How Much Do You think You Need to Retire? What Age Will You/Spouse Retire? General Retirement Issues (Part 2)

At the risk of possibly asking a dumb question…when I am eligible for Medicare, can I sign up for private insurance as a supplement (like employer retirement insurance)? I am assuming you can’t just get private insurance without medicare.

I can only answer for myself- I got medicare the month I turned 65. However there are other reasons- like disability, dependent kids, etc. which have different dates.

A lot of people here can explain it better.

I had federal employee insurance when I retired at 60 and then it became a secondary when I turned 65. In addition to part A, I also took out part B (cost is income based).

You can keep private employer health insurance as a secondary, but it’s not the same as a Medicare supplement.

When DH turned 65, he took Part A. Since he was still employed, he kept his employer plan. Once he retired fully, he went on Medicare fully…no more employer plan.

I am signed up for Medicare, but have a BCBS Medicare Advantage plan that I purchase from my former employer as a former government employee. Someone correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe that with this plan Medicare pays BCBS to take care of my medical needs.

A few times a year I get a notice from Medicare that says “you may be billed $XXX by your medical providers” because Medicare does not cover those services. However, I NEVER get billed (or get billed a tiny amount) because although Medicare doesn’t cover the service, BCBS does.

I get where he’s getting that number. After paying for all the federal, state, FICA taxes, plus housing and private school, there won’t be much left. I don’t think the number is unreasonable at all, for such a high cost of living area. But he certainly made a mistake on the math. You obviously can’t have those kind of expenses when you don’t have enough income. So they need to go back to work or move, that’s not the end of the world.

I understand that people don’t want to move, they feel like their kids need to go to these pricey private schools, they don’t want to change their lives. We were paying similar expenses, but obviously we had to have the income to pay for it. If they really wanted to stay retired, they did a poor job of planning ahead.

2 Likes

What’s funny about the article on the FIRE guy who now has to return to work - wasn’t he giving out advice to folks on how to achieve a FIRE lifestyle? Wondering if his ‘back to work’ plan is more fin advice- and if so, it might be worth rethinking the validity of it!

Going down the rabbit hole of online financial advice forums (including FIRE) can be exhausting!

1 Like

I sure think I wouldn’t take financial advice from him, unless his point is how he messed things up!

2 Likes

It seems pretty clear what happened, since the reduction in income after selling stocks and bonds was entirely predictable. He thought their expenses would fall after their kids went to public school/were homeschooled and his wife insisted that the kids go to private school instead (“we’ve decided to send our kids to private Mandarin immersion school”), which blew up the budget.

This is his passive-aggressive way of getting back at her (“If the school isn’t working, we can always homeschool, or send our kids to public school”).

2 Likes

It’s hard to say who thought private mandarin immersion school was the best decision.

But life with kids is very unpredictable. First it’s mandarin immersion, then it’s private violin lessons and the fencing school. Wait until college admissions with the private counselor.

Has a way of busting the budget.

I think that when you think you can retire in your 30’s, you haven’t really thought out the whole plan. It feels to me a very selfish idea, and not completely thinking out what expectations you have for your kids.

It’s much easier for us to make those retirement plans once the kids were launched. We’ve already paid for the expensive musical instrument :wink:

6 Likes

Absolutely agree that being an empty nest/having kids launched helps make retirement planning easier w/o some of those variable outgoing expenses.

Hanging one’s hat on retiring very early w/o a much bigger nest egg and income stream was IMHO foolish - and he certainly didn’t ‘count on’ a lot of things that you cannot predict with that long of a future ahead of his family. Also it seems he has a pretty high expectation of living standard and constraint on where his family can live. Now a 10 year gap with when he/spouse was last employed.

I wonder if he has reconsidered the learning of mandarin with his children, unless they have family connection with this language. It seems other languages is a higher priority if one is looking at the business world and usefulness. He is in a bubble and a state bubble. He/spouse have a lot to learn and grow with along with the kids. Of course an article like this will not give a full picture.

I believe there are people on this thread that are considering retiring before age 60 or in their early 60’s. Health insurance prior to Medicare can be a cost concern unless they have benefits lined up via being retired military, retired government, or other source of stable health insurance cost. Some can bankroll if one spouse is significantly younger than the older spouse.

Getting to retirement, and enjoying retirement - it all depends on lots of things. Some people will retire younger with a lower household budget - and be quite happy with that.

In the first few years of retirement, one can often see if the spending and the nest egg is ‘stable’ for both short term and long term. We are doing a little tweaking, but are on a good course.

1 Like

Oh, it seems like they were just fine retiring in their thirties if they had just kept their spending at a more sustainable level. They are still bringing in a hefty yearly income from their investments.

I only fault them for not seeing earlier how their spending was going to force them to modify their plans.

I don’t personally see them as selfish. I’m not going to criticize them for faltering and needing to regroup. They obviously did something incredible to be in the position they were originally. Good for them. I wish them well as they navigate their next steps now.

6 Likes

I am talking about if someone should want a private market insurance instead going on Medicare even if it’s a higher cost. Does everyone need to be on Medicare or Medicare advantage.

You are not required to sign up for Medicare.

You can elect to purchase your own insurance. You don’t have to get Medicare.

Medicare part A, hospital insurance, is free for most people. You just need to have paid into the plan for 10 years while working. You should definitely take that no matter what when you are eligible.

2 Likes

Perhaps someone else can explain…if you decide later that you do want Medicare, you will have to show evidence of credible coverage or there is a monthly payment penalty. IIRC, you need to take Part A, and can defer the rest if you have credible coverage.

Hoping someone can clarify this!

1 Like

DH signed up for Medicare A on time, and later went to Medicare B and Medicare D (drug plan). When signing up for the drug plan, the date picked up right when the private insurance plan left off - so no ‘gap’ in coverage – we did on the phone enrollment with this drug plan. With the Medicare B, there was no gap in coverage from private coverage to the Medicare B (actually was a month of overlap). Nothing was later questioned by Medicare.

Best case, you need to sign up for Medicare A in the window of initial eligibility - the late enrollment penalties are spelled out in the “Medicare and You 2024” 131 page book, and of course can see on line as well. Index under Penalty Part A, Part B, Part D. “You usually don’t pay a monthly premium for Part A coverage if you or your spouse paid Medicare taxes while working for a certain amount of time. This is sometimes called premium-free Part A. If your aren’t eligible for premium-free Part A, you may be able to buy it. For more information…”

I think my wording was clumsy. Selfish isn’t exactly what I was trying to convey.

Maybe more not understanding what having children does to a person who’s never had them. That having a family changes how you think and what your priorities are.

Selfish meaning thinking that things are going to turn out how you think they will. Meaning choices aren’t your own anymore and you aren’t in control and will make different decisions than you would have had you not had children.

For example before you have children, you think it will be easy to bend them. They will nap when you want and eat what you do. Then you have kids and they nap when they want or don’t nap sometimes. And one of the kids will eat everything and anything. The next will eat cheese on tortilla chips and plain noodles.

I’m not saying he was wrong. He thought he had enough income streams. Then those pesky little buggers changed all his carefully designed plans.

I think we agree and I think my wording of selfish wasn’t the best choice

6 Likes

Kids can certainly change plans and shift priorities.

Thanks for the clarification regarding “selfish”.

As I understand it, everyone gets Medicare part A (hospitalization) for free, so you should definitely sign up for it.
Part B is optional, and it does cost money, especially if you have a fair amount of monetary assets. You do not have to take part B. However, for each year you choose not to take part B, you will have to pay 10% extra if you decide to take it. We have ver6 good coverage from our federal jobs, and we are considering NOT taking part B.

2 Likes