How Do You Choose Your Doctor/Does Med School and Fellowship Program Matter

They make notes of their observation mostly if you’re new patient, unless there is a change in your statuses.

I had my first Medicare physical last summer. Although I was not a new patient for my PCP, she noted all her observations about me in the note. Maybe because Medicare required it?

I don’t know if there’s separate section for private doctor’s comments. It may depend on what electronic record system they use. There are 500+ different vendors for electric health records (EHS). They are all different and record information differently. (And it drives physicians crazy since any EHS will not interface with a different EHS to share data.)

And some locations still use paper records or old style systems like Microsoft Office products –and then the deities help you– those have to copied and transferred manually. PITA.

Also, after certain period of time, records (electronic and physical) get archived, usually at an offsite location and have to retrieved manually at the offsite location.

Have you watched The Pitt? The Pitt is a pretty good representation of the level of professionalism of an emergency room.

Appearance really isn’t considered unless it’s an indicator of some of the social inequities in healthcare and the patient may require additional services. Like a referral to social services for housing or substance abuse counseling.

Well that is a good point about Medicare because they don’t cover the full physical annual exam like your employer insurance did - they do the basics and “talking to you and asking questions” exam. Unfortunately I have a few chronic diseases that requires 6 mos checkups w/ blood tests but that’s about it for Medicare physical for me but I never see anything except the vitals and the results - no comments. The only MyChart is for my gastrointerologist at a hospital that does my annual endoscopy - I’ll have to poke around that one a little more but the only time I see him is for a procedure and I’m usually already a little goofy before he comes into the procedure room!

I’m not that concerned, but nor do I think that I am being over-sensitive or making up problems where none actually exist. I still contend that because CC skews educated and upper middle class (and I suspect white), there is not a lot of awareness that some (not all) doctors make assumptions based on demographics and stereotypes. These assumptions impact the way that they treat their patients from different socioeconomic circumstances. This is as much as a problem in medicine as any other profession (e.g., banking, teaching, social work). I’m saying that any conversation about how important a doctor’s credentials and schooling should acknowledge that while we may be judging and labeling our doctors based on their prestige, some may also be judging and labeling us.

3 Likes

You were there and so heard the tone of voice and the context, but sometimes such a comment can be a way of hinting “leave the doctoring to the person in the room with a medical degree”.

I agree.

1 Like

When I tested for low bone density, I went to an endocrinologist. I did not like her. She was heavily pushing drugs and I wanted to build up my bones naturally if possible. I read in my portal she wrote “patient refused treatment.” That did not endear me to her any more than my exam already had.

1 Like

My biggest issue with the “visit clinical notes” is when they are inaccurate, often saying the doctor did something that did not occur. This fits with the thread title, as it’s a key reason why I may choose to switch doctors.

For example, my most recent doctor visit was a physical. The patient instructions section of the clinical notes begins by saying the following. Neither of these were discussed during the physical. The NP did not inquire about my diet or exercise regimen during the physical, and did not give any related recommendations. Had the NP inquired, she would have known they aren’t meaningful recommendations for me, as I’ve been exercising far beyond these recommendations for decades.

  • Well balanced, low fat diet discussed and encouraged
  • Regular daily exercise for a minimum of 30 minutes discussed and encouraged

The patient instructions also says things like “Patient encouraged to journal feelings”. This also wasn’t discussed, and I’m not sure why the comment appears, as that is not a standard recommendation for physicals. Maybe it was cut and pasted from notes for a different patient?

In addition to listing recommendations or events that did not occur, my PCP clinical notes always include the word-for-word comment below, in spite of blood tests for vitamin D showing “optimal level” and getting plenty of vitamin D without supplementation.

If there is only 1 vitamin you take it should be vitamin D3. Nearly everyone is vitamin D deficient. I used to check vitamin D routinely but all too frequently insurance companies would not cover it. I generally recommend taking 2,000IU daily of any over-the-counter Vitamin D3 supplement. Many people have been taking as much as 5000 IU daily to help boost immune support.

The good part about clinical notes is they exhaustively include everything that was done during the visit, including line by line the results of every test/check. My experience is they never exclude anything that was done, but may include things that were not done. I’ve also seen charging insurance for procedures that were not done and adding supporting comments in notes.

I asked my PCP about tests that the oncologist had done in Sept, that she wanted to do in Dec (but lab was closed so delayed to Jan and a new insurer), that she wants to do again in March and of course back to oncologist in March. I asked if they couldn’t coordinate these as I didn’t want to be billed for ANY of them. PCP said that the only one she they would balk at was vitamin D levels. Only one doc ever told me how much to take (2000 IU) and no one else ever said what level to take. 5000 IU are actually cheaper than 2000, so I asked if I could take that. NO!

My levels are fine but I do take it every day.

I wonder if this is boilerplate inserted by the digital record program and the doc just pushes a button to enter the sea of text. On most of my doctor visits (primary care, dermatologist, after a colonoscopy) when I read the after-visit summary it often includes mention of conversations we never had. Pretty much an account of an “ideal” visit.

Seems like insurance fraud is a good reason to change providers. Also, a provider engaging in insurance fraud may recommend procedures that are not really of value (or of negative value) to you in order to run up the insurance reimbursements.

2 Likes

Just checked MyChart notes from my recent visit and it all looked very detailed and accurate. There wasn’t a lot of personal info beyond medical:

General: well-appearing, alert, no acute distress (Yay, I appear well, whew.)

Social History Narrative
Lives with husband.
Pt is retired.

#SH - traveling to New Zealand and Australia (I think that’s more Social History?)

And this - low bone mass with elevated FRAX (declines bisphosphonates).( Very polite term compared to refused treatment!)

No mention in the notes of how i told her I had researched the education and medical training background of both my new podiatrist and ophthalmologist- or that I knew her background!

1 Like

My last medical visit summary just listed the Rx I’m taking and scheduled me for the-check in August. Didn’t mention any of the things we discussed nor the forms my md signed so I can fly with my O2 in May/June. It also didn’t mention that I’ve had no flare ups in my condition since starting the biologics in 11/2024 compared to 3 flare ups in 2023.

My UCSF docs do much more thorough notes about our conversation and my condition and topics discussed. Maybe they are better reimbursed as they have better medical coders?

My internist also did a more accurate & comprehensive summary of my visit, as did H’s internist and geriatrician.

I have seen stuff on these visit notes that were clearly copied and pasted from a boilerplate., that they insert into the notes for every visit when patient is a certain age, etc.

2 Likes

Doctors have to document when a patient declines suggested treatment due to liability. I think “decline” is a better word than “refuse.”

1 Like

Oh I can imagine this! However, this was mostly conveying my dad’s T1D levels and the various changes his endocrinologist had to keep making to his bolus and basal insulin. After a TBI he could no longer be trusted to manage his diabetes so I did his injections 4 times a day for weeks until we could find skilled nurses.

I also had to convey my mom’s history of getting Fifth disease as an adult which led to vascular issues which led to an aortic aneurysm and then later a Type B dissection which she survived thanks to a wonderful vascular surgeon who found a stent large enough. Plus recurring a fib. She had a complicated medical history for sure.

@surfcity at 23 my kid with T1D had a severe TBI after being hit in the cerebellum by a car. Since she was unconscious, they had no written permission for me to manage and it was a nightmare: 29 to 400 back and forth. I wrote a detailed, authoritative (I think) letter basically about what they were doing wrong (for example pump is to .025, they only had one unit syringes) and at the end simply said “This is one of the top hospitals in the world.” I didn’t spell out the implications. They then let me manage. She had pneumonia in the ICU and a blood sugar of 400 sure wasn’t helping.

Like your dad, she was not able to manage blood sugars for months. To manage her, I slept on the couch in the ICU and the inpatient rehab, and then on floor in her room in her apartment and got up overnight- for 9 months.

What a nightmare. I would not trust anyone with this care. The neuro ICU at a major hospital had never had a T1D patient and had no idea how to manage, a fact that was admitted by the endo dept. there. In fact, when my kid returned to have coils put in her brain, after much preparation of staff by me about reconnecting the pump, she came up to the ICU very high. When I asked if she had been reconnected the nurse informed me “Oh, she only needs insulin when she eats.” Everyone knows type 2 but do any of these folks even know T1D is totally different?

CGM’s sure are helping these days but not sure what hospitals are now doing in terms of allowing a pump and CGM. Sorry you had that experience. Hope the skilled nurses knew something about the disease.

It is more than appropriate to take charge with management of T1D. Even endos don’t know the particular individual and everyone is different. I’ll stop when they add more than 15 minutes on T1D to medical training.

1 Like

Agree, it is very scary. In my situation my dad was in his 80s and there are very few people of that age who have T1D with no complications. He was his doctor’s oldest patient by far. So assisted living places don’t routinely see a lot of patients with this.

One night I had to run over there in the middle of the night because the RN had accidentally given him bolus insulin at night, instead of the long acting. So we had to keep waking him up and feeding him to keep his blood sugar from plummeting. To her credit, she realized her mistake and knew it was bad. If she had just ignored it I am certain he would have died.

WHen he had his TBI, he was wearing a pump and the nurses on the neuro floor were not familiar with how to manage that. While every patient is different and every patient may have different doses etc it would have been nice for them to have the general knowledge that “hey this guy needs insulin before every meal and he needs his blood sugar tested multiple times a day. And if his blood sugar is 40 for the love of god give him some orange juice!”

1 Like

We lay people are expected to learn the pump. It isn’t that hard. I don’t get it. Providers are scared of insulin and rightly so. So they run everyone high and don’t learn how to manage. Problem is, any infection or any health issue really is worsened by highs.

One more: 15 years ago a top children’s hospital got the decimal point wrong. I had insisted that I be consulted before any insulin. They came in at 1am and wanted to give 8 units instead of 0.8. The nurses used a marker to make a darker decimal point so it was basically covered up. Hospitals are scary for T1D’s.

We have great doctors and are by no means bitter against medicine in general. But noone with T1D who is sick should be alone in the hospital .

ps Back on topic: I always like a doctor who says “I don’t know.” One orthopedist said to us “I know a lot about knees, but nothing about diabetes.” We appreciated that.

Sending hugs. You are a phenomenal advocate!

Adding to your point about doctors with a modicum of humility– I finally got an appointment with the recognized “Gynecological cancer expert” in my area. She looked at all the previous scans, bloodwork, did a physical exam, then came back after the transvag ultrasound and said ‘I have no idea what this is. But I guarantee you it’s not cancer. If it were me- I’d do nothing” and walked out of the exam room.

And 15 years later- whatever “this was” growing has now apparently disappeared on its own (undetectable on ultrasound, physical exam, etc.) and in fact- I did nothing! I was grateful she didn’t try to come up with a plausible sounding reason to operate!!!

Everyone concedes her bedside manner is a C minus but her medical knowledge is A+. Works for me….