High School Class of 2014

<p>Mass is just a bitter place. Everyone is chill in MD.</p>

<p>I’ve missed out on a bit!
I’ve literally slept for like a week straight after all my acceptances came out- I had no idea how stressful these last few weeks had been on my psyche. </p>

<p>I LOVE the respect underclassmen show me! Other than being 5’9 and wearing business clothes to school bc I have co-op, they look at me like I’m some mystical god lol</p>

<p>As far as reactions to my acceptances, it’s been “interesting”. Similarly to you, @preamble, some people try to play that “I took harder classes then you mess” or “what’s your gpa?” or most annoyingly, the silent “it’s because she’s black” judgement. Tbh, I really could care less about what people think bc I’m about to go 2,000 miles away, but some people need to chill. Just like everyone who gets into top tier schools, I WORKED for those acceptances- it’s been an 18 year production! I do have sympathy for people like our salutatorian who was rejected from every ivy. Although naive, I wish everyone could get some kind of gratification for their hard work…</p>

<p>Race or socioeconomic background is NEVER the ONLY reason someone gets into a college. Granted, affirmative action can help tip the scales in someone’s favor. But nothing can replace hard work at the end of the day. They’re all fools @lydiamanglin. </p>

<p>I know a kid who’s really bitter because he only got into a not so well ranked school, but aLSO ONE OF THE BEST LIBERAL ARTS COLLEGES IN THE COUNTRY. WHEN HE READ THAT ARTICLE ABOUT THE KID WHO GOT INTO THE IVIES. HE SAID “IT REALLY BOTHERS ME HOW THE ONLY THING THAT KEPt me from getting into the ivies when he got in was my race” It really made me mad.
Also, sorry for the caps. They were an accident.</p>

<p>I always get irked when people cite affirmative action immediately when they see a person of color excel. </p>

<p>Yeah, affirmative action probably helped that student get into XYZ college over you - coupled with the fact that they probably also scored 400 points higher than you on the SAT, too. And they’re probably a hell of a lot more interesting than your bland whiny ass. LOL. </p>

<p>A couple of kids were complaining that they had better scores and grades and didn’t get in anywhere. Also, sometimes they look at how good your HS is something that’s hard to control within the application process.</p>

<p>Argue with me as much as you want, but at the end of the day, if you have two identical candidates, and one’s Asian and the other’s black, the black one will have a much higher chance of getting in.</p>

<p>The only thing with that logical fallacy is that Asian and black students come from such different cultures, pressures, and backgrounds(usually) that they will NEVER be identical. </p>

<p>I find that hard to believe. There are over 3 million high school graduates. </p>

<p>Also, that’s stereotyping. It’s not like all Asians go to prep schools in California and all blacks to to inner city schools in Atlanta.</p>

<p>Most opponents of AA assume that there is a hypothetical well-off black kid that’s taking the place of a hypothetical poor Asian/white kid. While you may hear a few cases of that happening, I suggest either reading books or articles on the topic, or actually talking to the kids that do benefit from AA at top colleges and universities(like MITES/E2 alums, most of who came from impoverished backgrounds, and are heading off to Ivies/MIT/Stanford/Chicago in droves this fall). Many of them are the most brilliant kids I know who came from ridiculous backgrounds and overcame ridiculous obstacles, in which their race undoubtedly played a part.</p>

<p>A great book on the topic is “The Shame of the Nation” by Jonathan Kozal, or “Hope in the Unseen” by somebody(about a MITES alum who despite scoring in the triple digits on the SAT, back when it was out of 1600, went to Brown. It follows him for two years after matriculation and depicts his struggles and epiphanies about the consequences of AA for kids AFTER the applause is over and they’re left to face life on their own.)</p>

<p>Or, you could poke around on the stats threads and see the dozens of hispanic/black kids that get rejected and waitlisted from Ivies just like everybody else(read: black+2100 SAT =/= Harvard acceptance).</p>

<p>Or, we should probably stop talking about this as affirmative action discussions violate the CC terms of service. :/</p>

<p>I didn’t say they would get in. Just a higher acceptance rate assuming they meet the academic standards. </p>

<p>I feel like most of the challenges they face are based from socio-economic class primarily. But I do agree, a poor white kid will face less challenges than a poor black kid. However, I doubt a rich white kid will face less challenges than a rich black kid.</p>

<p>But yes, we should stop talking about it.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>“Identical candidates”? Applicants can only be identical statistically. But due to the holistic process, statistics aren’t the only factors. If the black kid was accepted over the asian kid, it had to be more than just race. </p>

<p>Talking about results threads doesn’t really help your argument, @AmaranthineD. They always have tons of relatively less qualified hispanics and blacks that get in with numbers that would almost always get a white kid shut out. Black+2100 SAT =/= Harvard acceptance, but white+2100 SAT ≈ Harvard rejection.</p>

<p>Identical ECs for the most part, similar suburban high school, sheesh, there are 3 million high school graduates, not everyone is a special little snowflake.</p>

<p>Lol no.</p>

<p>If race didn’t matter they wouldn’t ask you for it.</p>

<p>@TinnyT “If the black kid was accepted over the asian kid, it had to be more than just race.”</p>

<p>Neat opinion, but actual college admissions reps say the exact opposite of this. The gist of what I’ve heard straight from people who work in the admissions offices at Michigan, Stanford, and MIT, is that race sometimes is a “tiebreaker” between two similar applicants.</p>

<p>Race is ONE of the many, many things that can be a tiebreaker between two similar applicants.</p>

<p>@AmaranthineD They have a word for that. It’s racism.</p>

<p>lol. “discrimination” against white people is not racism. </p>