How come no engineers have taken these courses?

<p>Quantum Electrodynamics(QED)
Quantum Chromodynamics(QCD)</p>

<p>Most of the engineers i have talked to said they have never even heard of these courses. I know these disciplines would be restricted to really electrical and nuclear engineering, but even the EE’s i ask say they didn’t take it.</p>

<p>Whats going on? These seem like pretty standard courses to take for advanced engineers. Maybe the engineers i asked were non advanced engineers?</p>

<p>I’ll also throw in differential geometry just to see if anybody on here has taken anything remoetly similar, i.e lobachevsky geometry, riemann geometry.</p>

<p>Because we’re not physicists. There’s enough junk for us to take, no need to add advanced physics and math to the mix.</p>

<p>They sound like graduate level courses.</p>

<p>also, it doesn’t necessarily mean engineers don’t learn those concepts; they just call them by different names. That sounds like physics terminology. Engineers likely call the classes that cover those topics by a diferent name, if they learn them at all.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’m a EE and I have Kaku’s textbook on QED. Even though my thesis work is in the area of condensed matter physics, I haven’t used any of the content in the book. The stuff really is far removed from what engineers can use at the moment.</p>

<p>Electrodynamics in general is a graduate level topic. Anything quantum will definitely have a lot of theory in it, so its useless for an undergrad engineering major… you will never be asked to solve a problem in quantum electrodynamics in industry, so you aren’t taught how to. </p>

<p>You seem to be interested in the more theoretical parts of physics and mathematics. This, of course, is the realm of mathematicians and physicists. Nevertheless, at the graduate level, the line between mathematicians, physicists, and engineers (especially electrical or chemical) tends to get blurry… but the far-out physicists and mathematicians inhabit own plateaus that are infinitely far removed from any possible practical applications at this point in history.</p>

<p>Those courses have nothing to do with EE. Most Ph.D. physicists don’t take those courses unless they are field theorists.</p>

<p>Those topics are normally covered in second- or third- year graduate physics courses.</p>

<p>There is no reason to study quantum electrodynamics unless you’re interested in applying Feynman diagrams and looking at the exchange of virtual photons. Most graduate students do not need this especially if they are experimentalists. Quantum chromodynamics has even less application.</p>

<p>Those courses sound god awfully boring</p>

<p>At my school, we only had to take physics I & II, however, other topics in physics were taught in engineering classes on a “need to know” basis.</p>

<p>Remember, engineering is more concerned with the application of science than the theory behind it. Especially in highly specialized fields.</p>

<p>If you are a theoretical physicist, they are some of the most interesting courses of all. I’m not particularly interested in subjects like E&M, thermo etc. This is stuff that’s 100 years old. I’m way more interested in the research today and understanding how the universe works.</p>