HELP with decision

Hi,

I recently got into Duke RD with no financial aid ($0) for biology as a Canadian student from Ontario. For some reason, I didn’t even apply for FA.

The costs would be around 100k CAD a year.

My other choice is Mcmaster for life sciences (a lower ranking Canadian school).

The costs would be around 20k CAD a year.

Are the costs for Duke worth it? I’m not sure if I want to do med school yet (maybe pharmacy or grad studies). Please help me decide.

Where is this money to pay for college going to come from? Cash on hand…or loans?

The cost of attendance at Duke is over $75,000 USD a year…so $300,000 USD for four years. You can do the conversion.

That’s a huge amount of money…huge. Does your family have the resources to fund this?

@thumper1

Hi, my mom is willing to go as far as refinancing the house to pay for this Duke education. It would completely cover the 300k cost easily, but the question is: is a Duke education really worth going that far?

Second Q: Let’s say I take student loans instead. I would imagine that would kill me as a bio undergrad because the costs of med school (another couple hundred thousand dollars) would hit me later. And a bio undergrad isn’t worth as much as other undergrads. Am I right?

Your mom should not put her whole house on the line for you to attend Duke, in my opinion.

Why didn’t you apply for financial aid?

YOU can’t take out loans to the tune of $75,000 a year.

What makes you say McMaster is a lower ranking school? Quick search says minimum ACT is 27. This is on par with some very good American schools.

By my own financial standards, if McMaster offers your field of study, Duke is not worth the cost.

@thumper1

It was actually my mom’s idea to not apply for FA. She thought it’d negatively affect my chances. Now that I got in, she wants me to go to Duke regardless of any costs over McMaster. I’m the one that wants to save money and go to mcMaster, because I feel that Duke’s bio undergrad isn’t worth 100k CAD a year (literally what an entire 4 years at mcMaster would cost)

A big reason why she wants to send me to a super prestigious American school is because she thinks I’ll make connections with innovators… She also says the job opportunities are much better for a Duke grad. Is this really true?

@OhiBro

Interesting, I didn’t know Americans had to send SAT/ACT scores to apply to Canadian schools. For Canadians like me, all they needed was our grade 12 average.

But compared to Duke (ranked around top 15), Mcmaster is still considered a lower ranking school (ranked around 100). My mom seems to think that the job opportunities/networking for a bio undergrad is worth paying 100k CAD a year for to go to Duke.

@UraharaKisuke

I have to respect your mother’s opinion, as you should. I only offer my personal opinion, which is somewhat supported by this article:

https://www.npr.org/2019/01/03/681851493/does-it-matter-where-you-go-to-college-the-answer-it-depends

Also, the McMaster ACT requirement I cited is from this link:

https://future.mcmaster.ca/admission/documents/

@OhiBro Okay, thanks for the information.

You are sane. Your mother is confused. And maybe a bit over-invested in the notion that a certain college/university will magically justify the kind of expense she’s contemplating.

Does she listen to sensible adults, or is she in love with Duke?

You are correct that you aren’t going to land a job straight out of college with a biology degree that is going to allow you to make any sort of dent in the kind of debt your mom is talking about. A Duke degree in biology is not going to get you anything that you can’t get from McMaster, or from umpteen other colleges and universities in the US and Canada for that matter. Most of what you get out of your education is up to you.

Go to McMaster. Do well. Give yourself some time to figure out what it is that you want to do with your biology degree. Not having a boatload of debt for yourself, or worrying that your mom will be homeless because she can’t pay back the loan on the house, will make it infinitely easier for you to find your own best pathway.

And if you do end up in med school or dent school or pharmacy school, that might be the time for your mom to borrow against her house to help pay tuition bills.