How Do You Choose Your Doctor/Does Med School and Fellowship Program Matter

In addition, because the people who frequent CC are generally well-educated and upper middle class, I think there is sometimes a lack of awareness of how some physicians treat patients who are not those things. Bedside manner and a doctor’s personality matter (to me anyway) becuase I’ve met physicians whose arrogance leads them to discount some patients more than others.

I do wonder if the gruffness of the best doctor’s docs matter less to people on CC because they are used to being respected and heard in other parts of their lives (due to their profession and education) so they are less sensitive to a physician’s dismissive behavior.

How Do You Choose Your Doctor/Does Med School and Fellowship Program Matter

I actually think that this whole line of questioning is a bit funny given that twice in the last year, upon working with a new provider, the initial notes in my online chart have mentioned where D22 and D24 attend college —they are both at prestigious colleges. Maybe I’m wrong, but I got the distinct impression that the colleges were mentioned by name because the physicians somehow believed that my children’s attendance reflected something surprising or pleasing about me. I’ve also frequently had new providers mention my profession in their notes, along with my affect, mannerisms and once in a while my grooming! The notes are usually complimentary, but it makes me wonder what those notes would say if my affect was unpleasant or my grooming was unprofessional. Would I be treated differently? Once in a couple of years ago, I was in a spectacularly bad mood during a doctor’s visit on the same day that I’d had a huge argument with a good friend. My unhappy demeanor was noted in the chart so I’ve made it a point to be more upbeat or at least less grumpy in subsequent visits with that provider.

All of which makes me wonder if the follow up to the “How Do You Choose Your Doctor/Does Med School and Fellowship Program Matter?” question should be “What does your doctor think of YOUR education and professional status and does that matter in their treatment/judgements about your health care?”

7 Likes

How did you know what was in the notes?

I can read after visit summaries and notes as well as test results in the online portals (MyChart) , which is used by most of my physicians (both primary care and specialists).

3 Likes

I always read the after visit notes in the patient portal for my family members. When I accompany my husband on his regular visits to the oncologist, I wait in the waiting room. He is in remission, not actively being treated, and an adult who can see a doctor by himself. I then read in his doctor’s notes - patient presented alone. It bothers me a little bit, makes my husband seem like he is unloved by his family. However, no need for me to go in, and I guess no need for my husband to say I came with my wife who is in the waiting room.

My better half runs my medical…makes appointment, reads the notes, tells me what stuff us. She’s an internet doctor. Without her…..who the hell knows. She got me the Dr. appointment that led to my diagnosis after the doctor refused to see me because I hadn’t been in for four years for a physical. That led to finding high PSAs - after I agreed to get a physical if they saw me.

She finds all my doctors, etc and my kids in CO and CA - but it always starts with in network…and goes from there (availability usually). We asked a cousin in CA for a rec…no help. Whoever you can get into (that was in So Cal).

As I wrote before, I look at reviews (and bios, but reviews are more important). I also look at their areas of interest.

To be honest, I have seen a series of doctors in some specialties until I find someone with the flexibility I like. My best doctors customize treatments (lower doses for instance) and value my health over liability concerns. I avoid too much medical care. I finally found a cardiologist who doesn’t follow guidelines strictly and prescribes anticoagulation as a “pill in a pocket” regimen for my infrequent afib. Not only is he well-educated and competent, but he listens.

I had an appointment yesterday and we were both at home in the snow. His 4 year old daughter climbed on his lap eating marshmallows and he just asked if it was okay with me. He even put his bluetooth in her ear so I could talk to her. Nice to know my doctor is a great father in addition to being a great physician. It translates into how he treats patients.

2 Likes

This should go on the learned something new thread, but I’ve never noticed the notes part on the MyChart visits. As I’ve mentioned before, nobody in town uses anything digital, but our out-of-town colonoscopy doctor, the ortho, and the cancer doctors do.

I did a quick scan of maybe half a dozen of H’s visits and nowhere do any of the doctors mention his education, his mood, nor if I was there or not. I always am with him with these kinds of doctor visits.

I will continue to monitor this stuff from now on though! I know at some point in my life, a doctor has asked what I do. I know because they usually show a shock of surprise when I say engineer. But, it is rare that I am asked. I always have to write it 10x in the mass of initial paperwork, but considering the doctors never even know why I’m there when they walk in (despite writing that 10x and telling 10 different people), I highly doubt they take note of that.

The visit notes typically start with a description of the patient - age, gender, work status, etc. Sometimes in a conversational tone - The 66 year old retired man presented …

I read those too, but never see personal notes? Maybe they don’t make any. BTW, I do glance at where they went to Med School but search for board certifications as well.

Board certification [BC] is important. (Or board eligible [BE] for recently graduated physicians since sometimes fresh-from-residency doctors need to have 1-3 years of case files before taking their board exam.)

Often insurance companies won’t pay for visits with physician who aren’t BC or BE.

1 Like

Yes, that is how almost all of mine start. And I have liked my encounters with the majority of providers. The tone of their notes is positive as are our conversations. It just makes me wonder what if I were seen as a “difficult patient .”

I also wonder if some of the remarks reflect a disconnect based on a new provider’s initial assumptions (because of my demographic) compared to the conversation that we have when we first meet. For example, do they see a single somewhat overweight black mother with a bunch of kids and expect certain characteristics and then they are surprised by my presentation? And is that is part of why I get notes like “Patient is an X years old, non-smoker with a BMI of Y. She presents with concerns about Z issue. She has a pleasant demeanor, makes good eye contact, and is able to explain the details of her health history. She lives in Z. She works as a [insert my profession] at [insert my workplace]. She has one child who is a senior at [prestigious university] and another who is sophomore at [prestigious university] in addition to two children still in secondary school….”

It sounds like my chart is more detailed than many. On the other hand, I have had a lot of health issues and seen a lot of new providers in the last five or so years so I have read a lot of notes lately.

I absolutely consider my appearance when going to a new doctor for the first time. Once we were on vacation and I had to take my daughter to a pediatrician that I found in the yellow pages (or online equivalent, it was very early internet). I made sure we were both dressed nicely.

Doctors are human and it can’t hurt to put your best foot forward.

When caring for my parents with multiple health issues, and it seemed like we were at the ER or a doc almost weekly, I had a notebook where I wrote down everything. I learned all I could about their conditions to the point where I was asked more than once if I was a doctor.

I think it is only natural to react more positively to a patient who is well groomed and articulate.

1 Like

Perhaps it is natural, but I would hope that most doctors provide the same level of care to all patients no matter what their grooming or status is.

6 Likes

Agree.

It’s one thing to assess a patient’s ability to accurately describe their symptoms, participate in a thorough medical history, etc. which sometimes will require evaluating non-verbal “clues”. It’s another to assume that every patient with messy hair and a mismatched outfit is in the throes of a psychotic break.

2 Likes

Oh I absolutely agree. And I imagine most doctors would not take any of that into consideration. Still, I am going to do my part to make sure I get good care.

I think you are apt to get more info if you ask your questions in a respectful way, rather than complaining that the doctor is just looking to make more money off you or to prescribe drugs because they get a kickback etc etc. All stuff I have heard family/friends say at different times.

2 Likes

The first step in diagnosis is observation. Patient notes will usually contain a first impression of the physical appearance, demeanor and other physical factors (such as body odor, grooming, gait, balance, speech, vocabulary level and use).

A patient’s smell may be noted if it’s unusual. Sometimes it will be noted that the patient smells like alcohol, ketones, fruity scents, urine, unwashed bodies–all of these are diagnostic clues to possible health conditions. Race will be noted because different races tend to have different health concerns/issues. Grooming/self-care [or lack thereof] will be note because it can indicate that patient may be unhoused, mentally ill, physically disabled or has other issues.

All of these are clues, not a diagnosis. It’s something that another physician who may read these patient notes needs to know in order to accurately assess and treat a patient.

Social determinants of health.

BTW, if any of the information in your patient notes is wrong or inaccurate, you have the legal right to ask for it to be corrected or removed.

True story: the physician wife of a former colleague of Dh’s ran into him socially after not seeing him for several years at national physics conference. After they shook hands, she asked if he had serious chronic illness. Odd question, but he did. He asked how she knew–she told him his fingernails were “wavy” which is indicator for a major illness. Now she had no idea what his illness was might be, only that something was interfering with his nail growth at the nailbeds. (FWIW, the physician was a general pediatrician, not some sort exotic specialist. And neither DH or I had ever noticed his nails weren’t completely smooth.)

Another true story: a NP I know said she could always tell when a patient had a vaginal yeast infection because she could smell it as soon she entered the exam room. (yeah, gross, but a lot of what physicians deal with is gross.)

@Alqbamine32 I wouldn’t be concerned about noting your education level and profession. The same info is in my chart. (It notes both of my daughters are physicians, that I live with a physician and that I worked as a medical librarian. It’s partly to explain why my descriptions of symptoms/conditions tend to be overly medical/technical which often can raise all sorts of red flags when a new provider sees me for the first time.)

2 Likes

ALL my doctors use a digital portal. The problem is they ALL use different ones so I have to log into each one separately. My old PCP ( and hospital system) used MyChart, but it is a different my chart and log in than my dentist. The dentist has access to the other myChart and can get stuff like vaccination records, medications, allergies, but I can’t pull them up on the same system. Newer PCP uses a different system (and just changed to that one from a different one), oncologist uses another one, New retina specialist uses a different one than other retina specialist that I went to exactly once and she ‘couldn’t help me’.’ Oncologist is next to a different hospital system where they refer me to and, yes, the hospital uses a different one and the mammogram radiologist still another one. I don’t even sign up for them anymore.

I also got something called Picnic and they offered me a gift card for signing up with them and they DO gather info from all the doctors, update my vaccinations and medications. They don’t seem to pull every appt but do the major stuff. I find that pretty helpful (and like the gift card every 6 months.

When my daughter was a baby, she was always wearing cute outfits (older mother, waited forever for her, lots of friends who also wanted her to look cute so gave us things). One Saturday she was sick and had to go to the doctor, and it wasn’t her regular doc’s Saturday to be on call. A BOY doctor had to see her! She had on a striped one pieced outfit and mustard colored socks that perfectly matched one of the stripes.

He said ‘her socks match her outfit.’ I asked “Don’t yours?”

1 Like

Do they really do this if you are going to your annual physical? I know they do this on TV shows when making rounds in the hospital, but I usually did into my portal to look around for results and reminded suggestions etc but I don’t think any of my portals (yes too many diff portals) have referenced observations like this? Do they have a Dr only section that hides the notes?

I think the MYChart that my old system used had a standard form for all the docs, PCP and specialists, to use. It always started out with XXX is a __ aged female who presented today for (annual exam; foot pain; bleeding; surgery) and most of it was filled in by a computer. The front pages (they handed them to me at every appt) started with ‘what’s next’ and would list the next appt even if with another doctor or department. Then there would be a ‘today you saw Dr. __’ and that could be WRONG if they gave me to another doctor and I made them correct it several times. Then the notes of today’s vitals, then what the doctor did or recommends. Also attached were all my meds and other info like ‘you may want to see Dr.___’, tests that should be completed, labs. Sometimes it was 8-10 pages long.

The computer filled in my age and took the vitals off what the assts had put in.

Even my dentist sends notes on the treatment for that day.