High school class of 2016

Thanks, everyone!

I wish I could apply to NYU as my only safety, but I don’t want to rely on a school that’s going to give me no fin aid…

@Woandering - Just curious, what do you like about University of Rochester?

I think this comment from a NY Times article about Harvard admissions sums up perfectly how I feel about the college admissions process.

“Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein” is not nearly as scary as Harvard’s admission process, designed to construct the super-human organism called the Freshman Class. What Harvard and other elite colleges dont get is that their hyper-competitive policies reward neurotic backstabbing cynical overachievers and their largely affluent parents who can pay the price: for expensive musical lessons, travel soccer, mercy missions to Africa, academic and admission tutors etc. I’d like to hear one admission officer say it’s more impressive for a kid to get a job suitable for a teenager (lifeguard ?) and earn spending money (and learn the mundane lesson that you have to work for the things you want and live within your means) than work at an unpaid internship (that Mummy or Daddy arranged and support by giving the kid allowance $$ and a car during the year). And Harvard’s acknowledged desire for superstars sends the message that even as a kid, there’s no time to smell the roses — you’ve never done enough, you cant relax, you cant just be a kid — it’s not enough to get straight A’s, you must take the most advanced courses in every subject whether interested or not (lacking interest itself is an academic demerit), with perfect SATS, you also must unique extra-curriculars like playing symphonic cello in the marching band on the foot controlled non-carbon emitting platform you designed and built yourself. From all accounts, heaven is not nearly as hard to get into as Harvard. What’s that say about Harvard?”

@Woandering Dude, URoch is like the only safety school that I wouldn’t actually mind going to. It’s got fantastic research.


Has it become a popular pastime to bash Harvard and the other Ivies/Ivy-tier schools for their selectivity? Harvard, as a private college, can require whatever it wants from people who apply to it, be it having perfect SATs or showing up on its doorstep wearing a clown costume and pink bunny ears. If one has a problem with the “neurotic backstabbing cynical overachievers” that allegedly populate Harvard and similar schools, he or she should just not apply and stop complaining about it. Stuff like this just sounds like the polemic of a bitter student who was rejected from Harvard or Yale or ________. And the ones who say this before applying but go on to apply anyways are essentially hypocrites, like the guy who wrote an entire article criticizing his Columbia classmates for being vapid and materialistic when he, by his own admission, only remained at Columbia for the opportunities it provided him.

@glasshours
Its “near open” curriculum is basically perfect for me. I would study economics/financial economics, computer science, and philosophy, coming out with a double major and actually exploring my interests. Fantastic music school, with orchestras I can join, so I can continue music. Some clubs that I would love to join, and other smaller things.

Like @TeamRocketGrunt I definitely wouldn’t mind going there. I’m pretty happy about my list right now, because there’s not one school I wouldn’t mind going to. Hopefully, I’m not making a mistake treating U of R as my safety, because that’s the only one I have right now. I don’t want to add anything that will take away my time from applying to the ones I actually want to go to. I might also apply to the UCs, and I’ll just add a few safeties there, because it’s just one application, but I’ll see how it goes.

EDIT: I’ll be applying to U of R in their PR round, so if I get rejected or deferred there, I’ll just apply to U of Alabama or another safety.

@TeamRocketGrunt Sorry if that came off as Ivy-bashing, it’s really my frustration with the whole admissions system in general. Read the second half of the quote. It’s about how the hyper-selectivity of colleges has made it so that a lot of people don’t enjoy their teenage years. It’s all about “How many APs are you taking? What high-intensity summer programs are you a part of?” I’m a firm believer that if certain subjects don’t align with your interests, you shouldn’t be forced to take the highest level of rigor available in order to be considered competitive at a college. I’m an English guy and I don’t particularly care for Math or Science. Does that mean I should be penalised for not taking AP Calc/Bio/Physics/etc.? That’s my real problem. Our society today doesn’t always allow people to pursue what makes them happy, and people are often discouraged from doing the things that they love.

@WindyCityKid How would you change society so it both allows everyone to do what each enjoys and has a fair political and economic system?

@Woandering obviously there’s no clear-cut answer, otherwise someone would have come up with the solution by now. As a society we should focus more on allowing teenagers to grow up and find themselves in the kind of intangible ways you could never put on a college app (going to music festivals, sharing dinner with friends, sneaking out late at night to meet your girlfriend).

@WindyCityKid Except when universities focus on that, the universities get less “impressive” students. Like you said, there’s currently no clear cut solution. The best system we have right now is capitalism. It can be unfortunate.

Trust me, I would love something like what you’ve described, but right now, it’s just not feasible.

@Woandering I say this as someone with relatively high stats, but I don’t feel like the obsessive focus of colleges on achievements creates a healthy lifestyle for a lot of kids. When doing things is more about getting into college than doing what you’re passionate about, I believe then it becomes a problem.

@WindyCityKid And there are many, many people who are stuck with jobs they don’t necessarily like, but they make great money. If your goal is to get into a great college, then you’ll be stuck doing some stuff that you might hate, because this is the best system we have. There’s definitely a problem there, but there’s no way to fix it, yet, without creating more problems.

There are those who do what they like, but do not always make great money. For us, we could actively learn about what we are actually interested in and likely get into a worse college than otherwise. We might yet turn out to be great people of history. However, we’ve “lost” the college game. Those who do what they like, in capitalism, don’t always make the most money, but they’re usually happier doing what they like to do.

It’s simply this capitalistic system that gets out of the human resources what humanity needs or wants most. We want engineers and businessmen to keep humanity inventing and producing more, so they make the most money. There is no human bias there.

Sometimes, if we all do what we are passionate about, we could live a comfortable life together. Other times, the world will fall apart. It’s not a risk humanity is willing to take, clearly.

P.S Also a high stat kid, I sometimes envy some of my friends who do do what they’re passionate about. Not everyone is college-obsessed like we are. They do get stressed about grades, but they also take classes that they want to take. However, they’ve also accepted that they probably won’t be going to Harvard.

@Woandering I think I’m in somewhat of a weird position. While academically, I’m probably qualified enough to at least be considered by an Ivy, the very prospect of going to one never seemed to appeal to me all that much. I go to a very competitive public school (top 5 in the state), but everyone seems to be just as interested, if not more so in non-academic pursuits. I feel like for the “exploring yourself and doing fun, crazy things” part of college, the ivys don’t have the same atmosphere as something like a big state school. Although academic quality can’t be undervalued, I think there’s more pieces of the puzzle to be considered.

@WindyCityKid Have you visited the Ivies? I don’t think the Ivies would necessarily lose to any other school in terms of non-academic activities either. They’re still full of young adults, and young adults do need entertainment. In any case, it’s better to be non-obsessed about the Ivies than to be obsessed for the wrong reasons.

@Woandering I haven’t, so my posts are essentially sweeping generalizations :stuck_out_tongue: The closest I’ve gotten to visiting an Ivy was visiting Stanford, and I was not impressed with their lack of professionalism (info session presenter reading off sticky notes and not being able to answer a lot of questions, 100+ people in a single tour group). The honest truth is probably that I don’t know how I’d handle the uber-competitive environment of the top schools, and that scares me.

@WindyCityKid That scares me too! If I do get into any of my reaches, I’m just hoping the excitement of going to a top school never wears off, so I won’t be worried about the competition. Honestly, though, I’m going to really relax a bit more in college, since I won’t be going to grad school. Do some internships, and go to more parties. I can’t wait.

My parents work for a service that does job placement- you just need a college degree to get a well-paying job, not some fancy education from an Ivy. So you’re going to Harvard just for your bachelor’s? To major in economics? Biology? And what job concerning economics can you get with an Ivy degree that you can’t get with a degree from Ohio State, Penn State or even SUNY Buffalo. It isn’t about the name anymore when getting a job. Whether it is a top 20 school or a top 500 school, college isn’t a given, so be lucky you’re even going.

@Woandering haha what schools are you looking at?

@jdschooled5 You’re right for most careers, but not Investment Banking, which is where, a bit unfortunately, I want to start in. Therefore, prestige logically matters for me.

@WindyCityKid My favorite is Claremont McKenna. Otherwise, in order of preference: Harvard (haha), Cornell, Stanford (haha), Colgate University, Bucknell University, University of Rochester. How about you?

@Woandering ayyy I wanna do investment banking too. Or consulting idk rn

Do any other prestigious uni’s have an open curriculum like brown’s? not UR