High School Class of 2014

<p>Any Science Olympiad kids up in hurrrr?</p>

<p>wow, haters</p>

<p>i didn’t do a cancer project to be mainstream. maybe i know someone who has cancer? maybe i’m genuinely interested? and i might not even do intel sts or siemens. maybe i just want to write my paper with the professor who lets me work in her lab and go from there?</p>

<p>oh no, people who want to help save or improve lives of the victims of a horrible disease are winning the science fairs?? </p>

<p>can you honestly think of a more worthy reason?</p>

<p>because it’s popular right now for a reason.
just like HIV research, or really any other medical field research.</p>

<p>i think any project that could help save lives is popular right now.</p>

<p>cell line research is inaccurate?? so we should just test right into people and animals… good idea</p>

<p>also, every recurrent genetic change, such as gene mutations, deletions, amplifications, translocations, on and on, found in tumors has been identified in cell lines. ever hear of translational research?</p>

<p>in vitro projects can be very accurate, especially in my project, where i made a microfluidic device that improves the in vitro environment…</p>

<p>Sorry, clementines2016, I’m not hating on your project in particular, sometimes projects that are really simple that have to do with cancer and then bam. suddenly you hear their name. </p>

<p>Too bad # of winners per category is not monitored. It would be great if biological sciences had their own science fairs of the same caliber of Intel/Siemens where you submit a research paper. There’s probably enough students to do that. </p>

<p>Of course, then it would get confusing when you throw bioinformatics into the mix. I attempted to do bioinformatics but there aren’t that many specialists willing to help. I respect anyone who has a mentor and can work in a college lab. Well, that is, if they’re not related/a family friend to the PI.</p>

<p>I was going to do a bioinformatics project either involving stroke or HIV, but could not find a mentor or even mentors who could tell me about either the diseases or more advanced bioinformatic techniques, so I scrapped it for my project that will surely not win anything. </p>

<p>Oh, btw, I’m on SciOly but my school only made Nationals my freshman year, before I knew anything about the team.</p>

<p>Okay, clementine, I apologize for being a bit rude and over the top with my comments. I was having a pretty miserable day when I wrote that. I wasn’t meaning to attack you. I actually didn’t read your posts - just quidditch’s, when I was skimming.</p>

<p>My issue with the cancer projects is that I know a guy, who did not do the work himself and (it was pretty redundant too) places extremely well at a bunch of competitions (think major money). His parents then bashed my stuff for not being cancer or cool enough, when I used a technique that’s not that common. I know another guy, who did SIGNIFICANTLY less work than me - think culture some cells and do a little staining/image them who placed over because he did cancer in a smaller competition. One judge legitimately told me that that he didn’t believe my work because it wasn’t a western blot and HS kids do cancer. </p>

<p>And my issue with in * vitro * is that you can’t kill some cells and say it’s a <strong><em>cure</em></strong>. And that they’re not comparable…an cell line that’s supposed to be like an epithelial cell has 54 chromosomes? (T84) Those extra chromosomes have to do something. And we haven’t really figured out gene therapy yet beyond cell lines. </p>

<p>In many ways, animal work is easier than nonanimal work, I definitely concede that. And yes, cell work has a place - I did a cell project myself on something related strongly to cancer (cell cycle control)! I just don’t like it when people run out there and say it’s a cure. It’s a possible precursor, maybe. So yeah, translational research.</p>

<p>The hype is just super annoying and I think you’ll have to concede that among people who are not well informed, they gasp at cancer and don’t acknowledge other work. That can be frustrating. And ISEF is not 100% lock that you’ll get a smart or informed judge. I think they match abstracts electronically for words and many judges had nothing to do with my area, and the guy who was an expert in my field got assigned to the kid with the cancer cell culture. </p>

<p>I think science fairs in general reward what’s trendy, which is frustrating, above solid research. With bioinformatics, my friend actually did some work with peanut allergies and modelling of it and the ISEF judges ignored that bit and talked about her scant in vitro work. I think old people are not well acquainted with bioinfo. </p>

<p>Don’t get me wrong, science fair is a really good experience, but I think you need to look at research as the reward itself, because science fair can be hella unfair. It can be great sometimes for publicity, but it’s not the be all end all. I wish you the best of luck with whatever you’re applying for!</p>

<p>omg, yeah, the most annoying part of bioinformatics are the older judges. they told me my project was not valid for science fair, and proceeded to say I wasted their time. </p>

<p>i mean, i think even without these awards, my teachers know about how much effort I put into these things.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>lol that’s not even what i’m doing. i’m dealing with cell interactions and cancer stem cell development. i’m using already established medicine inside my device. i’m not necessarily going after a cure, but what makes things worse, especially for the cells’ environment.</p>

<p>and i’ve seen a lot of high school cancer projects, and none of them claim to cure anything or fit your description. maybe you’re just not understanding their projects.</p>

<p>@superstarlala I would average the hours :)</p>

<p>The new iOS 7 is seriously bugging me.</p>

<p>Kudos for the heated cancer discussion btw. I don’t know a lot about cancer but I do know that there are so many different types of cancer out there and they’re all malicious in their own ways, there are so many personal acquaintances of mine who have been/will continue to be affected by it, and that it’s an incredibly difficult disease to overcome, even with the most scientifically up-to-date treatments.</p>

<p>Although I agree about the INTEL thing- if I were to make a formula for a winning science fair project, it would have something to do with cancer. Not saying that that’s the end goal for all high schoolers who study cancer, but I’m sure it plays a large factor given the prestige of INTEL, Siemens, etc.</p>

<p>@Mocheng: The new iO2 7 is bugging everyone. It’s all over Twitter.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well then, great! It sounds like a super awesome idea and I’m sure you will do great :slight_smile: .</p>

<p>Maybe I come from a crappy region or one that skews to cancer stuff - mind you, I am international, but I saw stuff like that at my regionals and nationals. I’m pretty decently acquainted with protein - protein interaction stuff and whatnot so I don’t think I’m misunderstanding them. And work aside, everyone sells it as ‘the next big thing’ even if it’s something that’s not going to immediately cure something. The specific projects I am referencing - I know the kids well and basically saw their project 100x at least. </p>

<p>Look, I’m not trying to bash you, or your work that you did at all! I hate it when people misunderstand me and make generalizations about my work either and I’m sorry if I came off that way.</p>

<p>What I am against is the “hype factor” that exists in science fairs and in general. I think it’s not always the best stuff that wins, per se, but the stuff that’s the most marketable. I know a 4X ISEF veteran who won best in category twice and even he’ll admit that part of it is how it ‘looks’. And I think this is unfortunate because sometimes better stuff is looked over. I used it to my advantage - my soph year project was tangentially related to cancer and I honestly had so-so results but I just blabbed for a while about the possible uses of my discovery 40 years (and idk even then, it was a really just figure out the function thing) down the road and I got to go to nationals over some other girl who I think was honestly better than me. </p>

<p>And this basically carries over to real life. When is science represented in media?
When there are: killer robots, a “cure for cancer”, “how to get thinner” etc. etc. I think it’s a shame we don’t recognize other stuff. This adds up in funding too…recently, the federal government reduced and tied funding to “hot button diseases” and it really sucked for people who did non ‘hot button’ stuff and the people who got fired because there was no money. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well, there’s just a marketable sense to it. I think cancer or renewable energy or some super weird gadget work. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>wow that’s really rude. My friend got blown off too and another friend who did a project on fundamental physics (basically an addition to newton’s laws that’s getting published somewhere) got laughed at by the judges who were like old men.</p>

<p>I just wish we had better judges and a strong focus on the quality of work. It’s really disappointing when you or your friends get screwed over. I love science fair as an experience - it is super fun if you come from afar but I wish some things were different.</p>

<p>To be 100% fair, I am a bit bitter about last year, which may be why I’m being so harsh. And I’m genuinely sorry if I was rude. I have mixed feelings on science fair. </p>

<p>Ultimately, all we can do is do our best and hope.</p>

<p>@The last couple of pages:</p>

<p>[NERRRRRDDDDDD</a> - YouTube](<a href=“NERRRRRDDDDDD - YouTube”>NERRRRRDDDDDD - YouTube)</p>

<p>An event I had to organize was today, and it was a success. I’m feeling accomplished. :)</p>

<p>My Intel/Siemens project has to do with Type I Diabetes. Not mainstream at all, right?</p>

<p>so… how many people are doing Intel/Siemens here? or any big science fair? </p>

<p>lol…</p>

<p>god, I hate people. This chick I know was bragging about her MIT interview and talking about how she had designed the interface for some kind of computer/tablet that’s now on the market. When I asked her what programming language she’s familiar with she said “Linux” and then said “Android”. </p>

<p>-__-</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>lol sr yr disillusionment</p>

<p>I wish I would have known about Intel/Siemens before finding CC. I didn’t even know there were high school kids that even did research. </p>

<p>On the other hand, I’m not sure how I feel about turning scientific research into a competition. Its good that it gets more people interested in science, but I don’t think competitiveness is necessarily a good characteristic for a scientist to have.</p>

<p>That’s not saying anything negative about anyone who participates, as I sure wish I could have done it as well!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>hahahahah yeah it actually gets pretty hardcore</p>

<p>i was trying to find my way inside a building once, and this girl told me the wrong direction on purpose. </p>

<p>and some guy who was competing with me was like, “i bet you don’t even know what your project title means” RIGHT in front of the judges</p>

<p>haha yeah, it does get intense. </p>

<p>It’s going to be so weird to be collaborating with people in the real world of research. Like in college… and actually being a scientist…</p>

<p>Gonna have to learn how to trust people again. This sounds morbid, but it’s unfortunately true. </p>

<p>Also since so many people are really competitive in my area it makes me worried all day erryday.</p>