High School Class of 2017

Does anyone want to give me advice about who to ask for a rec letter next year? I have some possible teachers, but all have their caveats…

Two teacher recs:

  1. Honors Precalc teacher from sophomore year. We have a really good relationship and I still talk to him several times a week; he’s written several summer program recs for me. He can talk about how I’m passionate about the environment and stuff in his rec. I’ll also have him again next year for AP Computer Science.
  2. AP Physics teacher (this year). I’ll have him again next year if I get into AP Physics C, and he really wanted me to take the course. We often talk about politics and he’s a really nice person; he wrote me two summer program recs and personally called me up once to say that the second one was “a good one.” I struggled in his class first semester, however, barely scraping a 90%, and this semester, I did extremely badly on our project so I have to work to bring my grade back up to an A.
  3. AP Calculus teacher from this year. He has very specific requirements for students who want to ask him for recs, and I met them, so that’s a miracle in and of itself. He wrote me a rec for one summer program already. My calculus project was one of the best ones in his class, and I constantly participate. He once asked me if I wanted to be a math major because I was the only one in the class to get a question on a quiz correct. However, second semester he introduced homework for extra credit… and I didn’t do any of it, so I don’t know his feelings about me anymore.
  4. Honors English teacher from this year. I’m a part of a club she runs (one that is very active) and she likes me a lot. She’s also the only humanities teacher I’ve connected with that I’ve kept in contact with (probably should have kept up those relationships with my sophomore teachers). However, her recommendation comes with two exceptions: she doesn’t write recommendation letters for Early Action (oops I’m applying EA to Stanford) and she doesn’t write recommendation letters for any classes outside of Common App (aka MIT).

Supplemental:
I can get a supplemental rec from my seventh grade English teacher, with whom I now run a program at the local middle school. She remains one of my favorite teachers, and I think she can definitely speak about how I helped the program grow a lot and grew as a person while doing so.
However, if I get into any summer programs, they all provide recommendation letters from research advisors, so I think I might want to take that, particularly since I’m applying to STEM schools…

What should I do?

@tonystarkofwinterfell I would suggest your pre calc teacher, your physics teacher, and/or your 7th grade English teacher. Definitely your 7th grade, but not as a teacher rec letter, but like a character reference or additional letter.

@musiclover131 yeah, it’ll be my additional rec if I ask for it. That’s what I was thinking too–thanks!

Oops I just found out that Harvey Mudd and MIT require teacher recommendations from a humanities teacher… I don’t know how this is going to work. I really, really don’t want to ask my history teacher, because while I participate in her class, I don’t like her very much/don’t know her well as a person and I feel like it’ll be detrimental to the rest of my application to have her write a recommendation.

@tonystarkofwinterfell i think you should definitely ask your physics teacher since youll have him for two years and he seems to really like you, although you arent excelling in the class. admission officers want to see what your personality is like to see how you would fit in with the school, not necessarily how well you do in class since they can easily see this on your transcript. as for humanities, im actually facing a similar dilemma because i talk to STEM teachers way more, but i would ask your english teacher for rd common app colleges (not another STEM teacher). and in the end you will need a humanities teacher for mit and harvey mudd, so choose the teacher you think knows you best. even if its subpar its better than having a worse teacher do it

I’ve been stressing about recommendations too! Although I’m a science major, I think I’m going to get a rec from my sophomore/junior calc teacher, by sophomore world history teacher, and my current research supervisor. I haven’t really established a relationship with any of my science teachers, as I tend to work pretty independently and be pretty uninvolved in their classes (which is still the case with calc, but I’ve had my calc teacher for 2 years and I’m like one of the best in his classes and I know he writes good recs in general so it’s different). Thankfully this will also work out if I end up needing both a STEM and humanities teacher.

@coffeeaddicted Yeah, I’m also worried about recommendations. Good news is my Chem Honors/AP Chem teacher told me she’d love to write a recommendation for me, but I’m not sure who I’d want for a second (is it possible to have 3 teacher recs or not?). I’m not sure if I want to choose my Spanish teacher (who I had for freshman, junior, and will be having for senior year) or someone else…

Asdf I wish my English teacher would do MIT. I can deal with the no EA situation–Stanford is a crapshoot either way–but I don’t want to have to ask my history teacher for MIT :’( In addition to not knowing me well, her grammar… well… sucks… and I don’t know how good her college recs are…

does MIT require different information for the rec letters?

I assume so, since they require you to have one rec from a STEM teacher and one rec from a humanities teacher.

Dang, that’s super inconvenient about MIT… Just trying to make my life harder as a student haha, but I guess it’s worth it to have a shot at going there.

Wait, are we supposed to be asking for recommendations already?
And thanks for telling me about MIT! I didn’t know they needed a recommendation from a humanities teacher.

I’m trying to plan things out early since some teachers at my school have very… specific… requirements (also known as: I should probably start sucking up to my history teacher just in case but I hate her class because she’s so easy & treats us like babies asdf).

@SockandBoots I mean, I guess we could…

I’m struggling with determining who I should ask for my 2nd rec :((

I already know my English teacher will write me one since she asked me to tutor for her next year and she knows of my love for poetry. Since I have her, I feel like I need a STEM teacher for the other one. So it’s either Chem or Math. Technically my Math teacher asked me a few months ago if I would like him to write me one, but I haven’t taken him up on his offer yet just because I’m reluctant. While I’m doing extremely well grade-wise, I don’t participate in his class and he doesn’t know me on a personal level at all. But it’s the same with my Chem teacher. I never participate and she doesn’t know me at all, except I’m doing much worse in her class (I barely got an A last semester).

Alternatively, I could ask my history teacher, as she did agree to write a rec letter for my summer programs, which means she doesn’t think badly of me. But I still don’t participate. Also, like my chem teacher, getting a rec from her is really competitive since apparently those two are great rec-letter writers. And both teachers have a lottery system. Supposedly. Even if I do get selected from the “lottery” (I know that the history teacher also does pull some people aside if she likes them enough to tell them she’ll write a rec letter if they ask), she only does up to 10 on the common app, and I am definitely doing more than that.

I have been a tutor for my freshman biology teacher the past two years, so I am certain I will ask her for a supplemental rec, geared towards my years as a tutor and the growth she has seen in me. Yeah, even though she’s technically STEM, I don’t think that’d be a good STEM 2nd rec. Better off as a third.

I guess worse comes to worse I can ask my Math teacher, but I don’t know how much damage that would do to my application.

I’m in shock… I just got my ACT score back, and I got a 36.

I’m so surprised! The highest I’d gotten on a practice test was a 33!

@eyrar99 that’s great! Congratulations!

@eyrar99 Amazing! Congratulations!!

@eyrar99 OMG That’s amazing!!!

@eyrar99 Bro, that’s amazing!