<p>Not necessarily. I was almost killed by a vaccine reaction. My argument would be that parents should be able to decide what is worth the risk. For some people it’s better to be vaccinated, for others it’s better not to be. Parents should educate themselves on the benefits and hazards of vaccines and then make the choice best for their family.</p>
<p>But that could lead to reduced vaccination and greater vulnerability to epidemics.</p>
<p>Mandatory vaccination saves lives.</p>
<p>They can also kill. I haven’t been vaccinated since I was 2.5 (when I had the seizure that almost killed me). I was incredibly lucky. People should be able to decide whether they want to risk that.</p>
<p>. .</p>
<p>I just realized that I’ll know about every school I’m applying to by the end of next month.
Brandeis says I’ll know by Dec 15th. Pace told me I’ll know by Christmas. So Pace is the one I’ll know about last.</p>
<p>And you’re sure the vaccination was responsible for your seizure? We’ve all seen your stories of your many illnesses; how can you be certain that the seizure was not just another one of your ailments? Allowing families to choose whether they are vaccinated is unsafe for everyone and opens the door for dangerously low vaccination rates in response to fundamentalist misconceptions. I’d be happy to send you my 2012 state debate case on vaccination that explains the dangers of non-mandatory vaccination.</p>
<p>EDIT: Here’s the opening statement of my case:</p>
<pre><code>Vaccines have revolutionized the medical field and have saved hundreds of millions of lives in the last century alone. Unfortunately, public confusion and misinformation regarding vaccination has led to many anti-vaccine movements. In the UK the scare that the MMR vaccine may be connected to autism triggered by the bogus study by Andrew Wakefield resulted in a precipitous drop in vaccination rates down to about 78% overall. This resulted in a surge of measles – from a low of less than 100 cases per year to 1,348 cases in 2008. The surge continues today despite an aggressive campaign to inform the public about the safety of the MMR vaccine. This is just one example of the disaster that can result from a lack of mandated vaccination.
</code></pre>
<p>EDIT2: Here’s part of my first contention:</p>
<p>One of the most compelling justifications for mandatory state vaccination is the absolute wealth of historical and scientific evidence supporting both its effectiveness in eradicating disease and its safety. Within the last century, the number of people afflicted with diseases that have plagued humans for millennia has decreased dramatically because of vaccination. These diseases include polio, measles, and meningitis. In fact, smallpox was completely eradicated by systematic vaccination. The World Health Organization estimates that vaccines annually prevent almost 6 million deaths worldwide. In the USA, there has been a 99% decrease in incidence for the nine diseases for which vaccines have been widely used, accompanied by a similar decline in mortality and diseases. </p>
<p>And a bit from my third:</p>
<p>As immunization rates drop, the protection against disease grows thinner. That’s what happened in the current measles outbreaks in the western U.S., and that’s what happened in Nigeria in 2001, when religious and political leaders convinced parents that polio vaccines were dangerous and their kids should not receive them. Over the next six years, not only did Nigerian infection rates increase 30-fold, but the disease also broke free and ranged out to 10 other countries, many of which had previously been polio-free.</p>
<p>Yes, I’m sure. My connective tissue disorder has nothing to do with seizures. It doesn’t cause that. If you go on the CDC’s website, even they admit that vaccines can cause life-threatening reactions. I wouldn’t have been given a medical exemption if my doctor did not believe the vaccine caused it. I’ve never had another seizure either. </p>
<p>Someone in my college health class is having repetitive seizures after receiving the Gardasil vaccine. Her doctors believe that is the cause because the seizures started after receiving the vaccine. The doctors did a full examination and looked into any other causes. They couldn’t find any other reason. </p>
<p>Since most of you disagree with me, I probably shouldn’t write about that because I’m guessing the admissions officer would disagree.</p>
<p>You definitely should not write about vaccination if your stance is anti.</p>
<p>And your anecdotal evidence is not convincing. I’d love to see some stronger sources. Gardasil (an HPV vaccination) is voluntary anyway (i.e. not mandatory), so that point is null. Regardless, the infinitesimal risk to the individual is much smaller than the huge risk to society associated with even slight decreases in general vaccination rates.</p>
<p>You might be right about vaccinations and you do make a good point. But because of the controversy surrounding the whole “vaccines cause autism” thing and the diffusion into other debates, it’s true that another issue might work better for you.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>If I were applying to NYU, this would be the first sentence of my supplement essay</p>
<p>I’m not going to write about it. </p>
<p>I don’t agree with the whole autism thing. I just don’t think the govt should have the right to tell people that they have to risk the side effects. (Especially when the risks on both sides are very significant.) I’m not anti vaccine, just anti-allowing the govt to make important health decisions.</p>
<p>Speed limits are health decisions.</p>
<p>The difference there is that there isn’t a risk associated with following the speed limit.</p>
<p>There is a huge risk associated with <em>not</em> following the speed limit, and there is a huge risk associated with <em>not</em> being vaccinated. When an action (such as refusing vaccination or driving at reckless speeds) endangers the lives of those around you, it’s no longer just about personal rights but about the rights of society as a whole.</p>
<p>You have to see the difference here though. While vaccines can save lives, they can be deadly. (Both sides have risks.) Following the speed limit isn’t dangerous but not following it is dangerous. (Risks associated with the illegal action but no risks associated with the legal action.)</p>
<p>But not following vaccination requirements can be just as deadly. Not everyone can get a vaccine, due to health reasons. Some of these people are the most susceptible to illnesses, and they rely on others getting vaccinated to bolster herd immunity and keep them healthy. I think it’s unfair that people can get out of vaccinating my claiming it’s against their religion or whatever, just because they don’t feel the government should tell them what to do. </p>
<p>And don’t get me started about that whole autism scare cooked up by a washed up actress.</p>
<p>Rachel, you’re severely overstating the risks of vaccination. It is almost never deadly or anything close. All vaccines are tested for years before being approved by the FDA and CDC; if a vaccine is unsafe, it will not be approved. Being vaccinated is much less risky than driving a car regularly.</p>
<p>Yes, not following the requirements can be deadly, but so can following them. I don’t think something is selfish if it can kill you or do serious damage. You can’t be guaranteed that your next vaccine won’t cause a serious reaction. You shouldn’t be forced to take that risk. I will not vaccinate my future children. I refuse to have to go through what my parents did. Until they make vaccines that can’t cause seizures, brain damage, etc., vaccines shouldn’t be mandatory. Now, if we experience an outbreak of something (like in the movie Contagion) deadly, I think vaccinating would be worth the risk.</p>
<p>I know these reactions are rare. Regardless, it still needs to be up to the individual whether or not they want to risk it. <a href=“http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/side-effects.htm[/url]”>http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/side-effects.htm</a> Even the CDC acknowledges that vaccines can be deadly. They are rare, but severe reactions do occur.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>They have made such vaccines. Anyway, as I cited above, the general population is subject to dangerous whims that can and have endangered society as a whole. Not vaccinating a child is far more risky than the alternative. </p>
<p>Were an outbreak of Contagion-like proportions to emerge, it would be because of people like you, and thousands if not millions of lives lost would fall on your shoulders. Remember–vaccination is a preventative measure, not a cure. The whole point of vaccination is to prevent such outbreaks, and your and others’ insistence on refusing to be vaccinated is antithetical to that purpose.</p>