If I understand your post, then Princeton University would only cost you $19,000 per year ? If so, the decision should lean toward Princeton in my opinion. (Even though you cannot double major at Princeton.)
Otherwise, three distinct choices with respect to location: Urban, suburban & rural. Do you have a strong preference ?
Then Princeton since you may be headed to grad school for law or business which would bring Columbia & Dartmouth College back into consideration, but not Princeton as it doesn’t offer an MBA or JD degree.
I feel that you want to go to Columbia. Try negotiating with their financial aid office using what Princeton is offering you. They might give you more aid. If they do, go to Columbia!