. I still need a few more schools to add to their lists, if anyone knows of any other colleges that might fit our criteria please post.

Thanks.

Allegheny

UDayton, Depauw…look at some of the Colleges that Change Lives, many of the middle range smaller Catholics…

There are others here who I hope will chime in with names.

Do you want them to attend the same college?

Thanks, @ mom2collegekids:
No, they would hate the idea of attending the same college. I’m not sure that they would consider a religious school, although I know some of these schools give amazing aid.

Academically possible with some merit:
Ohio University (honors for twin #1?), Temple, Ithaca (honors for twin #1?), JMU, CNU (with a shot at honors/presidential Scholars for twin #1), Grand valley state (honors for twin #1), UVermont (honors for twin #1), Fordham.
If you can look at smaller colleges: UScranton, Muhlenberg, Susquehanna, Elizabethtown (esp. Twin #2), Elmira (esp. Twin #2), Hobart WilliamSmith, Mount St Mary’s MD (esp. Twin #2), Ohio Wesleyan, Allegheny, St Michael’s.
No certainty that merit will be sufficient for your price point.

If you say Rutgers is a reach then I’d say Rowan Ramapo as you listed already but I’d add NJIT as well. All fine schools. The dorms at Ramapo are extremely comfortable; some of the nicest you will see at any college. Rowan is a great campus layout and size. NJIT has a little of everything, rated high but the trade-off is the campus surroundings may not be the best but workable. The thing with NJIT is the job market is great for graduates at NJIT because of its proximity which draws companies to their career fair.

Thanks for your recommendations MYOS1634. I will run the NPCs on those colleges you listed and see if the numbers might work.

I’d scrap the 8-hour and medium-sized criteria. Although I’m sure both are sincerely desired, they are both things that SEEM important, but really aren’t ( as opposed to, say, wanting to major in engineering and a college doesn’t offer engineering).

Whether kids are a 3-hour drive away, or a 5-hour flight away, it probably won’t matter as much as you think. And size of undergrad enrollment is one of those things about which people tend to think they know what they want, but in fact you can adapt to whatever size the student body is (I’ve attended a bunch of colleges, ranging in size from 225 to 60,000 students…there wasn’t that much difference).

Some of the most reputable colleges that will be in your price range are major state universities in the south and midwest. They tend to have reasonable sticker prices, and when you factor in aid based on grades and ACT/SAT, they should be well within your price range.

I’d start with Oklahoma State, U of Mississippi, U of South Dakota, & U of South Florida.

Elon University in North Carolina for son #1.

I also think that a look at the CTLC schools would show the possibility of merit aid. Many are smaller than the 3,000 size and further than 5 hours.

Susquehanna University is very generous with aid.

Have them look closer at the SUNY’s…they are affordable at full price. There are many of them depending on what they want to major in.

I highly recommend TCNJ! Rowan is very up an coming so will be a good value.