<p>My apologies to POS and Derek Duplessey. You also know about government.</p>
<p>Anyone who thinks that, after threatening war with Afghanistan in July, 2001, Bush just went in there to flex his muscle is naive. Afghanistan and Iraq have made some people very very rich.</p>
<p>Ignorance of government by students who have gotten into college is sad. If you want a bill passed in Congress, who are you going to go to?</p>
<p>So basically, you condone a war for a show of power? I’m curious to hear your reasons. Now, let’s pretend that this is justifiable–there are many more ways to show power than sacrifice so many innocent lives and global political stability.</p>
<p>Besides, isn’t boosting one’s economy a show of power as well?</p>
<p>Reiterating;
CollegeConfidential is not the place to talk about politics. If you want to debate the Iraq and Afghan wars, please find a different venue</p>
<p>I’m not saying that Iraq was good (I was against it from the start) but honestly Afghanistan was necessary. People WERE training there to attack the US (and they did kill over 3,000 people) and if that isn’t justification for military action I don’t know what is. I’m sorry Barbara Lee didn’t feel that way but at least she was right on Iraq.</p>
<p>I also have a problem with your sophist arguments which while true (no afghans attacked us on 9/11) are truly misleading. I hope you don’t actually believe them. While no afghans attacked us people were using afghanistan to train to attack the US (with the blessing of the afghan gov. at the time).</p>
<p>If the United States had waited 6 months, Lebanon would’ve been an easy target. If one doesn’t recall (not to be pedantic, but so everyone is on the same page), Lebanon and Israel were engaged in combat. Not only would Lebanon have been easy to crush militarily, occupy, and claim victory, it wouldn’t have thrown the Sunni and Shi’ite balance in the Middle East between Iran and Iraq off.</p>
<p>Afghanistan housed the Taliban. It’s always hard to pinpoint where to attack terrorists, due to the fact that they have no organized location to attack, but Afghanistan was as good as it would get to crushing them (which pretty much has been done, minus a few pockets in Pakistan). Hence, in my opinion, that was justifiable.</p>
<p>Just a note now, I am willing to respect arguments that are both believable and professional. The second this devolves to ad hominems, there is nothing I need to talk to you about.</p>
<p>fiesta of fire: I can respect your opinion, but I rather think you have too much of the CNN version of the news. I don’t get my news from just CNN and I don’t believe that violence can solve anything–even though history proves this point again and again, this is only my belief. </p>
<p>In respect to some ppl on this thread, I will refrain from going any further. I tend to get too passionate when discussing politics and can a bit nasty </p>
<p>Perhaps if we ever meet, we’ll discuss. If not, then oh well. I find it much easier to control myself when I’m looking at a face rather than the computer screen.</p>
<p>I don’t watch CNN. They make half-assed attempts to call themselves fair and unbiased by giving rodeo clowns like Glenn Beck a show and calling that a-okay. I’m much more a fan of Huffingtonpost.com (it has a little liberal bias), realclearpolitics.com, and discussing it with others about it.</p>
<p>And I would be happy to meet, one of my passions is discussing how the world is functioning right now, it’s one of the reasons I chose Berkeley - it has a major that lets me balance that with my other love, Economics, together.</p>
<p>haha I go on realclearpolitics.com too occasionally. Never read from Huffingtonpost (although I do listen to NPR :)). When I can, I get foreign news (although it can get really difficult at times), not American/American endorsed news, as well as stuff like NYT (although I’m really growing to dislike it) so I can get multiple perspectives on things. </p>
<p>Yes, definitely. What is your major btw? I signed up for Political Economy of Industrialized Society but might change that to Econ + poli sci (minor) or create my own International Affairs major.</p>