How has the president done in his first year of office?

<p>

</p>

<p>Do we have the right to decide if another person’s life is worth living? I think we don’t, but Ii we do, then parents should also be allowed to kill their older children if they consider their life bad enough.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’m fully aware of your definitions. So much so that I even put a note in my last post to clarify. Did you read it? When I use the term “human” in this debate, I am not using it in the biological sense. I am using it to mean “A member of the species known as people, who are considered to be inherently sacred and to have certain rights that are inherent to its nature.”</p>

<p>If you don’t agree that such a creature exists, then you believe that all rights are granted by the rest of humanity for the convienence of humanity as a whole. If that is your belief, then you shouldn’t have a moral problem with abortion, but you shouldn’t have a moral problem with euthanasia or infanticide either. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Is there any difference between “subhuman” and “pre-person” if the net result of both is that the creature is considered to be simply a bundle of cells to be put down if that is convienent to the rest of society? </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I think you are probably intelligent enough to figure out what I mean when I use a term like “human”. If not, then refer to my explanation above. If you have a better term that fits my definition, tell me and I’ll use it to avoid confusion.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>No, you can’t. You name things by definition, then you use logic to prove facts about them. So first we define “orange” as “a citrus fruit, usually yellow in color, with a soft, fleshy interior and a tough, leathery skin, that grows on a fairly small, smooth skinned tree… etc”</p>

<p>But if I want to prove something about oranges, like say “oranges can cure colds,” then I would not be able to simply add “and cures colds” to the definition. If I did, then my opponent would simply say “then all those fruits you have must not be oranges, since they don’t cure colds.” To prove my point I would need to show evidence that oranges do indeed cure colds.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Ok, lol. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>One of the clumps of cells is a human being, by my position, and the other is a part of a human being vital to that being’s survival. In both cases a human being is destroyed, if my position is true. What we are arguing about is whether that is the case.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I believe that a person is any living member of the species homo sapiens, being unique from all other members of that species, from the moment they first begin to exist, which would be the moment of conception.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>A chunk of flesh has the same DNA and the person it came from and is not a unique being. As for a braindead person, that is something that was a person. The question is whether it is still “living”, and I am not an expert on that subject.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I do consider science without relevant evidence to be arbitrary, and in fact not science. But the key difference between the preemie/newborn/infant/toddler/child/etc distinction and the embryo/person distinction is that none of the former distinctions have a bearing on the morality of killing or harming the person, but only on what tasks we consider them capable of. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>That’s right. Your liver is not a person because it is a part of you, sharing your DNA and characteristics. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Maybe she would. That’s not what I’m arguing about, as I said before. If this debate is only about whether a mother’s right to self defense justifies her killing another human being, I nwill consider you a far more reasonable person. But we must first agree that an embryo is human before that argument has any meaning.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>As I said, an embryo is different from a liver or a skin cell in that it is a unique instance of humanity, having it’s own DNA and characteristics.</p>

<p>PS: Before you go off half-cocked, I am aware that identical twins exist. However I don’t think anyone would argue that even identical twins are uniquely human. Even if you did, that relationship has nothing to do with the relationship of mother and child.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Because we also think it is wrong to be cruel to animals. It’s not the same issue.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>An embryo is a unique instance of the human race. It just happens to be less developed. An unfertilized egg cell is simply the raw materials from which a human can be made.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>This is my position:</p>

<p>Your liver is a part of you. You have human rights. It doesn’t, in itself. An egg or sperm cell is only half of a human. Once joined into an embryo, with unique characteristics, they are a human with human rights. If a woman accidentally miscarries, then she isn’t resposible. If she purposefully miscarries, that is no different from an abortion in any way I see.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I disagree that healthcare is a birthright. I think at some point people are responsible for their own choices, and some of those choices involve taking risks, and they should not ask others to bear those risks unless the others so desire.</p>

<p>But that is beside the point. If enough Americans want to share each others health risks, then so be it. But bring everything out on the table an make SURE the people want it before jamming it down our throats. As for the “if you’re happy you can keep it” lie: I have read the bill, or at least the part that applies here. I am happy with my insurance. If the bill as written passes, my insurance will become illegal. Case proved. If my own healthcare were let alone, and the rest of Americans wanted something different, then I would be more than happy for them to get it.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Hating people never fixed anything.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Both of you are beating up straw men. And that’s a repeat offense for one of you…</p>

<p>MM, you have MUCH too much time on your hands.</p>

<p>^Lol, yes. but this doesn’t take much time, I have it open in another window while I do other real time wasting things.</p>

<p>And FWIW, when people argue that you should just give up babies to be adopted- people ARE arguing that babies should be adopted. It’s PERFECTLY reasonable for me to talk about what ACTUALLY happens to these foster care kids.</p>

<p>^ I never said you weren’t. The plight of kids who grow up without a loving family is a major problem. But not a problem caused by the pro-life movement.</p>

<p>^ Caused by the pro-life movement no… But the pro-life movement certainly doesn’t help it, you could go as far as saying that they do contribute to it.</p>

<p>An embryo is not a human, it’s a cluster of cells. If anything it’s closer to cancer, which is also a cluster of cells. I have no problem killing embryos. I do have a problem with killing fetuses/babies BUT, it all depends on the mother/father. Certain situations call for certain measures. </p>

<p>On topic, I think he’s done well so far. Better than other previous people anyways…
Give him time, don’t judge too quickly and perhaps things will work out in the end!</p>

<p>^Cancer is a cluster of damaged cells from the victim. An embryo is a cluster of cells belonging to a unique induvidual of the human race.</p>

<p>^You’re still posting here?</p>

<p>^Yup. .</p>

<p>why?Your arguement has been refuted so many times. Just leave and end it already.</p>

<p>^ My argument, that there is no real distinction between killing an embryo and killing a 2 year old baby, has hardly been addressed, not to mention refuted. Except for applicannot, most of the people here are arguing about where the line should be drawn, and not why. I think that the decision to abort an embryo sometimes has to be made, but is just as weighty as deciding to kill a 2 year old and can’t be whitewashed with political talk.</p>

<p>Can we let this thread die? Once again, MM, you want to argue this crap go to the POLITICS section.</p>