How motivated are cal students?

<p>Not everyone’s ultimate goal is money but I was under the impression that most want to be super successful someday in the future. Seeing all the MCB competition and competition for grades and whatnot, you’d think students here are extremely motivated to achieve their goals. I’m wondering how many of you actually care to be obscenely wealthy or successful in the future.</p>

<p>Of the people I’ve talked to, I’m surprised they don’t always shoot for the best and most amazing opportunities. Sure there are external factors at work but I’m surprised when a cal grad goes to SF state grad school when they could be aiming for Harvard.</p>

<p>I’m shooting for the stars here and I haven’t quite met anyone with the same thirst for success.</p>

<p>Anecdotal, but my friends who go to Berkeley don’t really have the mindset of “shooting for the stars”. They figure that only getting out to Mars will give them a comfortable enough life, and it will require a lot less work.</p>

<p>I think I’m pretty motivated, but not so much for wealth and success. I’m motivated to get a job that I’ll love (field zoologist) and just to make a comfortable living.</p>

<p>Haas investment banking. Nuff said</p>

<p>It’s because Berkeley pretty much de-motivates you when you get counselors saying Oh you should probably switch majors because I don’t think you’ll get a job as a ________. And then the difficult/weeder courses is another thing that turns people away from their once big dream. Then it just becomes take the easy way out or settle for blah.</p>

<p>The nice thing is if you’re aiming for graduate school rather than professional school, the frustration of weeder courses doesn’t figure much in, because it’s your specialized work that matters most anyway. If you really get good experience and become good at a field, people stop caring what you did in basic classes.</p>

<p>Haas is probably good, and there are lots of majors you can go to law school with that aren’t traditionally overcompetitive. </p>

<p>Cal kind of sucks for premeds in many ways, because there doesn’t seem to be a good way out of the competition…unless perhaps one can take weeder courses elsewhere.</p>

<p>Honestly, battling competitively through weeder courses sounds so boring that I don’t wonder why people give up on it.</p>

<p>@mathboy98-Huh? If you are aiming for grad school, you’ll need to keep your GPA up. That means battling through “weeders.”</p>

<p>I have no idea how motivated people are because I have no opportunities to gauge other people’s abilities. I can’t tell you who in my lectures or discussions are smart, or who works hard, or anything like that.</p>

<p>cal is a big school. statistically, there are bound to be a fair number of slackers, hard workers, geniuses, and morons. the question of how motivated are cal students is vague because there’s so many of them. it really depends on which category you fall in, and which circles you hang out in.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Getting into grad school requires a substantial amount of research. An applicant’s GPA is almost secondary to the impact or extent of his/her research projects.</p>

<p>^^ Correct exactly, and further, I think it’s an unwritten rule that your upper division GPA is what really matters.</p>

<p>It’s in the case where GPA is computed through a streamlined curriculum involving plenty of “weeders,” not in the much more customized and research-driven graduate school process, that it really becomes an issue.</p>

<p>I’m under the impression that a lot of really ambitious people are quite good at hiding it. I’ve been shocked a few times by people who I thought were super chill but were actually sharks and/or academic gods lolz</p>

<p>RedSoldier is correct. Most academic superstars tend to understate their abilities.</p>

<p>@mathboy98-Research experience is very important for science grad admissions, but you will need above a 3.00 to even apply for graduate school in most cases. You should also keep in mind that grad schools are not looking for 3.00 students; it’s just the bare minimum to keep would-be applicants from wasting their time.</p>

<p>How motivated are other Cal students? I completely agree with RedSoldier’s assessment. Many times, I’ve found that the highest-achieving students in my classes are the party animals or the chill types who seem like complete slackers; transfer students as well are particularly motivated. It’s the over-stressed students who freak about every test and talk about studying 24/7 who seem to do worst academically - but that’s probably the reason they’re over-stressed in the first place.</p>

<p>I know I’m in the minority here, but I don’t understand all the complaints about lower-div “weeders.” I actually thought taking lower-div math, physics, and chemistry was interesting and intellectually stimulating - sometimes even more interesting than my upper-divs. Some of my upper-div classes were pretty disorganized and in topics so new that you had to wonder whether your professor was just making all his lectures up. At least lower-div classes taught ideas that were old enough to now be generally accepted and not challenged (e.g. physics, the laws of thermodynamics are already in place). But that’s the trade-off you get for being on the cutting edge of research here at Berkeley!</p>

<p>Weeders don’t necessarily have harsher curves if you’re getting at least a B, though. The main difference seems to be that C/D/F grades are much less common in UD classes while they are not an impossibility in an LD class. I don’t see “weeders” hurting good students so much as, well, weeding out those who just don’t get it either because they don’t get the material or because they don’t get how they should study. I personally am not aware of anyone who finds UD classes to be easier (some UD classes have been harder, work-wise, grade-wise, and of course content-wise).</p>

<p>I mean, we’re talking about a 3.0 baseline here, a number lower than the purported 3.25 campus average, and still about or below the average for engineering. Weeders don’t affect students above this baseline so much as they can hurt and discourage students who are below the line. While they might receive a B- in an UD course, they might get a C- in a LD one. I can see how poor performance in a weeder might be demoralizing and indirectly affect one’s UD performance… but these are not the students usually destined for graduate work in that field. So with respect to grad school I don’t really see the problem. (I still think it’s crummy to discourage students with D’s or F’s since it might affect their job prospects and more importantly their self-confidence to do well in the future.)</p>

<p>I was going through the average GPA for ‘good’ grad schools. And almost all of them were in the 3.8-4.0 region. I think doing poorly in weeders and lower division would put you at a big disadvantage no matter how much research experience you have.</p>

<p>How do you quantify motivation?</p>

<p>

Of course it does, even in very research-driven majors. I have seen multiple cases where applicants had less than great overall GPAs but still got into top grad programs, but all of them had 3.9ish in-major GPAs.</p>

<p>But still… how many students pull straight A’s in UD classes but don’t do well in weeder classes? It’s certainly possible that someone might score below par in a weeder because it happens to be a class outside of their focus (say, physics for a BioE major) but I don’t think that weeders greatly affect the students on the higher end. If you’ve looked at the grade distributions for LD classes vs. UD ones, you’ll see that they usually are quite similar with one main exception: the LD classes have the UD curve plus D’s and F’s tacked onto the end. If you’re a candidate for a good grad school that demands an all-too-perfect application, you probably won’t be swimming in these waters anyway. Of course weeders do hurt the students who get these poor grades - I’m just saying that there is little overlap between that group and the group of students who get 3.8, 3.9+ UD grades (more likely to be top grad school candidates, to generalize).</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>OK, I quoted myself so this discussion is very clear. Let me explain why there should be no concern that what I said is either misleading or untrue. I’m saying that if one isn’t a fan of the setting of weeders, then it’s not a big deal to try to coast through them and look to fight your real battle later. The reason is that if you are of the caliber to do well in the upper level, you realistically will end up with a high GPA. It shouldn’t be that hard to do well at the lower level either, but I understand learning nitty gritty points may be boring, and if a prof expects you to do it, you can probably take it a little easy. Most of my acquaintances did through the maths/physics lower division stuff, and funnily generally got A’s anyway. </p>

<p>My point was in response to Batman, that the weeder courses should never be a way of shooting one’s dream away, unless one is truly underprepared for the upper division, in which case the success chance is low anyway.</p>

<p>In line with what bsd says, I know of maths graduate students here who had 3.5-ish overall GPA’s, just very strong, generally perfect GPAs where it counts. Remember that getting a grade is a function of ability and work, and all I’m saying is you don’t have to put in the work if it’s in extraneous stuff that doesn’t matter much to you. The ability has to be there anyway.</p>

<p>To be realistic here, I’m talking about people who can get A’s if they try, and may be turned off by weeder class material; I know of people in my major who just don’t care about the lower div material much, for instance. Having a B or so in the lower division but then doing very well when it counts should keep you very competitive for the topmost programs, after which research and independent work is what should make the cut. </p>

<p>If you’re getting C’s, D’s and F’s of any kind, and you didn’t have some external concern like a medical issue, honestly there’s an issue more fundamental than battling weeders. Even EECS centers the GPA mean so that it’s not conducive to getting C’s unless you really didn’t get what was going on at all.</p>

<p>Motivation to do what? To get into a prestigious graduate or professional school?</p>

<p>Well, I plan on getting a master’s in nursing so I can, hopefully (after years of practice in the US), work as a nurse practitioner or a nurse midwife abroad for an international humanitarian organization (like Doctors Without Borders). For some careers, like nursing, it doesn’t matter where you get your degree from-- so as long as you have a license to practice. </p>

<p>From nursing graduate school forums, I gather that SF State actually has a lower acceptance rate than more prestigious schools like Columbia, Georgetown, and UPenn (anywhere between 5%-15%) since the in-state tuition attracts an insane amount of eligible CA applicants.</p>

<p>I’m not going to lie, somehow Cal has made me less motivated, academic/careerwise. I have no idea what happened, but in high school I was wildly ambitious and extremely disciplined, but then along came college (maybe it’s not Cal’s fault in particular), I just don’t care too much about getting straight A’s anymore. And somehow, I’m okay with it… yeah I sound insane.</p>